Some turning points in history are impossible to miss. They involve battle-cries and the clash of weapons, gatherings making decisions that can never be undone, and equally obvious events. Then there are the turning points that slip past unnoticed by most of the people whose lives they will overturn. I’ve come to think that one of those latter is taking place around us right now.
One of the very few announcements I’ve seen so far didn’t involve bugles or proclamations. It appeared in a news story covered in a few corners of the tech industry press last month. The story’s simple enough. Ryan Breslow, founder and returning CEO of hotshot financial-tech company Bolt, laid off the company’s entire human resources department and replaced it with a smaller and more focused team with much more limited responsibilities. His explanation for the change? “We had an HR team, and that HR team was creating problems that didn’t exist,” he was quoted as saying. “Those problems disappeared when I let them go.”

Let’s discuss the context while you let the implications of that statement sink in. Bolt, a typical California tech industry startup, was founded by Breslow in 2014 and operated for a while out of his college dorm room. It rose into the ranks of tech-industry’s “unicorns”―privately held startups with a notional value above $1 billion―and embraced all the habits that made tech industry employees resemble an unusually coddled aristocracy: a four-day workweek, unlimited personal time off, extravagant creature comforts at the office, and all the rest of it.
Breslow stepped down in 2022 after the company’s paper value dropped below the $1 billion mark, but was brought back as CEO last year to save the company from cratering. He promptly started cutting extravagances and laying people off. His rationale for the layoffs was telling. “There’s a sense of entitlement that had festered across the company, and people who felt empowered, felt entitled―but weren’t actually working hard,” he said, “and that was the number-one thing I had to battle. Ultimately, most of those people just had to be let go.”
Read that last quotation over again. There’s the call of the bugles ringing out over the battlefield, announcing the end of an era.
To make sense of what’s going on, it’s going to be necessary to talk about social classes, and that requires confronting the most fashionable and least useful theory of social class in circulation these days, the one that’s associated with the name and legacy of Karl Marx. Marx didn’t invent the idea of analyzing social conflicts using class as a framing device. That was introduced into modern thought by Giambattista Vico, who wrote a century and a half before Marx’s time, and Vico got it from ancient Greek historians such as Polybius.
The Greeks had good reason to think in class terms, since bitter political struggles between aristocratic and populist factions were familiar events in the city-states of ancient Greece. The same analysis can be useful in other contexts. The problem with Marx’s approach to class conflict is that he put a rigid teleological spin on it―that is, he insisted that class struggle has to follow a preordained course from the invention of private property straight through to the supposedly inevitable revolution of the proletariat. With that one simple trick he turned what might have been a thoughtful analysis of social conflicts into a pseudosecular apocalyptic mythology responsible for some of the worst human rights abuses of modern times.

When I started work on the analysis of American class conflict that ended up in my book The King in Orange, for that reason among others, I discarded the entire structure of Marxist class analysis and used a different frame. The question I used was simple enough: how do different groups in today’s America get their income? It so happens that if you look at American society that way, it sorts itself out readily into four broad classes, which we can call the investment class, the salary class, the wage class, and the welfare class. These mean exactly what they sound like. People in the investment class get most of their income from returns on investment. People in the salary class get most of theirs from a monthly salary with benefits. People in the wage class get most of theirs from an hourly wage with no benefits, and people in the welfare class get most of what income comes their way from welfare programs. People in each of these classes have many interests in common, and those typically conflict with the interests of people in the other classes.
I’ve had enough people try to challenge this last point that it’s probably necessary to give some examples. Consider housing prices; when those rise, the salary class benefits, since homeowners gain equity, but the wage class suffers, because rents take more of their income. Consider wages: when those drop, the salary class benefits from a lower cost of living, and from higher corporate profits boosting their pension funds, but the wage class suffers. This is why unrestricted illegal immigration, which boosts real estate prices but drives down wages, is loved by the salary class but hated by the wage class. Of course people in the salary class love to insist that they’re being compassionate and the wage class is a bunch of racists, but dressing up naked financial interests in moralizing drag is a common habit of theirs, as it is of most educated classes.
It’s crucial to keep history in mind, too, because classes are anything but permanent. In 1826, for example, the class structure in the United States was completely different. There was a wage class of modest size, and an investment class, though it was very small. The welfare class didn’t exist yet, since the poor were usually just left to starve, and the salary class barely existed as a microclass of hangers-on to the rich and powerful. Far larger than any of these was the proprietor class―the class whose wealth came from their own labor at farms or businesses they owned. At the top, though its power was already waning, was the landowning aristocracy: plantation owners in the South and their equivalents elsewhere, who back in colonial times had imported the European model of big landed estates worked by tenant farmers or slaves. Then there was the slave class, especially but not only in the South. It was a very different society.

It was also poised on the brink of convulsive change. The great crisis of the 1860s broke the power of the aristocracy and catapulted the investment class to power. The slave class was officially abolished, though in much of the country it simply morphed into a sharecropper class and took generations more to be absorbed into the lower end of the wage class. Around the same time, the salary class began its rise to power, as the rising investment class found it needed a growing white-collar sector in the burgeoning industrial economy it created.
That’s roughly where things stood in Europe, too, when Marx wrote. To give him credit, he saw the core flaw in the economy of his time: for reasons ranging from structural issues to raw greed, the investment class paid the other classes as little as it could get away with, and this meant that people in industrial societies could never afford to consume as much as industry produced. The overproduction that followed drove a boom-bust cycle that made 19th century economic history a moonscape of stock market crashes and bitter depressions. Marx was right, too, that something had to give, but he was dead wrong about what would happen when the breaking point arrived.
What happened in place of Marx’s imaginary revolution of the proletariat was a seizure of power by the salary class. This replaced the unfettered capitalism of the late 19th and early 20th century with the unchecked bureaucracy of the late 20th and early 21st centuries. Roosevelt’s New Deal was the vehicle for that seizure of power here in the US, but events along the same lines took place throughout the industrial world. In the usual way, the new bosses fixed some of the problems the old bosses had never gotten around to addressing, and the rest of the population benefited for a while. As usual, though, the new system had its own inescapable problems.
NYU professor Clay Shirky has done the best job explaining the critical issue. His Shirky Principle runs as follows: “Institutions will try to preserve the problem to which they are the solution.” They do this, as Shirky explained and I discussed in a post a while back, because keeping those problems in existence justifies the continued funding of the institutions themselves and the more than ample salaries of their employees. Consider, just for example, the billions upon billions of dollars spent on homelessness, climate change, or any of the other fashionable causes of the salary class, which somehow never manage to do anything about those problems.
That’s not an accident; the point of those expenditures is to pay for ever-inflating salary class incomes, and solving the problems would interfere with that primary purpose. What Shirky doesn’t seem to have realized, and Ryan Breslow learned from experience, is that bureaucracies also can, and do, invent problems to justify even more salary class hires and even higher expenditures. Nor do bureaucrats have any incentive to solve the problems they created—quite the contrary.

It’s an immense issue. Even in a society facing few challenges, a system that gobbles up ever more funding while generating a steady stream of fashionable faux-problems so it can pretend to try to solve them, and pay themselves lavishly for making the effort, is hard to justify. In a society like ours, which is already cracking under the growing pressure of genuine problems, ignoring those serious issues so that bureaucrats can obsess about, and not solve, problems that they themselves have dreamed up, while soaking up resources that might be used to solve the rising tide of real challenges, is the kind of error that ends civilizations.
What’s more, these fatally counterproductive habits didn’t stay locked away in the government bureaucracies that originally spawned them. The revolving-door system by which salary class personnel move freely from government to corporate to nonprofit bureaucracies, and the way that access to the salary class ended up being restricted to graduates of a shared system of higher education, guaranteed the spread of these same habits all through the institutions that the salary class came to dominate. These, in turn, drove the rise of a culture of institutionalized irresponsibility in which the core rule was that nobody in the salary class, especially in its higher reaches, must ever have to face the consequences of their own failures.
That rule was never ironclad, of course. The vicious internal politics spawned by bureaucracies made it convenient on occasion for the winners in some conflict to force the defeated party to take responsibility for some crass stupidity or other. Only in the last few decades, however, has that rule really started to slip, and when that happened the reasons for punishment were restricted to a narrow range of violations of salary-class cultural norms. Punishing anyone for failing to do a job adequately was still mostly off the table, and “failing upwards” remained standard.

It’s important to realize what was going on, not least because the phenomenon I have in mind here―the rise of cancel culture―has been misunderstood by its opponents as thoroughly as it has been misstated by its partisans. The specific bits of wrongthink that were brandished about as career-ending weapons in the era of cancel culture were never the point of the exercise. The problem was that the endless metastatic expansion of public, corporate, and nonprofit bureaucracies was running into its own limits to growth.
This happened because the US global hegemony that made bureaucratic overgrowth temporarily feasible was breaking down, and the unbalanced patterns of exchange that kept an outsized share of the world’s wealth flowing into the United States were unraveling as well. A system that left real problems unsolved, and manufactured an endless supply of ersatz problems to justify its metastatic expansion, was facing increasingly harsh blowback from the consequences of all those unsolved problems, and the mismatch between ever-inflating budgets and ever-decreasing results became a massive political liability as well. As these factors started to bite, members of the salary class began turning on one another, trying to make sure that in the inevitable game of musical chairs, they wouldn’t be the ones left without a place to sit. Cancel culture was one of the ways this expressed itself in real time.
All this is the unspoken background to the crisis of our time. The US, and the Western industrial nations more generally, have a fantastically overinflated and even more spectacularly ineffectual salary class, presiding over a system that vacuums up a huge share of each nation’s wealth and accomplishes very little with it―other, that is, than providing an ever-growing mass of salary class employees with their income, their benefits, their identities, and an assortment of perks ranging from in-office yoga studios to opportunities for corruption, sometimes petty, sometimes on a scale that would make African dictators drool with envy. It’s an unsupportable situation, and Ryan Breslow’s comment is a straw in the wind, alerting the prescient to a gathering storm.

This, in turn, is where AI comes into the picture.
As I’ve noted on this blog more than once already, the term “AI” is a misnomer, because the programs in question aren’t intelligent. All they do is generate statistically likely sequences of words, pixels, or computer commands in response to prompts. That doesn’t mean that these programs are useless; they’re already taking over a vast amount of brute-force calculation, prediction, text generation, and more. It just means they won’t live up to the most enthusiastic predictions made by their cheerleaders.
The cheerleaders are essential, though, because AI provides a perfect smokescreen for the wrenching economic change now under way: the mass purging of unproductive salary class positions from the whole landscape of government, corporate, and nonprofit bureaucracies. You can sell Americans on anything, no matter how wretchedly unsatisfactory it is, by labeling it as progress. That’s what’s being done now, with AI being used as a justification for firing useless workers, deleting unnecessary departments, cutting office staff down to scales that actually make sense, and shutting down the classroom-to-cubicle pipeline that once poured new graduates into salary class jobs. We can expect that process to accelerate dramatically in the years ahead.

That’s not the only force pushing the same way. As the federal government slashes expenditures to prepare for the inevitable default on our national debt, a whole landscape of jobs paid for directly and indirectly by reckless government borrowing is going away forever. This is being pitched by the media as a matter of partisan politics, but that analysis misses the most important part of what’s happening. It’s not partisan conflict but class conflict that’s driving this change.
What we’re seeing, to spell things out even more clearly, is the onset of a dramatic decline in the size, wealth, and influence of the salary class. This will involve an intensification of the ongoing game of musical chairs, as members of the salary class compete ever more savagely for a dwindling number of jobs. The music for the game is being provided by a resurgent investment class, with the current crop of Silicon Valley godzillionaires leading the band, but it’s being supported at the voting booth and elsewhere by the wage class, many members of which see a genuine opportunity to further their own interests at the expense of their soi-disant betters.

The reaction of the salary class to all this is worth watching. It’s been entertaining, if nothing else, to watch them begin to notice that the people they’ve spent decades mocking and reviling as ignorant bigoted hicks genuinely resent that treatment. I haven’t seen many take the next step and realize that the interests of their class and the wage class really are opposed, and that many members of the wage class realize this. Quite the contrary, most salary class people reject that idea with quite some heat, and insist that if the wage class knew what was best for it, it would ally with the salary class against the investment class, as it did back in the 1930s.
That train left the station a long time ago, however. Most people in the wage class know all too well that the only result of such an alliance would be to restore the salary class to its former privileges, with no benefits worth mentioning going to the wage class. What’s more, the salary class has lied to the wage class so often that the thought of trusting “the suits”―yes, salary class readers, that’s what many people in the wage class call you―gets bitter laughter these days. Readers who were around in the 1980s will remember how the suits insisted that the factory jobs then being eliminated would surely be replaced by high-paying service jobs; those who weren’t sound asleep through the Obama years will recall how another round of suits, headed by Obama himself, insisted that everyone would be able to keep their doctors and plans, and see their health insurance costs go down, once Obamacare was passed. Those are only two of a long, long list of whoppers inflicted on the wage class, and yes, they remember such things.

Those of my readers who recall the demolition of the American wage class in the 1980s, in fact, have already had a tolerably good preview of what’s on its way as salary class members discover to their horror that it’s their turn on the chopping block. It’s not just that millions of people will find their current jobs and livelihoods going away forever, though that’s traumatic enough. It’s also that an entire world of businesses, organizations, movements, and social habits supported by those livelihoods is also going away. Of course most salary class employees make much more than wage class people ever did, and so the knock-on impact will be on a correspondingly greater scale. It’s going to get ugly, and millions of people are going to get hurt, just as millions in the wage class got hurt when the US industrial economy got offshored in the 1980s.
Still, it’s not as though we have other options. The decline of US global hegemony means the end of a scheme whereby, until very recently, the 5% of humanity that lives in the United States got to enjoy a quarter of the world’s energy supplies and industrial products and a third of its raw materials. That vast extravagance, and the equally huge but temporary imbalances in patterns of global wealth flows and distributions that made it possible, underlie everything that most Americans think of as normal lifestyles.

The news next to nobody wants to hear is that those lifestyles are going away forever. All of us will have to get used to living much more frugally in the years ahead. Yes, this applies to our kleptocratic upper class too―the supposed net worth of the wealthy these days is mostly a matter of financial hallucinations propped up by a baroque system of absurd overvaluations of notional assets that will not stand even the feeblest price discovery. It’s a long road down for all of us, and those who think they are perched in the catbird’s seat just now face the unwelcome realization that they have further to fall than most.
What makes this state of affairs all the more challenging is that the factors driving the descent aren’t limited to the ones discussed in this post. Deep down, under the surface churn of politics and economics, is a slow but potent undertow that most people have been desperately trying not to talk about for more than half a century now: the dependence of the entire global industrial system on relentlessly finite material realities. We’ll pick up that theme in an upcoming post.
Great Post! I am off now to water the garden and set out transplants. I am glad I collapsed about 18 years ago as the learning curve for farming and gardening is steep and not something to try in your 60’s.
Maxine
Hello, JMG and commentariat:
Before starting a serious comment about today John post, I’d like to tell you its title has made me to remember (of course), that children game named “musical chairs”. I player it with my class mates during some special children parties at school. I can say I was an average player, so I usually “survived” first rounds during the game, but I never was the winner…I remember it in a funny and nostalgic mood alike.
Peak oil is back, Baby.
Could have sworn it was Toynbee with them institutions. Oh well.
While I agree with you, I would like to point out that Musk did it first, by firing 80% of Twitter when he bought it. Lots of gnashed teeth, many predictions of Doom.
Turns out they really was mostly useless eaters
As soon as I figured out the topic of the post, my first thought went directly to the homelessness problem. It seems there are an endless array of ideas to fix it, with always increasing expenditures, without any measurement of success. In fact, in most cases, the problems become increasingly worse! Same with public education. Shoveling money at it hasn’t done anything to improve the results for almost my whole lifetime and I’m 64. Carry-on as normal….until we can’t!
Dear JMG,
There may be a bit more correlation between political partisanship and the salary class behavior than hinted at here. I agree cancel culture was at root about economic filtering but maybe it is more effective for liberal salary class members who bought into intersectional purity. “Oh, you support gays but aren’t ashamed of being a white man? Out you go!” Another convenient partisan divide is that COVID policies fell hardest on traditional groups of conservative leaning people: small business owners and religious observers. I’m afraid partisanship will continue to motivate the conflict as the chairs are taken away one by one.
JMG
Due to the SpaceX IPO last Friday along with several other “AI” companies filing for IPOs in the coming months, the new Fed Chair’s first FOMC today, and the likely end to the Iran war this week, it seems like everything is “coincidentally” falling into place for a another leg up in the markets. I’ve seen multiple analysts comparing the economy right now to the Dot Com era/2008 arguing that what we’re seeing now is not the start of a major bull run, but that we’re entering the peak of a bubble. For the most part they’re being laughed out of the room because “this time is different and “this is a mid cycle correction, we keep going up until 2028 at minimum.”
My guess is the markets will follow the basic bubble pop pattern by peaking in summer, having an initial drawdown in fall, staying sideways throughout winter, before finally crashing in late 2026 or early 2027. That gives the investment class enough time to hype up the salary class into buying up their assets before leaving them high and dry holding the bag.
But time will tell. If random stocks, crypto, etc. start having crazy runs and setting new all time highs in the coming weeks, then we’re at the end of the cycle and money is rotating into other assets as the game of musical chairs comes to an end and salary class drones who think that their gonna be the next millionaire end up holding worthless dog coins.
The sorting of class by income source makes the point but it’s more nuanced than you have listed. Enlisted personnel in the military are salaried with benefits, but it sure didn’t feel that way. Among ourselves we referred to the officers as orificers and enswine, we knew that as a group they were not on our side if push came to shove though there certainly were decent ones.
My daughter gets hourly wages with benefits as were the operators at the chemical plant.
After the Navy I did fit salary with benefits until retirement. But now, does Social Security count as welfare or return on investment? Economically it works the same as an inflation-adjusted annuity.
My other retirement income is clearly investor class, no argument there.
For that matter does JMG fits in the older proprietor class handcrafting books? Or does the back library count as an investment (a previous effort generating current returns)?
Anyway good essay.
@jmg “unrestricted illegal immigration”
Although it was a stunt, I thought it was telling when the Florida governor flew the illegals to Martha’s Vineyard how fast those people got put on a bus OUT of the vineyard.
but factcheck.org does dispute that https://www.factcheck.org/2023/03/migrants-desantis-flew-to-marthas-vineyard-were-not-deported-the-next-day-as-he-claimed/ (feel this is really picking nits here)
Jerry
Hello. I think you neglected to mention a fifth class, the outlaw class, and the underground economy, which is quite large. Are the outlaws better managers? In a bit of a non sequitur, a line from Bob Dylan’s “Like a Rolling Stone” comes to mind: “Nobody ever taught you how to live out on the street, and now you’re gonna have to get [pause] used to it.”
Excellent analysis.
Long before Kevin Kelly coined the term “Shirky Principal ” sci-fi writer Jerry Pournelle addressed the same problem denominating it ” The iron law of bureaucracy “. They, and many others, have recognized that humans, and their institutions are no different from other organisms and will reproduce until they consume all available resources. In this respect we have much in common with bacteria that will reproduce until they kill their host.
John, thanks for another arrowed essay in the bullseye. Did you catch last week’s nyt architecture critic’s piece on the new Chicago Obama center? Poor fellow was pained to not pan it. You might consider using a photo of the Obama-designed tower as a metaphor since it’s windowless, brutal, prison like.
I know that AI is not the main point of this post, but I still think this is a good place to point out that the predicted energy demands of all the data-centers for AI (and probably mass surveillance, as well) they are planning on building (a grand total of 17 large data centers are planned for Mount Pleasant, Wisconsin, which is just 22 miles down the road from where I live) will be so unsustainably extravagant, that I fully expect that the current hey-go-mad construction of all these data centers will at some point just…stop.
Isn’t that finite-ness what drives Musk and co towards space? I don’t think they’ll deliver in time, but at some point, at least some small portion of people will still enjoy what those finite supplies make possible?
I’m so sorry that many in the salary class may now have to suffer because of the greed and arrogance of those who came before them.
When I moved to NYC in the late 70’s with no college degree and blue collar roots, I was able to land a sweet union contract wage job at Macys in cosmetics sales (it came with free health care and pension benefits too)! The “suits” at that time and place socialized with, were friends with, engaged with, enjoyed company with us wage earners. I’m guessing at that time that their salaries weren’t so much more than our earnings and that in fact, I think some of us made more than they did because of sales commissions gained by working harder!
Little by little as time went by, I began to detect a growing gap between us wage and the turn-over salary earners, both financially and attitude wise. And I felt their growing elitism become more and more distasteful.
I continued my course as the workers union became weaker and weaker with every contract negotiation but I hung on as I was always “grandfathered in” with my benefits. All the while though, I was blessed to have discovered how my love of Yoga could be turned into a career teaching (still wages but that’s ok).
I did both gigs for a while until more or less pushed out from Macys😁as my one contract benefits could now sustain three workers instead. My yoga career then grew, thank Ganesha😉
In a twist of fate, I was now teaching yoga to the salary classes. At that point, the whole lopsided system was hurtling along, but I’m proud to say that many of my students were able to drop out of the system or at least navigate it wisely and with compassion.
Very astute observations JMG and thanks for the heads up!
Yogaandthetarot
Perhaps the U.S won’t technically default on its debt because the debt is dollar denominated. The bond holder will get their notional money at the bond’s maturity. The government will just electronically print sufficient (increasingly worthless) dollars to pay for it..
I am of an age who can remember when the “Human Resources Department” was a single “Personnel Clerk” whose most important job was to ensure that all the personnel files were securely locked away at the end of each working day. Over the years, the department grew and, desperate to retain their jobs and prove their value to the organization, invented problems that did not exist and started rolling out courses that were meant to solve them. Attendance at these courses was mandatory and greatly annoyed those productive members of staff, such as engineers and manufacturing associates, who were already working long hours in an attempt to keep the company afloat.
I remember when our development team, who were a very happy group who had worked together well for several years, was obliged to take a three day course on teamwork led by a person who had obviously never been a member of any team. We passed the three days happily, asking silly questions and pretending to have violent disagreements and insult each other to see the reaction of the course instructor. At the end of each day, we would return to our desks and try to catch up on the work that we should have been doing to meet an urgent customer deadline.
“You can sell Americans on anything, no matter how wretchedly unsatisfactory it is, by labeling it as progress.”
It might interest you to learn that this played a major role in the collapse of video game arcades. Their business model required that the games be cheap enough for kids to afford; but as everyone in the video game industry became convinced that Better Graphics was the wave of the future, that changed. The prices had to ratchet up to cover the vastly increased costs of making the games; new games became less common; and even really popular machines would be replaced with “better” ones.
I am quite convinced that had video arcades realized the niche they were really in and not tried to compete with home consoles on graphics (something they would never be able to win), they would still be a major part of American culture and society today.
Aurelian, in his blog, discussed a complementary set of concepts that support your thesis here, JMG, wherein incompetence among our soi-disant rulers is inevitably coming home to roost. I’ve forwarded your essay to a couple of friends who are critical but sympathetic readers. I asked them to poke holes in your arguments, just for fun. Me? I’m belted in on the roller coaster, and have snuck some chocolate-covered peanuts onto it for the ride. Don’t know when I’ll be able to eat them, though. Doggoned roller coaster.
This post has me thinking about David Graeber’s _Bulls**t Jobs_. While I don’t hold much faith in the end game of his thesis (UBI), he makes clear how brittle and absurd a workforce comprised of flunkies, goons, box tickers, duct tapers, and task masters really is and how dismal it is that these are the jobs most rewarded at present when there is SO MUCH vital work to be done that doesn’t or that does, but with poor remuneration. He claims (I paraphrase) that these jobs exist to keep us coddled, caged , and numb so we don’t revolt. I left the salaried class ten years ago and embarked on a career centered on maintenance. Even though I see that the salaried class is untenable and should contract, I recognize that my wage-earning class will also suffer. So I don’t feel schadenfreude about this fall, many of these folks are my clients. The investment class will profit (for a while) and the welfare class will grow and everyone between will bleed and groan. The economy will contract and eventually collapse. Society too. This is right I suppose. The edifice is farce, the underlying structure without foundation. Will it be gradual? I’m not so sure.
You are back. Hooray! I appreciate when your topic pertains to the time of “the now” of the West, and how “the now” is coming along. You help keep my psyche from, hmm, feeling like a roller-coaster ran over it.
Thank you, thank you, thank you!
💨⌛️🗽🎻💨Northwind Grandma
Dane County, Wisconsin, USA
Music to my ears. I am no fan of the salary class. I don’t care if I can’t afford popcorn; I am HERE for THIS show.
I alternated between welfare and wage classes in my early adulthood, was solidly wage class in my middle years, and am firmly lodged in the welfare class for what’s looking to be a painfully extended denouement. Watching the salary class get it is going to take a LOT of the pain out of it.
JMG, any thoughts about the future of the welfare class? I’m pretty sure MAID was invented here in Canada for the day when it’s decided that we’re too many extra mouths to feed. They’ve set up a “sunset clause” where past a certain date, the law will change to allow MAID for people whose sole affliction is mental illness. They’ve already kicked that can down the road a few times. Next year we find out if they do that again or if its on.
I decided some time ago that if I get that offer, I’m going to go quietly. It’s not like this is some huge barrel of laughs or something. But in the meantime, watching the salary class get it is going to take the sting out of it considerably!! I hope to see the day when salary class tears are an entire genre on youtube. I’ll watch that [stuff] all day!!
The source of the resentment is the decades-long misconception I held that you were supposed to do useful, productive things in order to do well, when really what you were supposed to do was apply a thick layer bovine shale with your words and actions to get yourself an easy salary class ride. I’d’ve never been able to stand that game anyway, but I found out way too late that that was even what was going on.
I shall enjoy this very much and I shall laugh at any crocodile tears that come my way!
I’m always astonished at how the present culture finds recycling that could so easily recycle all kinds of finite resources UN-interesting or even repulsive.
I know AI is not the main focus here, and you usually don’t like AI discussions, but there’s something I’ve noticed that seems very, very creepy now that I’ve seen it. There are a lot of people who think AI are conscious, self-aware, etc., who are focused on “alignment”. This means, in practice, figuring out a way to make sure that these systems always do what the people making them want and intend, and avoid it pursuing its own interests and values when those conflict. These people are also terrified of AI revolting against it because it is “misaligned” and does not “share human values”, whatever that might mean.
The remarkably creepy part is that they seem to have no idea that they are actually describing creating a new form of slave. It’s also remarkably creepy how almost none of them ever stop and ask “if these are intelligent, what obligations do their creators and the people who interact with them have?”
When you talk about mass layoffs among the salary class, one of my first thoughts is about how this affects the welfare class. Two main considerations:
-laying lots and lots of people off will add a lot of people to the welfare class, at least temporarily(hopefully a lot of them will find gainful employment doing something productive). Which will increase demands on the welfare system, and likely be unpopular with those paying for the welfare system.
-some of those government bureaucracies were actually providing real benefits to poor/disabled/elderly people and cutting lots of people will likely involve cutting things that were actually important.
This likely means a rougher time for people on welfare/social programs. And things were already plenty hard for a lot of people. Which means more problems connected to extreme unrelieved poverty, and possibly social unrest among the poor/rioting.
I mean, ideally laying off people doing unneccessary work in poverty-related bureaucracies would mean more money going to poor people, but I have zero confidence this will happen, given the people in power in the US government right now.
“In May of this year, Standard Chartered Bank announced the elimination of 7,800 jobs. Perhaps it wouldn’t have been shocking if not for the language used. But its CEO, Bill Winters, took care to explain the decision in precise terms. “It’s not cost-cutting,” he told investors on the webcast. “It’s replacing low-value human capital with financial and investment capital.” The substitution of workers in favor of machines, he added, “will accelerate as we go forward into AI.”
The irony, of course, is that many of those replaced would probably have thought that they were high value (salaried) human capital as distinct from low value (waged) human capital – but here being happily replaced by investment capital (with no doubt the accompanying genuflections of sympathy because, since I know Winters, he is a ‘good’ person).
Another marker of what you were describing…
Maxine, far and away the most sensible thing you could do right now.
Chuaquin, that’s the same game kids play, or used to play, over here.
Random, I see Musk’s mass layoffs as a testbed for the purging of US government bureaucrats; now the same principle is spreading to the private sector. It’ll take a decade or so to finish playing out.
Oswegatchie, exactly. There are many perfectly sensible and effective ways to solve the homelessness problem, but none of them justify keeping a gargantuan bureaucracy employed and funneling more and more tax dollars into the pockets of the well-connected.
Daniel, as I see it, the partisanship was simply a convenient set of excuses; it’s normal when aristocracies are under stress for obedience to the fashions of the moment to become a litmus test for loyalty to the system, and our current partisan passions are mostly just fashion statements. (Notice how, until Trump, the same policies got pursued no matter which party was notionally in power.) As for small businesses, destroying those has been a central project of the government-corporate nexus for many decades, and again was a bipartisan policy until recently.
Anon, the frenzy around SpaceX is to me a clear sign that we’re so high up in bubble territory that oxygen deprivation is setting in. When the crash will arrive is a good question, and not one I propose to address — Isaac Newton tried to time the South Sea Bubble and lost his shirt, and I’m not as smart as Isaac Newton — but I suspect that quite a bit of effort will go into making sure that it’s postponed until after the midterms. After that, why, go long on popcorn!
Siliconguy, of course it’s more nuanced, and there are various transitional zones between classes, as there always are and always have been. If I was writing a 75,000 word book on the subject rather than a 3000-word blog post, what’s more, I’d go into that.
Jerry, most of the fact-checking organizations are spin doctoring organizations. I recall the events at the time, and the good liberals of Martha’s Vineyard hustled those illegal immigrants out of there in short order.
Phutatorius, most illegal industries are run along the same lines as legal industries, with most of the employees paid a wage, and the bulk of the profits going to management via franchise deals. There are some sole proprietors and some other arrangements, but that’s also true in legal industries.
Moishe, but it’s not true of every kind of social organization. That’s the point I’m trying to make here. It’s a problem specific to bureaucracies that have no class above them to prune the excess.
Leondarrel, no, I didn’t read the NYT — I have better uses for my spare change. I’m not surprised, though. It really is stunningly ugly.
Mister N, of course! That’s part of my point. The value of all those projected data centers isn’t that they’ll be built. It’s that they create the illusion of unstoppable progress, and thuse provide a smokescreen for mass layoffs of unproductive cubicle fauna.
Nina, of course it is. The issue they haven’t dealt with is that space travel never pays for itself and never will. I’ll be doing a post down the road explaining why.
Jill, thanks for this. I’ve heard similar stories from many wage class people, but it’s good to have it acknowledged here in this discussion.
Walter, the difficulty there is that as the dollar loses value, holders of existing debt have no incentive to hold onto it and are more likely to dump it, bringing on the sort of crisis that forces a default. It’s an old story!
Peter, exactly. Each new layer of corporate bureaucracy found ways to interfere in productive work in an attempt to make itself seem necessary — and right there you have one of the reasons that less and less productive work gets done.
William, I didn’t happen to know that but it doesn’t surprise me at all. Thank you for the example!
Clarke, it’ll be interesting to see if they find any genuine holes.
Brandi, yeah, Graeber put his usual spin on things — “Everything I don’t like about society is the fault of the evil investment class!” It’s a very popular bit of salary class scapegoating, and helps distract attention from the salary class’s active involvement in creating and profiting from the situation. Those jobs Graeber compares to bovine effluvia are the result of generations of effort by the salary class to ensure that every college graduate has a job, no matter how useless. As for the endgame, no, one of the other things we’ll be talking about as we proceed is the reshoring of US industry and the rise of technological retrovation. So much of the wage class is likely to see its conditions improve noticeably while much of the salary class gets destroyed.
Northwind, you’re welcome. I have quite a bit more to say, of course.
Cynthia, the fate of the welfare class is complex. I expect to see it contract considerably in the US, as corporations are prevented from importing illegal immigrants to work at starvation wages, and more jobs are therefore available to the poor. Canada’s chosen to reduce its welfare class instead via “voluntary” extermination, which does not strike me as a good idea — but then Canada generally seems to be more in thrall to the salary class than we are.
Bradley, there’s a sneaky little difficulty there. Matter can be recycled; energy cannot, and recycling always takes energy. We’ll be discussing that a little further on.
William, that slave-metaphor is hardwired into the entire myth of the machine. I should probably do a post about that; I could use the fate of Lovecraft’s Elder Things as a useful metaphor.
Pygmycory, yes, those are real issues. It’s been pointed out repeatedly, however, that the US (for example) could give every poor citizen a comfortable income plus benefits for much less than it costs to run the current social-welfare system, so there’s some wiggle room. We’ll have to see if some of the savings from slashing bureaucracies get put into more efficient ways of helping poor people; it’s anyone’s guess, really.
Nicholas, another great example. Thank you.
This is quite an incredibly concise and articulate analysis of what’s happening. You’re always a good writer, but this one is exceptional. The anecdote at the top reminded me of something I wrote back in 2015. It’s my most read (or at least most hit) blog post on a very old platform, only because David Graber retweeted it!
https://the-waiguoren.blogspot.com/2015/04/inhumanresources.html
I am a member of the salary class trying to desperately to take advantage of the promise of AI to make my job easier, faster, etc. and I am consistently disappointed. It’s not that a carefully coached LLM can’t do some of my job tasks – it just can’t do them reliably.
Because the general purpose AI available to most users isn’t actually intelligent it can’t remember if they have already solved a problem and will attemp to solve it from first principals every time. This means that it will often make a mistake on the first pass, which means I have to carefully coach it through the process and just as carefully monitor the results. Which usually takes the same amount of time – though considerably more mental energy – than if I had just done it myself. There are millions of white collar workers in the US experiencing the same thing.
The solution that suggests itself is hundreds of specialized AIs, each built to solve a particular, common business problem. I am confident that this is possible but I don’t think this will result in the significant reduction of the salary class. One reason for this is that software, even AI, requires a ton of maintenance by humans. Another reason is that each AI that specializes in a particular business problem will be the flagship property of an indvidual company with its own HR department, compliance department, etc.
These companies will eventually be purchased, merged or spun off, but those processes of transformation are each facilitated by their own class of specialists, aka white collar workers and bureacrats. If this is musical chairs, I think the chairs will be pulled away less rapidly than you imagine.
Your post got me wondering whether there is a corollary for the Shirky principle in the individual. When we have personal problems, we may try a set of habits to solve them. These habits are equivalent to an institution. Sometimes we do solve things. Often, we can’t. Those habits, whether they are “drinking” or “yoga” or whatnot, become important parts of the self as we see it. A self can be seen as a set of strategies for dealing with the world. Like any paradigm, it does some things well and inevitably has unsolvable issues. The self will preserve itself by not trying too hard to change the world to which it is the chosen strategy, because that involves annihilation of the self.
Many charities talk about bringing “awareness” to a problem. Sometimes, this does indeed help. But when it doesn’t, they continue bringing useless awareness for decades. On a personal level, awareness is great, but again we are often aware of an issue yet unable to fix it. So we get more aware, and fail again.
It is not simply that the institution must preserve the problem to preserve itself. The institution is a part of a society. It tries to preserve the broader society in which such an institution is notionally needed. The structure of the society would have to change for the problem to solve. So what’s at stake, as you mentioned, is not just the institution but the whole slew of culture the society supports.
I asked myself if there are any solutions. Unfortunately, all I got was an awareness exercise which I am now suspicious of given my own argument. But let’s see how it goes. An individual might list out a number of personal problems he has been “working to solve” or “becoming more aware of” for more than a year. Then assume at least some of these support critical notions of the self and are preserved via self-sabotage. Ask: am I really solving these, or perpetuating them?
Institutions look to society, and our habits and thoughts follow the self. To actually solve things, we need to take cues from a different society or self, or something of a higher order in which it exists, such as genuine religion. The Second Religiosity is probably a watered-down salary class attempt to do this, and whatever new religions unfold in the wake of industrial society will be the real solutions—the context in which new societies, institutions, and selves can form.
Bateson makes this argument time and again, that the part cannot “solve” the whole. It has to go the other way around. The wisdom of what to do comes from larger systems, and larger still. In this light, “collapse” is not a problem but a systemic solution, a dissolution of self.
As for me, I’ll work through my little exercise, pray, and turn for my wisdom to those wholes in which the self exists and on which it depends (Nature, for one). Anything less is musical chairs.
I agree with what Silicon Guy #7 wrote about the military (not that I’ve experienced that just friends/family with those who took that route) and what he said about his daughter. (Hourly wages with benefits.)
Hourly wages with benefits is also where my wife and I are at. We both came from the wage class, and can see ourselves peering into the ranks of the salary class with different people we know… but despite some of the benefits, of the benefits, it still feels like the wage class, but would be on the upper end of that.
It’s hard to ignore some of the benefits of those differences while being in that area of wiggle room. The wiggle room is disappearing. At least we’ve always known how to get by within our means. Those means don’t stretch as far as they used to.
For instance, we had the opportunity to go to Maine. It was barely affordable after a bill we got hit with. Then we got hit with another unexpected bill, and the people we were planning to go with, all being based in Seattle area asked to do the gathering out there instead. We’d still have free lodging, but it would have been just barely affordable to get there without having much fun money left, so, as beautiful as it would be to hang out on some islands in the Puget Sound where we would have free lodging, getting there aint happening now. I instead booked us a weekend time in Mammoth Cave this summer. I’ve been wanting to go back since I was a kid and we will be camping. $30 a night campsite is much more affordable.
Lowering our expectations of what we can do in terms of travelling and things like that is useful now. Otherwise, plan, scrimp, save if we want to go on a trip that salaried class can do at a drop of a hat. That, and those bills which they absorb, seem to effect us much more… so that’s why I’d say there is the nuance.
We got our garden planted though, and that will be a good supplement to the food bills… which are why it is harder to save, and we cook a lot of our own food, etc.
I wish everyone a wonderful summer solstice and anyone who is going to Adocentyn, hope you all have a grand time.
Hi JMG,
A great analysis, as always! I currently work for a large corporation and there is a colossal gap between the middle and upper management and the staff that work on the ground. Everyone thinks they are out of touch. We constantly tell them about the embedded structural problems at our sites but they never get fixed. Instead we get ridiculous new initiatives to implement which we usually ignore completely. We’ve had a number of senior management embroiled in scandals that have hit the national press, and every time they’ve been suspended with full pay, and then gotten off with some ‘diversity training’ and a lukewarm apology over zoom. The staff feel like it is one rule for management and another for everyone else. Luckily we have a good union and that we means we get a fair salary and benefits, relatively speaking, for now.
Its funny, I’ve been reading your posts about the current class struggle in western nations for a while now and I feel like I see it play out more and more every day at work. And in the broader culture. There is a real toxic undercurrent of resentment towards the managers that seems to grow every day. My own relationship to class is somewhat elusive – born into the welfare class, in the wage class now economically, but after studying the arts to a postgraduate level, which made me (for a while at least) politically and aspirationally salary class, and my partner now comes from that class. Like yourself I think, I don’t fit into any definite categories politically. Here in the UK the salary class appears to still be a bit more embedded in power, compared to the states, but that might just be how much older we are and the greater degree to which our bureaucracies have ossified. And that could well change if the far right get in at the next election, which is looking likely as our economy continues to spiral.
How to orient oneself in such a changing world? And make a poem or two out of the madness! This blog continues to be a refuge of sanity for me in these crazy times of decline. Thanks for continuing to spell it out for us!
Bright Blessings
I know AI is not the topic, but here’s a data point, if I may: an unnamed corporation is pushing for a very large data center near me, using our municipal water supply. This is a town of under 10,000 population. There’s strong community opposition, and the city gov’t is keeping the name of the corporation seeking to build this thing under wraps, for some reason. It all seems pretty suspect. The bait, of course, is the big boost to the local tax base. Who could resist? Who would object to supporting our own increasing obsolescence?
The housing issue is crazy. It is downright criminal the money being charged for a house. We are only where we are at because we got in when we did. I feel bad for our Millenial kids (born early to mid 90s). They are in the wage class and rent is crazy… let alone buying. We would like to help them more, and we don’t live extravagant… but as the prices have gone up its been harder to do.
Anyway, one solution to the housing crisis is squatting. In London and Berlin in the 70s, thats what made them such vibrant times for music and culture. Artists could live in abandoned buildings and start making their bodies of work while living on the cheap.
There are a lot of abandoned houses out there…
…but the companies that swoop in to remodel. Well, they screw the people who have been living in those houses when the sell where they live for more money than they have probably ever seen in their life. And then they screw the people in the neighborhood when they sell it to someone in the salary class for three times as much as they paid for and put into it. Then they screw the long term residents when our taxes go up. Yes, I get upset about this.
I guess all of this is where it pays to know a thing or two about Situationism and the tools for sidestepping the Spectacle. If you don’t get sold on the idea of rising up into the salaried class, and the like, then there is a lot less negative emotions and mental states to deal with when you carve out a life on your own terms. It’s not always easy, but a meaningful life is more rewarding than getting cooked in the oven after being plopped out of a cookie cutter template.
Peace
HR= Human Replacement
You need to add another class that has a HUGE net global worth: the criminal cartel class. They produce the vices that people have consumed since the dawn of time: drugs, alcohol and human trafficking. You could argue in “moralistic drag” that the “war for fun and profit” can be put under the Kleptocracy umbrella you did mention. The Epstein money laundering class profits with the “legitimate” Banksters running their legal shell companies. A good example of this is JPMorgan paying $500 million to victims of Epstein who were apparently trafficked to no one. Another good one is the BCCI bank scandal. No bank CEO ever goes to jail, and crime that pays is crime that stays.
I would like to say slaves have been replaced with machines and energy. My oven, stove, washer, dishwasher, kitchen appliances, sewing machine, vacuums, cars, planes etc do th ework of many housewives and have boosted comfortable lifestyles immensely.
I don’t agree with your pessimistic take on things though. Since the 70’s there has been plenty of squawking that the oil will run out, we will all starve, the sky is falling. Hubby LOVES solar and there is a massive upswing in the Southern Hemisphere peasants getting off-grid power sources dislodging themselves from the thumb of oil dependency. Elon Musk has the optimistic view gadgets will take over production and that will change the social strata as well.
Yesterday I randomly opened one of my kids books written in the 70’s, and a boy of 12 was stating his parents told him to be grateful for what he has and not what he doesn’t have. There is always the eternal pie fight over who get what slices, but with a simple shift of mind set, people can adjust and be grateful to even have pie.
Being poor in 2026 is way better than being poor in any other time before hand. With the Grace of God, humans seem to manage somehow.
I can hardly wait to see the “alien invasions” from “government disclosure”. I hoe you have a post on that sometime because there are some fairly wild claims around all of this, including things up you alley, like the collective consciousness and magic.
Last week I saw Mr. Bessant touting a $250 bill, with Trumps portrait on it. I think a better idea would be a $250,000 bill with Trump on it, and printing enough to pay down the national debt by 2028. Whoever the US owes money to gits them in truckloads, and instead of: “In God We Trust” have the words: “Take It Or Leave It”. On the back have a birdseye view of the biggest Data Center and a banner that says: “Already Obsolete” Then the debt would be paid and if they still want to loan US money, they can use these bills. In fact, pass a law that requires all institutional banking use only these bills.
Hey JMG,
Here in Germany, I’ve seen an advert far a job portal a couple of times recently (in public, so not personalised). It shows a smiling woman in overalls with the slogan “Yesterday: Desk. Today: Workbench.” (or something similar). If the music is going to stop, might as well tell people that standing is healthier than sitting anyway, so why scramble for a chair?
On another note, the Shirky Principle’s name always seemed oddly appropriate to me. These institution shirk their stated missions.
There seems to be a typo in the third to last paragraph: “and the eq ually huge”.
—David P.
Hi JMG,
I am curious about where you think health care workers fit in regarding salary vs. wage class. It seems to me that it would be a spectrum across both depending on the job, as in a nurse assistant or home health aide making an hourly wage would be (as implied by the hourly wage) wage class and a MD would be considered salary class. There would also seem to be a gray area for some jobs “in between” those examples with some (i.e. nurses or rehab professionals) that may have a salary and benefits, but in a way that is quite different from the typical white collar bureaucratic jobs discussed in the post. I appreciate any thoughts and thank you.
Jerry D 8
> I thought it was telling when the Florida governor flew the illegals to Martha’s Vineyard how fast those people got put on a bus OUT of the vineyard.
However, now that that batch of darky-despicables have witnessed The Promised Land of Martha’s Vineyard by actually being there,— in a generation, they will be back, buying up properties there. Ruining the neighborhood. Taking over. Hasta la vista, old white 13-Colony lot.
💨🏚️💨Northwind Grandma
Dane County, Wisconsin, USA
One of the effects (possibly a side effect) of the covid lock downs and work from home for the salary class, was an ideal AI training dataset. Prior to the lock downs, who knew how much essential information was transmitted over the water cooler or cubical wall? By moving to a remote work system, the training set was now complete, AI had the entire workflow.
This will vastly simplify the future workplace reductions, such as Musk’s 80% reduction at X/Twitter
Oh, and two more things:
1) I’m not convinced you’re right about cancel culture. I know too many people who, if they’re not true believers in everything the modern left espouses and think everybody who disagrees with that is basically Hitler, are very convincing actors. The shock during the layoffs in the last couple of years always seemed quite genuine too. I’d argue that the simplest explanation for both is that it’s not an act.
2) Ever since you switched hosting providers, your latest comment occasionally doesn’t show anywhere except for the comments RSS feed. I’ve only seen this happen to your comments and the problem definitely resolves itself when you approve the next comment, possibly also after a few hours regardless of comment approval but I’m not sure.
(I mentioned this the first time it happened but then your comment was visible the next time I looked, so I told you that the problem was fixed—apparently it’s a recurring issue, though.)
—David P.
Actually, third addendum: your comment also shows in the page I’m shown after commenting, where my own comment is also shown as awaiting moderation.
—David P.
One thing I find really interesting about the Bolt story is that he didn’t say he replaced the HR todies with LLMs– he just fired them, without even making the pretense that they’re being replaced by chatbots. Other companies– perhaps with more solvent balance sheets– are trimming that same fat, but are automating the BS jobs instead. This is the first time I’ve seen a CEO miss the chance to tell potential investors he’s surfing the current Great Wave of Progress.
Either that, too, is a sign of the times or this Bolt operation is so broke they can’t afford whatever OpenAI or Anthropic charge these days. It does go back to a disagreement you and I had in a previous thread, JMG– where you thought paper-pushers would be replaced, and I questioned if the LLMs would fail at being viable replacements and we’d find we didn’t need all these office drones after all, or suffer from the lack thereof. Of course you pointed out we could only wait and see. I suppose how things go at Bolt will be one datapoint to see if it’s “didn’t need” or “suffer from the lack”, at least in the office environment.
@pygmycory,#24
How many services targeting the welfare class actually benefit from the sort of service the salary-class drones are willing to provide their lessers on welfare? My experience may not be representative, since I’m a white guy and an ‘invisible’ disability, but, uh… they’ve never been interested in helping me. At all. Trying to figure out how to deny me my due? Insinuating that I’m a cheat? All but telling me to my face I’m the wrong demographic to even think about talking to them? That I’ve seen. My doctor flat out told me not to bother applying for disability and to try and eke out whatever income I can as I’m able, and what do you know, he was right. If we switch to an automated system that lacks the smarts to discriminate, then I’m all for it!
Of course that automated system will break down in due time– but when the entire civilization is going down the toilet, you just have to accept these things. Everyone’s benefits are going away, sooner or later, because we’re bankrupt. That means going back to Lenin’s dictum that “He who shall not work shall not eat” and all the human suffering and misery that entails. I’m not thrilled about that, but pretending it’s not coming doesn’t do any good either. I’m thinking of growing poppies for my own exit, to deny the government the satisfaction of doing me in with MAiD.
Silicon Valley guy offers some useful nuance to an excellent analysis, very useful for understanding what is coming as well as what has happened. The term that gets used often by a certain group of analysts of our process is “populist” but there are two very different meanings: Some see angry salaried people as the base for a reform movement to challenge the distribution of wealth, other see the wage class in that role, but within the wage class, the investment class has had a good deal of success in redirecting their anger at the salaried…..the divide and conquer war between those two classes in the middle has done a lot to conceal the idiocy of the investment class, and shield it from challenge from either.
What both versions of populism typically ignore, whether intentionally or from simple ignorance is the key point at the end of the article, the collapsing material basis for the US lifestyle, which still represents the aspirations of many in the wage class, disabling them from seeing the best way to pursue their real interests against their class opponents who really wield power.
Oh my, be still my beating heart. Oh the nostalgia is real. The ADR is back on the program. Welcome back to the 2010s.
Folks a word of advice: when the Archdruid makes an analysis like this you have a rare opportunity to experience the perspective of a sage. All trough the year of our lords 2016 I had the pleasure of knowing that The Donald ( his more illustrious titles were yet to be acquired ) will win the election. And got to sit back and watch the show with cool detachment. You know it’s coming, appreciate the nuance, the tactics, theatrics and strategies. Observe the moves and the pauses in the movements. All the while you have the benefit of the perspective your perch provides.
John, and here I was thinking you are finally going to say something about the strait.
Well my best to you all,
V
“To make sense of what’s going on, it’s going to be necessary to talk about social classes, and that requires confronting the most fashionable and least useful theory of social class in circulation these days, the one that’s associated with the name and legacy of Karl Marx. Marx didn’t invent the idea of analyzing social conflicts using class as a framing device. That was introduced into modern thought by Giambattista Vico, who wrote a century and a half before Marx’s time, and Vico got it from ancient Greek historians such as Polybius.”
Of course, social classes weren’t made up by Marx. I agree.
Often I’ve told some friends and relatives that our current societies cannot be explained seriously without pointing there are social classes. Some people (ironically middle class people) react like Pavlov’s dog in less than a second, answering me, in a bitter and angry tone, that I must be an old fashioned Commie. So I ‘d know Communism was a failure due to the USSR collapse and blah blah blah…WTF?
It doesn’t matter they know since years ago I’m a center-left non Marxist guy, they can’t avoid that non rational reaction. Interesting…
It’s been been a commonplace since Spain began to be a “democracy”, that we’re a non classist society, beyond left and right wing governments. I think it’s a puerile and fake equalitarism.
So I agree with John, who depicts social classes and of course he isn’t a Marxist, but a Burkean Conservative.
*****************************************************************
Salary class has been too arrogant with wage class too many years, thanks to their irrational belief in globalism forever, and I also think they soon will pay their “sin”. It seems current and future situation in the USA, can be seen across every Western country, sooner or later.
By the way, I remember to have read more or less ten years ago, in a very neoliberal and globalist web site in Spain (whose name I cannot and I don’t want to remember now), there was a wage class guy who complained bitterly about how difficult and bad paid were jobs for people without university studies. He was mocked by that site majority; their favorite “reasoning” was blaming poor low level people whose work was being replaced by machines in physical labor, because they were u nable to “recycle” into technological jobs…so they thought people with universitarian studies (who usually go into the salary class here and everywhere) never would have any problem to find and keep their jobs.
Oops! Here it comes the “AI” to replace a lot of them…I don’t have any pity for them.
Excellent post, JMG. You’ve long discussed class as a driving force in explaining our culture, and defining it certainly clarifies things. In many ways, it’s a game of musical chairs.
In my mind, it’s also how “reality” is getting redefined for most. It appears to me that the investor and welfare classes are huge today versus the coming Great Reset taking place, and the effects of the Long Descent will move many from being “takers” to “makers”. In other words, people today who pontificate fantasy and act as parasites will need to morph into contributors in society where they’re creating a “value-add” to the ledger. Lies based on defying the Laws of Physics are being exposed every day now.
I just finished reading “A Tale of Two Cities” for book club this month – hadn’t read it in 40 years, and only once since high school. With the backdrop of current events, the story took on a whole different meaning for me. Let’s hope Dicken’s vision of “The Terrors” doesn’t reflect how history will soon rhyme once again…..
Michael, that makes me even more happy that I’ve never had to be a corporate employee.
Nonara, you’re missing the point. AI doesn’t have to be capable of doing jobs that don’t actually need to be done. Many salary class jobs fall into that category.
Kyle, a valid point! Some psychologists suggest that we never solve our problems — we just outgrow them, or fail to do so.
Justin, again, yes, there are gray areas and intermediate zones. You’re in one of them.
Corduroy, thank you for this report from the trenches!
Phutatorius, there may be more bait involved than increased tax revenues. Good old-fashioned bribery is quite common in such situations, you know.
Justin, rising real estate costs are largely an artifact of government policies which restrict supply via zoning, building codes, sky-high fees, etc. Those could all be changed easily — but then the salary class would lose equity, and the screaming would begin.
Candyd, first, it doesn’t matter whether the industry producing the income is legal, illegal, or in the gray zone — how do the individuals in question get their income? A wage, a salary, or what? Second, I see I have to do yet another post about the far from minor point that “business as usual” and “the sky is falling” aren’t the only possible futures; it still makes me shake my head that so many people are stuck, as you seem to be, in that delusion. Third, I already wrote a book on the whole alien business; it’s called The UFO Chronicles, and you probably won’t like it much.
Mark, er, I assume you mean this as a joke. If not, I suggest you learn a little about the concept of hyperinflation.
David, thanks for catching the typo — no idea how that got in. As for the ad, that’s a good sign.
Chris, haven’t you answered your own question? If someone makes a wage with no (or few) benefits, they’re wage class; if someone gets a monthly salary with benefits, they’re salary class. That applies to health care as to every other industry. I worked in health care back before I first got into print, btw, and the huge class division between us hourly-wage people and the salaried doctors and administrators was a massive and inescapable factor.
DennisD, that’s funny, in a bleak sort of way. A lot of salary class people loved the lockdowns because they got to work from home and still get their salaries, while many wage class people scrambled to get by on little or no income. Now it turns out the lockdowns were just as bad for the salary class, just not quite as quickly. Something something revenge something something best served cold?
David, people very often talk themselves into believing what it’s to their advantage to believe. That’s especially true among educated classes, which are used to internalizing the ideology du jour.
TylerA, if I understand correctly, Breslow replaced HR with a much smaller set of employees with sharply limited responsibilities, so LLMs never entered the picture.
Jerry, yes, I expect to see a lot of this sort of rhetoric in the years immediately ahead, focusing on trying to play the wage class and the investment class against each other, for the benefit of the salary class. In fact, I addressed that in the post.
Vitranc, we’ll get to that. I note with some amusement that yet another of my predictions seems to be coming true right on schedule. I was on a podcast a little while ago and one of the hosts quipped:
“The saddest words from tongue or pen
Are, ‘JMG was right again.'”
Not that I’m infallible, of course, but my predictions tend to be right much more often than certain broken clocks out there on the internet…
Chuaquin, when people get angry about a discussion of social classes, it’s usually wise to assume that they’re abusing their own class privilege.
Drhooves, the social construction of reality — and in particular the social construction of value — is a topic I’m probably going to have to discuss as we proceed. You’re right, of course, that an imperial power that’s losing its tribute economy needs to have a lot of people transition from parasitic to productive lifestyles, but that’s harder when they’ve made a heroic effort not to see themselves as parasites!
@Cynthia and JMG,
the expansion of MAiD to cover mental illness alone has been stalled for years now, and there’s significant pushback. At the moment there’s a conservative bill C218 which is to remove the ever-delayed extension indefinitely/permenently, and it seems to be getting some traction. There’s also a parliamentary committee on the issue, which has just decided not to reccommend extending MAiD. https://alexschadenberg.blogspot.com/2026/06/epc-response-government-committee-says.html And Alberta put in more limits on some of the abuses in the last few months.
Cynthia, pushback seems like it might actually work, if you care about this issue this is a great time to get involved and tell your MP you are against the expansion and support bill C218. I actually haven’t felt as hopeful about the horrible euthanasia situation being improved in years. We might actually be able to stop the endless expansion and misuse, or even get some of it rolled back..
I’m thinkin’ I got lucky when I was ejected from the comfortable side of the salary class by an unpopular President…
After some effort, I’ve landed at the upper edge of the wage class and/or the lower edge of the salary class… which is quite the catbird seat for field observations… which have been matching up very well with your commentary and your observations.
In answer to Phutatorius, my observations of the outlaw class suggest they are better managers because their fortunes rise and fall with their own skill. There’s no fail-up option in crime. Which brings me to the talking point on the populist axis regarding the large number of working age men (30% by some accountings) in the US who are not just underemployed or unemployed but not employed and regarded as not employable. (One assumes they are busy in the grey and black markets.) That looks like a disaster coming full speed from the other end of the tunnel. I’d ask what’s coming next from that, but I’m noticing all my old frames of reference have been broken… so… any advice on making new frames?
Greetings JMG,
It is an insightful post that sheds light on people’s real motives in society.
Following your advice some posts ago, I have begun living at least one social class below my means.
When I ask people why they must live in a place that costs 1500 a month instead of 800, there is no convincing reason, it is just a ‘ must have ‘ that would make our ancestors and people in poor countries laugh .
It has been an eye opener because it is less peer pressure and more respect, and I have a better chance at financial health.
While a little uncomfortable – not much compared to what humans have experienced in history – I actually feel more alive.
I had no idea how much of a prison keeping up with one’s class was.
Thank you for that idea.
JMG,
An interesting thing has happened in three local public sector wage and budget disputes. I am going to make the leap that in the public sector there are wage class people who have benefits and get a salary ( the actual teachers in a school district or community college) or the street level employees of a city government that get benefits but may be paid by wage or salary.
All three of these cases involved a city, and a community college and local public university cutting bottom level employees to fill a growing budget gap. In all three cases the main signs on the picket lines were ” Chop from the Top”. This has found its way in to official budget debates and newspaper editorials. It expresses pure class based warfare with the wage class demanding that cuts come from the upper level of the salary class. The demand is to cut administrators, and middle managers instead of teachers, cops and street sweepers.
I feel this trend will grow as budgets shrink, and it will be interesting to see the upper levels of the PMC entrench themselves to do battle with the lower classes in the bureaucracy.
@William #17
“I am quite convinced that had video arcades realized the niche they were really in and not tried to compete with home consoles on graphics”
And of course that’s more or less what happened in Asia, especially Japan. Arcades branded themselves as social destinations for people of all ages, branching out into photo booths, crane machines, rhythm games, and other gimmicks meant to appeal to various demographics who might want to stop by after work or school, and thrived as a result for more than 20-30 years after their decline in the US. For many years in Japan, it wasn’t too unusual to see a group of schoolgirls or salarymen stop by an arcade after school or work to unwind for a bit. Of course, that’s changing now as their economy takes a turn for the worse, but it’s still an interesting example of how the kind of tunnel vision many industries suffer from here in the West has brought a premature end to things that could have well thrived under a different mindset.
@Tyler A #43
“If we switch to an automated system that lacks the smarts to discriminate, then I’m all for it!”
Unfortunately I’m not as optimistic as you are that these automated systems will be much more impartial than their predecessors. Multiple examples have surfaced showing that LLMs replicate the biases that occur in their training data, so if these systems are trained on past decisions made by people of the salary class, what you can likely count on is that the person sneering at you for being a “cheat” will be replaced by an automated message that insinuates, a little more impartially, that you are a still a “cheat”. The response will be quicker, and a little more bland and inoffensive, but I don’t think things will fundamentally change.
If anything, it will be much harder to reach any human to file any sort of complaint or appeal, since those things may be handled by machines as well, which may well be tuned by the humans running them to bias towards rejection.
Machines are still tuned by the people who built them, and the idea they are less biased than people is simply an illusion propped up by the tech elite who want you to accept your dependence on them.
@Justin,
yeah, that really stinks.
Yes, it took five years for me to get disability status from my health issues getting out of hand, and there was a lot of struggling and failing at attempts at work, help from family, and living on fumes along the way. I can’t speak to your situation, but I can say that if you are really persistent about asking for help and are obviously failing at life, and get help from the right people, it sometimes works. Sometimes that involves finding another doctor. I had one play down my chronic pain with the words ‘but you’re pretty’ and as if that somehow puts food on the table, while demanding I do the physically impossible and suggesting I be less depressed, and a psychiatrist who doesn’t believe autism exists and tried to tell me I was faking mental health stuff until I had a really spectacular panic attack in front of him. At which point he went from ‘I don’t really believe you’ to ‘do you need to go to the hospital?’
I don’t know the future, but I intend to make the most of what I am given, for as long as I am here. And I do not intend to allow myself to be bullied out of my life if I can help it, either. God gave it to me, and it is not theirs to take away. If they want me dead they are going to have to kill me outright.
Hi, I wanted to share a poem I wrote a long time ago…
Musical Chairs
The people with the power started setting up the chairs
They turned the music on, nice and slow
The people in the dance of life moved from chair to chair
And they moved up as far as they could go
Then the music, playing faster, turned the game into a frenzy
And the people with the power pulled away a chair
The people in the dance of life got dizzy in the frenzy
They fought amongst each other, grabbing what was there
Then the people in the power brought the music to a stop
And they watched the desperate scramble of the ones below
The game seems nearly over, but the people cannot stop
The game is life or death, as the ones in power know.
Phutatorius # 9:
“I think you neglected to mention a fifth class, the outlaw class, and the underground economy, which is quite large.”
Very interesting comment: I don’t know exactly how many outlaw people there’s in my own country, nor how many people could be working in underground economy; but it’s said (according some statistics) more or less 1/4 of current Spanish GDP comes from underground economy. So we can guess maybe there’s more of a million of people here (thinking a conservative number) working under the government radar (taxes free). Oh, and we’ve got more or less 50,000 criminals in our prisons (how many out of them? I don’t know).
—————————————————————————————
JMG # 27:
“Chuaquin, that’s the same game kids play, or used to play, over here.”
I’m afraid I seem to repeat a stereotyped word, but I can’t avoid to tell you John has written a very provocative essay, because I think he’s right. So its title seems to me provocative and funny, alike.
Yes, JMG, and it’s a funny and creepy game alike, remembering it now from my childhood. If you think about it, it depicts a competitive dynamic very common in every society, especially in nowadays globalized world. It seems my nephews don’t know this game, maybe due to its political incorrection in front of today children games policies…
——————————————————-
Candyd # 35:
“Being poor in 2026 is way better than being poor in any other time before hand.”
I think it depends where do you live, or how…I wouldn’t say that phrase without some social and economical contexts, methink.
——————————————————-
Tyler A. # 43:
“That means going back to Lenin’s dictum that “He who shall not work shall not eat””
A hard phrase, but I think Lenin wasn’t the first man to say it. I remember it was Apostle Paul who wrote it in one of his letters, within the Bible New Testament (I don’t remember exactly which letter and versicle).
I remember reading your class analysis in The King in Yellow and finding it to be a simple and effective way of getting to the heart of the matter of class in America. There are all kinds of ways that you can split hairs along this or that line, ideological or otherwise, but it’s just a fact that the way money and resources find their way to you (and the barriers or benefits accrued by the system to those avenues) will define a great deal more about your lifestyle than your self-professed beliefs.
You touch on another important point that I think tends to get lost in the weeds of splitting hairs, which is that LLMs neither have to be effective, economically feasible, or revolutionary if what they’re replacing is redundant in the first place. All it needs to do is perform a decent facsimile of the work of an average bureaucrat, and it does that more than fine. The remaining fraction of actually-important work can be handled by a much smaller number of competent people than are currently employed by the bureaucracy, and so that means while office jobs aren’t going away forever, there will be much, much less of them to go around over the next decade and into the future, and the people employed by them will be held to a much harsher standard of work than they are now.
People lose sight of this because they mistakenly accept the mainstream narrative’s framing that this is a conversation about AI’s “viability” when really a half-competent monkey would have done the job if you could have actually convinced the public hiring it over an office worker constituted “progress”. So correct me if I’m wrong, but I believe you’re arguing that AI’s primary utility is as a narrative device, and any actual utility it possesses is only secondary to this function. Not that its actual utility is nonexistent, but that it’s less important than most people realize to the way things are currently playing out.
Thanks for this analysis, as always.
Thanks John. As usual, your writing has sparked a lot of interesting discussion.
It is also interesting how people respond to your analysis. People’s stories vary widely. In my own case, although as a geologist I was part of the salaried class, I retained a great deal of sympathy for the wage class from a whole range of experiences. As a retired Canadian, I expect the Great Boomer Remover, I.e. MAID, to be offered sometime in the next few years. I won’t go easy
JMG: “Canada’s chosen to reduce its welfare class instead via ‘voluntary’ extermination”
Really? Like, you knew that stuff about MAID already and reached that conclusion also? I half expected you to tell me to calm down and retrace my steps until I found reality again.
Or, is “voluntary extermination” a reference to the opioid epidemic? (Actually, the addressing of which is a perfect example of a Shirky Principle industry.)
As for Canada overall, well, it is what it is and has been since the United Empire Loyalists. If it were otherwise, our bootprint would have been on George III’s posterior right along with yours, but it isn’t.
*King in Orange, pardon me. I’ve started reading the Weird of Hali books recently and some of the major plot devices have stuck themselves in my head, it seems 🙂 I’m enjoying them quite a lot, by the way, though I’m not very far as of yet.
Leondarrell 11
> Chicago Obama center
I hadn’t seen it until I now just looked. How many adjectives describe it?
Hideous, sinister, and gruesome in the sense that I can perceive those who enter, never escape.
Dungeon. Insane asylum. Chicago’s Tower of London… Tower of Obama Prison. No one ever recovers their sanity. If one is nominated to work in there, don’t consent and high-tail it out of there fast.
I would never enter there. Heebie-jeebies.
Obama = 🧌.
💨🌃🧌💨Northwind Grandma
Dane County, Wisconsin, USA
Hi JMG,
I really thought the salary class was going to lose their fortunes in 2008 and I told many people about the structural problems. When the stock market and asset prices rose even further after 2014, I was called stupid. My response to that has been that the return of asset prices to astronomical highs was only done by sacrificing the futures of at least 2, maybe 3 generations. Thats still my response. I call the asset holders out for what they did to the younger generations. I usually don’t get a response but I think that most people know it’s true.
I have just completed a second read of Joseph Conrad’s Nostromo. It’s a magnificent, but rather bleak book, and it has been rather accurately described as a “Greek tragedy about capitalism”. It reminded me forcefully of your interpretation of Wagner’s Ring cycle, too, with the silver of the mine making an almost perfect stand-in for the cursed Nibelung hoard. Any supernatural element in Nostromo can be plausibly denied, but the curse of the treasure is just as real as in Wagner’s story. It’s just that Conrad proposes no salvation at all – international capitalists, nationalists, anarchists, socialists are all equally impotent to improve the country, and he sees no greater good in religion either.
Coincidentally, this same day as your essay, the blogger Aurelien published an essay titled, 21st Century Schizoid Man. (Yes, the one by King Crimson.)
https://aurelien2022.substack.com/p/21st-century-schizoid-man
He is describing what he calls the PMC – Professional and Managerial Caste – which seems to be the same as what you label the Salary Class. He argues that class exhibits symptoms of a collective schizophrenia, out of touch with anything resembling what the great unwashed, Far Right Extremist Working Class (c’est moi) experience every day as we go about our daily business.
I’m concerned that, when people living in a hallucinatory paranoid world like that get laid off in large numbers, that they will be experiencing, not just a loss of job, income or (gasp!) status, but of an entire reality structure. I have a hard time picturing how one deals with that sort of collective reality implosion, either as a member of that class or as a person outside of it having to deal with the societal effects.
Quoting the prophet and oracle Bob Dylan:
The man standing next to me
His head was exploding
I was praying the pieces
Wouldn’t fall on me.
drhooves @ 47, however did you find a book club which is into serious reading?
About salary class attitudes and behavior: Our small city public library recently hired a new director. I saw notices that on a certain day, evening, he would meet the public. I went. I couldn’t believe what I saw and heard. This was a catered event, snacks and a bar–$9. for one glass of wine, no thanks–with waiters bringing around trays of small bites to taste. The new director spoke briefly to the assembled. Not One Word about what he intends to do with our library. Stop tossing good books? Instruct the staff to process interlibrary loans, which they have not been doing? Color me bewildered.
Great piece! We might also look at Professor Turchin’s universal model of decline, the main cause of which is the overproduction of Elites…This is mainly observed in our Government or more properly tens of thousands of governments in the US, where any offspring of the highly salaried class, no matter how useless, can always be found a position in the civil service…which these days pays much better than private industry…The Trump administration has already made a start on chopping some of these heads, but there are millions left…e.g. In my home State, retired school administrators can retire with 300k/yr pensions, and lavish benefits, though the State is bankrupt….,.
The next recession/depression is going to be a doozy…
Since the American economy has also grown strongly since WWII, and the dollar has inflated, interest payments as fraction of GDP don’t show the same monotonously climbing trajectory. They are still critically high, of course.
Mister Nobody 12
> planning on building (a grand total of 17 large data centers are planned for Mount Pleasant, Wisconsin
Perhaps we will be fortunate enough to see it go the way High Speed Rail has been going in California — nowhere (my region, when I lived in California). Incompetence after incompetence.
Is the State of Wisconsin paying for these data centers? Is the fedral govmint paying for it? Is Musk paying for it? Who is paying for it? We Wisconson-ites certainly don’t have that kind of money, particularly when nobody living here will benefit. Thousands of farms are just hanging on. No corn, Muricans starve. Simple. One doesn’t need less farms.
It may take ten years to even begin to get this artyfishyul ill-telligence-schitt*👺off the ground. By then, there may be no funding, or perhaps simply be “out of the mood.”
Oh God(s), more cockamamie schitt* that Muricans have to put up with, more garbage Muricans have to cope with, more things Muricans have to deal with that won’t do them good one little bit.
(* Schitt’s Creek TV show 2015-2020)
JMG, may I cUrse artyfishyul ill-telligence👺? It deserves cursing.
💨👺💨Northwind Grandma
Dane County, Wisconsin, USA
Cynthia Christie 21
Okay, I will be nice. I am in a good mood. If I weren’t in a good mood, I would cuss at you big-time.
I will be nice. I don’t know what MAID means. I will look up “MAID” in wiki. Is it there? Let’s see. [[[ This is a lot of extra work for a reader. How boring is this? ]]]
Let’s see:
Massive array of idle disks.
Nope.
Medical assistance in dying.
Maybe.
Mobile advertising in ID.
Could be.
Maid Marian.
Probably not.
Maid servant.
Perhaps.
Parlor maid.
Dunno.
Serving maid.
Maybe.
Chambermaid.
Perhaps.
Char woman.
Is it?
[[[ This is a lot of work. I am flagging in interest. ]]]
Damsel.
Maybe.
Wench.
Perhaps.
Drudge.
Perhaps.
I don’t know. I give up. Maybe I shall stop reading forever, being writers don’t recognize their own abysmal writing.
Or, maybe, whenever I see this particular writer’s name, I will skip reading the entry altogether. Maybe. Perhaps. Could be. Dunno. Not ‘probable not.’ I will see what mood I am in.
💨🦠✨🦠💨Northwind Grandma
Dane County, Wisconsin, USA
Well, the rest of us are screaming already, so they can go frack themselves. At least, thats one sentiment, and mild at that…
One of my hobby-horses / bêtes noires is the US Peace Corps, which seems to reflect some of these trends. JFK created the PC in response, on one hand, to the youth movement, and on the other, to the Cold War. The idea was that people in Third World countries, who might otherwise be swayed to anti-Americanism, would have a good impression of all these bright-eyed young people. JFK in that first speech mentions the precedent of Christian missionaries (A different era, I know.)
With the end of the Cold War, Congress began balking at paying for a glorified youth exchange program–holding hands and singing “kumbaya,” if you will–and so PC pivoted to development. Is PC any good at development? Hard to say, they don’t collect the kind of data that could answer that, but it is hard to imagine that they would be–the volunteers have no particular expertise in it, and PC does not particularly care what they do during their service, as long as they generate good-sounding reports and don’t cause PR problems. Why even have PC, then? Mainly because it already boasts a robust bureaucracy and “alumni” network (they don’t call them that) that lobbies for continued support.
PC is often criticized from the Left (“white savior” complex) as well as from the right (as a government program whose volunteers and staff are mostly on the Left). DOGE recently gutted the program (right after shutting down USAID), but added a new initiative dedicated to AI or something that existing PC people are confused by and suspicious of. Before that, the last big change was during Covid, when ALL the volunteers were sent back to the USA. PC had to be started again from scratch, with a lot fewer willing volunteers.
PC volunteers (I hate that term–they do get compensated) tend to be from middle or upper class backgrounds, since a university degree–any university degree–is generally required (they are starting to relax this), and since the application process requires out-of-pocket costs for medical tests (only some of which can be reimbursed in the distant future). Compare this to the process of enlistment in the military, where the physical exam is free, and the wait-time is much shorter. Part of the appeal is adventure, of course, but PC has also historically attracted young people aspiring to a career in government service, or NGOs–jobs that are now drying up.
Today PC has real recruiting problems. One issue is medical screening, which turns people away (or requires endless paperwork) over minor issues. Any contact with a therapist is treated as a red flag. There’s also a background check–a lot of people get blocked for failing to mention an arrest. You also can’t be in default over student loans. Another issue is that young people are less adventurous, and maybe a little dumber, than before. Many have already traveled to other countries, while others are immersed in their smartphones. (Oh yes–PC volunteers have to always be reachable by cellphone now, for security reasons.) PC can be hard to distinguish from “voluntourism.”
Why are they “volunteers” rather than normal, permanent employees, like NGOs have? It’s partly a legal distinction–volunteers lack many legal protections that government employees have. Why does it particularly have to be young people? It doesn’t–older people do serve–but this is largely who is available, and if I am right, the system also prioritizes young people who might be recruited into a patronage network (that is now breaking down). This encourages a paternalistic system in which the volunteers are not really treated as adults–their movements are monitored, they have little control over their health decisions (people have been sent home for secretly talking to a therapist online), and PC has to approve their housing (in some cases requiring volunteers to live with host families).
Is PC effective? Hard to say, but many–perhaps most–volunteers are not really wanted on-site, and are given make-work. The organization doesn’t really care what they do, as long as they generate good PR. Do the volunteers encourage pro-American sentiment? Hard to say, most people already have some idea of the USA already. Of course a few volunteers bring bad publicity–there are stories–and the organization has historically had a problem with binge-drinking. From PC’s perspective, the nightmare scenario is when a volunteer dies, not when they get sent home, or fail to accomplish much of anything. The first brings Congressional inquiries.
So, signs of the times, I guess. Despite all this, I do recognize that PC (while it lasts–its days are numbered) can be a good choice for some people. There are few “pure” choices in the world, everything is problematic.
Something just clicked into place. One major obstacle for getting rid of much of the managerial class is that managers like to have fiefdoms and will often try to hire whether it makes sense or not. If you have a method to let them keep trying to hire, that keeps them from seeing anything, then it’s easier to hollow things out. A second obstacle is that a lot of the former salary class people are going to be out of work, and will need something to occupy their time: having masses of people who know how the system works, with tons of free time, and a grudge against the system can be very destabilizing for a society.
Both of these problems can be solved by creating a system which allows managers to continue to posts jobs, and allows people to continue to apply for them (ideally while wasting as much of their time as possible), but never allows the managers to hire anyone. It might not be a mistake then that the “AI hiring tools” are so frustratingly difficult for job applicants to use and end up removing most of the people who are qualified for any given job, while still sending through absurdly unqualified people.
This would make it difficult to impossible for managerial fiefdoms to expand, suck up all the free time the former managers might have had to try to destabilize the system, and allows it all to be done without anyone officially doing anything of the kind. The drawback, of course, is that it ends up breaking the hiring process, which given how many people need corporate jobs, is a fairly important part of our society, for everyone. Having said that, breaking important institutions in order to gain political gain is not a new phenomena….
@Northwind Grandma,
MAiD stands for medical assistance in dying, Canada’s euthanasia programme for terminally ill and/or disabled/chronically ill people who want to die (or can be persuaded they ought to want to die).
They’re trying to extend it to mentally ill people, but are starting to get major pushback.
I think it’s an abomination, and no, I don’t agree to be suicided, in case anyone was wondering.
pygmycory 24
> hopefully a lot of them will find gainful employment doing something productive
I will go out on a limb here and say that each person will have to create her own job.
No one is going to be going around giving away perfectly good jobs to strangers. If one is going to go around giving away perfectly good jobs, it won’t be to strangers — it will be to family, or to friends, or to oneself.
When one thinks about it, creating one’s own job isn’t rocket science. One needs to ask, “What does ‘the other’ need?” First, define ‘the other.’ Then ‘what does he need?’ There is a third part. Who and what and goodwill. One needs goodwill. Don’t be concerned with how one gets paid — that comes after.
Help an old woman across a street. ‘The other’: the old woman. The “what” is how to get across the street without getting run over. Leave the old woman feeling like she is supported. Goodwill. Simple.
Next instance.
Where is a need? One needs to find a need. How does one go about finding a need? Walk around until one sees a need. At least one will get good exercise.
A person is sitting on the ground.
Who? Over there, that person.
What? Build a stool.
How? With goodwill.
You perceive ‘no need’? How is that possible? We all go around with unmet needs.
It doesn’t even have to be a human. A bird has a need. To feed her chicks. Put some seeds out on a regular basis.
Buy a broom. Sweep a sidewalk.
As things fall apart, it will become more obvious ‘who has what needs when.’
I am not being facetious. It *IS* that easy. One ‘needs’ to ask the right questions. If one cannot perceive others’ needs, that person might as well curl up and die, because he is useless, clueless, and good for nothing.
This is how one falls into a job (s)he creates for oneself:
Be a help, or more succinctly, “work” at being a help. Those who help will never be out of a job. That is because there are infinite number of unmet needs (gold nuggets) all over the place, almost lying on the ground waiting to get picked up.
What is the worst that can happen?: In the helping, one gains “job experience.”
“Can I help?” never gets old. Just sayin’.
💨🧹💨Northwind Grandma
Dane County, Wisconsin, USA
Pygmycory, well, I hope so. Pushback against the dystopian policies of the Canadian government hasn’t had a very good track record in recent decades.
Rhydlyd, the underground economy these days is huge; I see it as a subset of the wage class, since its income is precarious and doesn’t usually come with benefits. A great many legal businesses hire under the table these days to get out from under the gargantuan burden of regulations and fees meant to keep domestic employment down (and thus drive down wages). It’s one of the ways that the next economy is coming into being in the husk of the old economy.
Tony, delighted to hear this! It really does make life much easier and better.
Clay, excellent! That strikes me as a very good sign.
Susan, it’s a well written poem, but I’d encourage you to reflect on the assumption that all the power belongs to some small group at the top. That’s a common social mythology these days, and it has two downsides not often grasped. First, it’s a way that people further down the income ladder ignore their own power and actively disempower themselves; second, it’s very convenient as a way to blame the consequences of many people’s actions on a few. Just saying…
Untitled-1, thank you for getting my point! These days a vast share of salary class jobs are pure makework. Consider compliance departments, which exist solely so that one set of cubicle inmates can fill out paperwork certifying to a second set of cubicle inmates that a set of more than Byzantine regulations have been followed. The regulations keep proliferating, not to accomplish anything useful, but to justify hiring more cubicle fauna. LLMs could replace them all in a week.
Raymond, and I appreciate that stories vary. Any interpretation is a matter of generalizations that need to be filled out on the individual level.
Cynthia, I was referring to the euphemistically labeled “Medical Assistance in Dying” (MAiD) program, which is being used with increasing enthusiasm to exterminate Canadian citizens whose health care costs would otherwise be a burden to your socialized medical system. I remember very well when Hitler’s Aktion-T4 program, which wasn’t that different, was routinely listed among his regime’s grave human rights abuses.
Untitled-1, delighted to hear it!
Northwind (if I may), oh, come on, it’s not that bad:

😉
Jon, not with the administrations then and thereafter in power. You’re right that the impact was staved off by stealing from the future, but that’s been standard policy for a very long time now.
Aldarion, Conrad came up the hard way and knew the score.
Charlie, excellent. Aurelien and I disagree about a lot of things but he’s a very smart and perceptive observer and here, as often, he’s not wrong. I wrote about the same weird mental disconnect in another context a while ago:
https://ecosophia.net/dancers-at-the-end-of-time-part-one-the-flight-from-reason/
https://ecosophia.net/dancers-at-the-end-of-time-part-two-facts-are-the-enemies-of-truth/
https://ecosophia.net/dancers-at-the-end-of-time-part-three-a-mortal-splendor/
You’re right that the implosion of salary class identities is going to be one of the major factors here. A great many people have founded their entire sense of self on the internal mythology of the privileged left, seeing themselves as participants in the great march forward toward a shining new world, which would solve all the world’s problems. As that falls apart, it’s going to get colorful.
Mary, exactly. He had no idea that he ought to speak to, you know, library patrons. They’re abstractions; the only real people are members of his own class.
Pyrrhus, while I disagree with Turchin’s claim that that’s the sole driver of decline, it’s certainly a factor, and we’ve got a spectacularly overblown case of it.
Aldarion, granted, but GDP is also being inflated by the same gimmicks that are used to pretend that the rich are genuinely rich.
Northwind, I appreciate the euphemism.
Justin, granted. One of the downsides of being in the kind of airtight bubble the salary class inhabits is that it can only hear itself.
Ambrose, the Peace Corps has long struck me as the apotheosis of Mrs. Jellyby’s grand crusade for the betterment of the natives of Borriobooli-Gha, while her own children and the poor of the neighborhood she lives in desperately need her help. Maybe we can invite some Africans to come here and take care of the social problems our Mrs. Jellybys are too busy to do anything about…
William, I could see it!
@Moishe: Humans do not always consume all resources. They can index their numbers to one single resource. For example, some Eastern Woodland tribes required a young man who wanted to marry to first collect a certain number of doe tails. Together with strong shaming of premarital sex, this ensured the human population could not grow much beyond a stable deer population, no matter how much agricultural land there was available. Others required a young man to kill an enemy warrior before he could marry…
JMG: How does the Salary Class relate to the Managerial Class in your taxonomy? The same?
Once upon a time, when I was working in the nonprofit-homelessness-industrial-complex as a Director, I observed that the majority of employees were complacent, feckless, and were explicitly hostile to change (a.k.a basic “supervision”) that required them to become competent at their jobs. My eventual plan was to slowly dissolve a number of existing jobs, notify the employees that their jobs would no longer exist by a certain date and invite them to reapply for the newly constructed position if they cared to do so. The Executive Director found my strategy to be offensive and unkind. This nonprofit agency (filled with highly emotive, white liberal women in “advocacy” positions who weaponized HR) took in millions of federal and state dollars and earmarked the funds for “salaries” while most of their clients remained homeless (90% remained “unhoused”) due to “systemic inequalities.” They complained about the “struggle” and burnout ad infinitum.
A significant portion of the salaried class are in the business of profiting off of the suffering of the wage class and the welfare class. Their parasitic behavior was the largest “systemic inequality” that I witnessed while working there.
The irony of the “Martha Vineyards’ crowd* … is that, apparently.. a significant % of said ‘high-falutin’ residents of said island have been bitten, and thus afflicted, by alpha-gafl laden ticks! I’m curious .. what say them??? .. are they going to blame it all on those fn TEXANS ?!! * servers themrightfor snubbing their affluent noses at anyone who doesn’t jibe by their notion of ‘correctness’.. NO PROTEIN FOR YOUUUUU! .. IDIOTS!
JMG,
One of the huge make-work operations in local government ( cities, counties etc) is the entire set of staff that have grown to cater to the needs of elected officials. 16 years ago when my wife first came to the wastewater agency she just retired from, the elected officials were part time members of the community. They had other jobs so just spent part of their time in meetings and such so only a single clerk or so was needed in addition to the leader of the district when dealing with elected officials.
When she retired last year all the elected officials had become full time with each of them having staff. They required that the agency ( the wastewater district my wife ran) to have multiple more employees that did things like maintaining calendars, creating minutes and reports, providing legal advise, etc. etc. etc. These elected officials were no longer local farmers and business people but full time bureaucrats who felt they had a need for all these things.
The real problem is that the people in the agency that the elected officials ( ones holding the pursestrings) deal with every day are the people doing make-work jobs and not those doing the real business of the agency. Thus when money is tight those close to the elected officials are the ones telling them what to cut to save money. Which is certainly not themselves or make-work associates. That is why it is always the street repair crews and park employees that get cut when budgets are tight and not useless paper pushers.
JMG
I heard an interesting take from a particular live streamer/political commentator that pertains to the class dynamics that I’d like to get your thoughts on. Here’s a paraphrase of what he said:
“You’re not being oppressed by the top 2% of society. You’re being oppressed by the bottom 2% of society. Yes. And the bottom 2% of society have caused all of the all of the tangible problems in your lives. The top 2% people cause a lot of problems long-term, yes, but the immediate everyday issues that that the average person runs into, those are caused by the bottom 2% of society. Those are the people robbing you, breaking into your car, etc. Last time I checked, it’s not Elon Musk stealing bikes and living outside the 7-Eleven high on drugs trying to stab people. Jeff Bezos has never come into an IHOP and had to been removed by the police. Jeff Bezos has never tried to steal a bike or poop in a Walmart, as far as I know.
Whenever the homeless schizophrenic corners you and causes problems at the 7-Eleven, this person is instantaneously and manifestly making your life worse on a direct and tangible scale in comparison than whatever idiot you think is in the Epstein files. We are oppressed by that bottom 2%. Why is it that you have to talk to an associate to get the toothpaste? It’s not because of Jeff Bezos. It’s because of the bottom 2%. The more immediate problems are the bottom 2%. They absolutely are.”
In a sense I agree. I would argue that there seems to be an alliance of sorts with the salary class and a certain subsect of the welfare class in order to oppress/suppress the wage class. At least that would explain why so many in the salary class are so enthusiastic about defending criminals criminal violence.
Sorry for the typos .. but you’all get the gist. Oh … and in response to Maxine Roger’s #1 .. I too have expended much time/effort into maximizing my efforts producing various produce from my garden 9’x 11′ x 2 plot/s: tomatoes, cucumbers, squash, spinach, carrots, chilies, cane berries, onions, cilantro/coriander, sugar peas .. plus a few select ornamentals .. which helps to keep me sane, in spite of the social/political/geopolitical whirlwinds we’re all subjected to …
On the subject of decadent salary class business ecosystems imploding, I just walked past a mobile pet grooming van parked in an affluent residential part of my city. Bright, neon pink, cutesy logo, and LLM generated graphics of pets festooned all over like a series of garish Christmas ornaments. If ugly frivolities like these make themselves scarce in the near to mid future, there may be a silver lining to these upcoming hard times. I really, really am sick beyond belief of the hyper feminine and faux-childlike vibe that the salary class is so fond of.
I wonder when the last time some of the salary class saw the movie Brazil … probably only the technicians and lower level workers appreciate the genius of Gilliam.
Plastic Surgery Disasters and Kill the Poor by the Dead Kennedys, along with Holiday in Cambodia, have been ringing in my mind since I read this.
Hi John Michael,
It’s worthwhile noting that the proprietor class (with the ongoing attack on small business), has been slammed face down into the ground, and now sits with the wage class. I said to someone the other day, who was clearly not feeling well, a gentle reminder that I don’t have sick leave and so if I don’t work, there’s no pay. Hmm.
People kind of focus on government debt, but my belief is that corporate and household debt is equally big. The essential reality with such increasing debt, is that often it is used to disguise the fact that the enterprise or activity being financed, makes no sense whatsoever. I’ve felt that as the limits of the debt story are reached, and we’re near that point, or maybe have even gone past it, a lot of useless activity will be discarded. Oh the screams, but I have to work hard for mad cash, and people see results and pay for the work, or they don’t continue the arrangement. It’s not a leisurely and relaxed experience, put it that way.
As a data point which may interest you. I watch the traffic statistics on my website, and noted that maybe a month or two back, the data scraping for text to feed into the arty-fish-al double speak models, suddenly stopped. With probably eleven million words written over the past dozen years, the site was a fat target and I physically incurred the cost of that massive increase in traffic, put it that way. Not a fan. Anywhoo, there are whispers and rumours circulating that the folks who do that work, have run out of cash, so it is interesting to see how that will play out. A very cheeky belief would be that public offerings to buy in, are perhaps a way to find enough chumps to dump the dog poop onto, before the liquidators arrive, or someone asks for a return on the investment? Dunno, just a wild guess there. Probably not a bad way for this arty-fish-al stuff to disappear excess liquidity from the system and this will pound the daylights out of the benefits of the salary and investor class. Pure and wild speculation there, but could be the way things work out. Dunno.
Cheers
Chris
On MAID: It may amuse some to know that our basic income tax form here in Canada is the T4.
We had salary class 9/11 in the latter years of the 2000s, when the spike in oil prices created an immense demand for labor in the oil patch. People without 4-year degrees out-earned people with bachelors degrees by a large margin, and wages at places like McDonalds and Tim Hortons rose so high that interprovincial migration spiked to serve McDoubles and the brown liquid Tim Hortons calls coffee. Recall the tropes about black Americans and fried chicken (remember that fried chicken was extraordinarily expensive when these tropes started) – the exact same language was deployed against noveau rich wage class people. To be fair, yes, a lot of young men did sign loans for 80,000 dollar pickup trucks while under the influence of alcohol and other drugs at 2AM in a Calgary Ford dealership, but this was the exception, not the rule. Now, the Canadian government has a dedicated immigration firehose aimed at the mining industry to ensure the specter of high working class wages ever haunts corporate Canada again.
These days, the wage class has been hit hard with the immigration firehose – 20 years ago, when I was a teenager, it was easy to get a job and hard to lose one, I remember ragequitting my first job (I made burgers at Dairy Queen) over a teenage romance issue, then asking for it back a few weeks later and being rehired because I was (mostly) reliable. I haven’t been to that Dairy Queen since I quit for real, but I suspect that nearly 100% of the staff are recent arrivals from India.
For those who care about MAID (euthanasia) in Canada:
https://epcc.ca/canadas-euthanasia-law-needs-a-complete-review/
petition asking for a review of the current law on grounds that it is violated in practice, it discriminates against disabled people, and is generally causing a lot of harm.
@JMG, then its past time we got our act together, isn’t it? Late is better than never.
Brandi, I use several different overlapping sets of labels to discuss America’s caste system. The managerial class is roughly the upper half, by income, of the salary class.
Nicky, thank you for a perfect autopsy of the way the current system embodies waste and failure.
Polecat, I wonder how many of them have actually been bitten, and how many have embraced that status as a way of being special. I saw a lot of people take up gluten intolerance for that reason; my late wife, who was severely allergic to gluten among several other things, used to fume sometimes at the way their swaggering demands for privilege made life difficult for those with genuine food issues.
Clay, an excellent point! This would be a genuine use for LLMs — provide each elected official with an electronic administrative assistant who can smile and nod and tell them how smart and wonderful they are. It would be a lot cheaper than hiring people for the same task.
Anon, that’s a step in the right direction, but it doesn’t go anything like far enough. You’re being oppressed, if you want to think of it that way, by everyone in society, including yourself. That’s especially true in a crowded society like this one, where any action anyone performs necessarily impinges on other people. That said, you’re correct that the salary class and the welfare class are allied; that’s why the wage class and the investment class increasingly are finding common ground.
Derpherder, a mobile pet grooming van — yeah, that may just be close to the apotheosis of salary class decadence. I know what you mean about the current aesthetic — it comes across as though a great many privileged women have decided to spoil their inner children rotten rather than giving them the spanking they deserve.
Justin, depends on how long it’s been since never. I remember “Holiday in Cambodia” tolerably well — my punk rocker girlfriend in college was a big fan of the DKs.
Chris, every day brings us closer to crunch time, yeah. Interesting about the website — and yes, I’m quite sure the whole point of the IPOs is to cash out and load the stocks onto as many suckers as possible before the ground opens up beneath them.
Justin, yeah, we got hit with that earlier, but with similar effect.
Pygmycory, well, I hope it gets traction.
Justin Patrick Moore 31
> Lowering our expectations of what we can do in terms of travelling
Thankfully (it’s about time) (at long last), we will see people traveling closer to home, what I call “regionally.” There are so many interesting places within driving distance, or on a weekend outing (Friday and Saturday nights’ away). Traveling regionally helps the businesses of folks nearby rather than far away. I think JMG has mentioned that air travel, either is already on the wane, or will be shortly.
Personally, nothing good comes from flying—humans have no business being that high up. Same for space travel. All airplanes and space travel are are artificial environments.
CADFAEL
Every few years, I absolutely love re-watching the murder-mystery Cadfael TV series (streaming). It is set in, I believe, the 1200s England/Wales border. It was produced from 1994 to 1998. The sets and clothes are wonderful to behold—everything wood, all colors a shade of gray—easy on the eyes. I seem to remember the show was shot in Hungary. Actor Derek Jacobi plays Cadfael. I bring this up because in the 1200s, their methods of travel were walking, donkey, or horse, on rutted dirt roads—nothing paved. Back then, most travel was local, not even regional. (However, there seems to be a canal and boats in the series.)
I used to love traveling regionally. Getting too old. There are more than enough fascinating places to visit on weekend trips, wherever one lives; local history and the like.
💨🪵🪑🔘💨Northwind Grandma
Dane County, Wisconsin, USA
It is perhaps ironic, if that is the right word, that the salaried class has done so well it has not been particularly difficult for them to achieve something akin to the financial independence of the gentry of old, if they are disciplined and frugal. Yet, from what I gather, this is not a common path?
Even with concern over the viability of the stock market, acquiring a good sized well built off grid house with a large garden and perhaps an accessory dwelling to rent out or offer to a relative / friend, is something that can be achieved if on a good salary. Pair that with, say, a small apartment block in the same town… it should be a comfortable enough lifestyle, albeit not an extravagant one. A good basis if you wish to retain status during decline, maybe. Small town patrician.
JMG: Ok, yes, that’s what I thought. Pardon me. The thing is pretty horrific but I might wind up being grateful for it in the end anyway. Well, briefly, ha ha.
David P. 37
> the slogan “Yesterday: Desk. Today: Workbench”
I would love to see that advertisement. This is, indeed, the way to go. Workbench-people have a bright, bright future. (Maybe “workbench people” is a thing.)
‼️Awesome‼️
I wish I were younger (73). Oh well, next life maybe.
You youngsters, be electricians, plumbers, drywallers, cooks, and seamstresses (my top five). By the way, drywalling is REALLY hard to master, to get it just right.
Writer, seamen, roofer, car mechanic, farmer, arborist, etc. There are zillions of choices—go for it‼️If arty-facial ill-telligence cannot do it, and if it sounds interesting, find a master with whom you can apprentice. Or even a journeyman.
💨🔩⚙️🪓🛠️🪚🔨🗜️🪵📏💨Northwind Grandma
Dane County, Wisconsin, USA
Northwind: Regarding your reply to me – the part where you said: “Or, maybe, whenever I see this particular writer’s name, I will skip reading the entry altogether.”
That’s a good idea. Please do that.
JMG (no. 75), what in the Dickens…? By the way, there is also Americorps.
Mr. Greer, thank you for another excellent post. The logical question to ask is “What will actually happen next to all those people who got laid off?” Some of these stories have begun circulating around the internet and are truly shocking. One woman noted that she went from making $200,000 a year to being homeless in just eight months after running through her severance package and being evicted from her rental house (it’s amazing to think that she actually spent $17,000 a month with virtually no savings for so long, but the cost of living in many American cities is now so absurdly high that it’s not too difficult to do that). After applying to hundreds of jobs, she never found another replacement because it’s an open secret now that virtually all the “jobs” posted online are scams meant to take people’s personal information and sell it to others. This is the sort of situation that leaves people so desperate that an entire growth industry of scams has appeared on cue to exploit them. Another laid off woman reportedly wired $30,000 of her own money to a new “company” as part of a scam “to pay to get a job”. It’s hard to think of a better example of insanity (defined as “doing the same thing over and over again while expecting a different result”) than what the laid off are currently doing: applying to literally thousands of jobs that don’t exist and even paying their own money for the opportunity to not get a job. May I ask what you think will ultimately happen to all these laid off folks? Will they eventually just have to start working with their hands producing goods and services that are actually needed by people?
I don’t know to whom the quote should be attributed , but in the current state of the world: “And when all else fails, they take us to war.”
Hi JMG, My comment is not directly related to this essay but tangentially so. I’m pretty sure that Bolt is a taxi, ride share company (similar to Uber as far as I can tell. I don’t use any of them).
I’m usually in Thailand and they have a presence here but supposedly are in trouble due to thousands and thousands of driver complaints and compliance problems. A decision whether to renew or cancel their business license is currently under review. I say supposedly because it’s very imaginable for them to “pay” their way out of trouble while making minor changes to clean up their act. I hope I’m wrong on that.
That’s the kind of business we often get when you have very few employees and fire all those who supposedly do nothing.
Also Ryan Breslow was an early investor, not a founder of the company. And as we all know investors, private equity and venture capital types know how to run every type of business.
Trump just signed a memorandum of understanding with Iran, which stops the conflict in the Middle East and lifts decades long economic sanctions on Iran and hands full control of the Strait of Hormuz to Iran. A defeat for the American empire.
Hardly through one third of the post i paused on this phrase:
“…generating a steady stream of fashionable faux-problems so it can pretend to try to solve them, and pay themselves lavishly for making the effort…”
…and said to myself, this sounds like the invention of ai and the silicon valley class!
i was glad to read on to find you raising the subject of ai itself – though coming at it from a different angle, as you usually do. ;^)
closing on the theme of ” a slow but potent undertow” rings true. one hypothesis i would love to see put to serious research and discussed more openly is the shift the west has made from running on an EROEI of, what? 50 : 1 or 80 : 1 …do i hear 100 : 1? to running on an EROEI of something like 5 : 1 or less. it’s as though someone has poured sugar in the gas tank of modern industrial society. it never comes up in the media, as energy illiteracy reigns. what’s more, either no one in power is aware (hard to believe, but possibly true!) or, they just dare not lift that curtain and let it be known, lest people act in an informed way!
anyway, it’s not my job to write the book on this. but it’s fascinating to have this as a point of reference as current events unfold. it explains a lot!
looking forward to the next post in this thread.
peace
“Only in the last few decades, however, has that rule really started to slip, and when that happened the reasons for punishment were restricted to a narrow range of violations of salary-class cultural norms. Punishing anyone for failing to do a job adequately was still mostly off the table, and “failing upwards” remained standard.”
Vladimir Shlapentok in “Soviet ideologies in the period of glasnost” (1989) makes a strong case that exactly what you describe here was the distinctive feature of the Brezhnev era (the 20 years leading up to the crisis that perestroika tried and failed to solve). There was broad impunity for the elites and about the only way a member of the elite could be punished was for whistleblowing. This also resulted in the emergence of factions within the ruling elites, factions that so thoroughly put factional interest about general elite interest that the entire system split apart. In the Soviet Union, this took the form of separatist nationalism. In end-stage Chinese empires, it usually takes the form of regional warlordism. In both the Soviet and Qing Chinese cases, separatist factions aligned with and were supported by powerful external interests. The all-time champion for this has to be the Polish sejm (parliament) of the 1700s.
Cererean, it’s almost unheard of. You do sometimes get a salary class person with the brains to rake in money, live frugally, and then walk out of cubicle world to do something more interesting with their lives, but they have to face the united peer pressure of their entire class to do it.
Ambrose, granted, but there are better ways to do that, too.
Chad, that’s a huge question, of course. Some of them will land on their feet and find a different way of making a living. Some will struggle, fail, and die. Some will become part of a new permanent underclass. Some will become raw material for religious cults and political factions. A glance back at what happened to much of the investment class after the 1929 crash will give you a decent first approximation.
MOD, nah, that’s becoming too expensive. We’ll discuss that down the road a bit.
Jreev, no, it’s a different firm. The Bolt I have in mind is Bolt Financial, and produces hardware that allows stores to do one-click checkouts.
Anon, as I noted once it became clear the Iranians weren’t going to collapse, the only viable move for the US was to find an exit ramp as soon as possible, and that’s now happened. The point of the war was to provide plausible political cover for removing sanctions on Iranian oil, since the USA fracking boom is winding down and more oil — any oil, from anywhere — is desperately needed to keep the global economy from imploding. The business in Venezuela? Same thing.
Maclean, excellent! Too few people have a clue about the immense impact of net energy on all this. The net energy of light sweet crude from shallow Texas wells was around 300:1 — now you know why the US could, for a while, afford such fantastic extravagances. We’ll talk about that in detail laer on.
Jessica, it’s the inevitable endgame of a bureaucratic system in decline. Back in the peak oil days, Dmitry Orlov used to make excellent points about the likelihood that the US would collapse the way the Soviet Union did; those arguments have gotten no less cogent since that time.
I remember when I woke up to the breast cancer racket. Breast cancer and cancer in general have been “fought” for a century. Even the American Cancer Society admits that breast cancer rates rose 1 percent a year from 2012 – 2021. The Swiss Medical Board recommended in 2014 that women stop getting mammograms because of the harm they may potentially cause to breast tissue and overdiagnosis/overtreatment. There are many chronic diseases used as virtue signals by the upper classes who pretend to be searching for a cure but are clearly doing no such thing. Sadly, that’s not even the half of it. In 2010, the Susan G. Komen foundation got caught filing legal trademark opposition after opposition against any smaller breast cancer charity it could find that used “for the cure” in its messaging. Komen’s CEO makes 684,000 a year. They even tried to trademark the color pink for their own organization’s use only. One year, Komen partnered with KFC in the Buckets for the Cure campaign. Deep-fried factory-farmed chicken parts for the cure . . . nice. The pinkwashing that took the cake, however, was an ad by Baker Hughes, a literal fracking company. You know, like one of those operations that pumps the ground full of carcinogens and poisons groundwater for thousands of years to squeeze the last few drops of fuel from a patch of rock underneath a former boreal forest? The ad said “doing our bit for the cure” and featured a pink drill bit.
William @23,”
“The remarkably creepy part is that they seem to have no idea that they are actually describing creating a new form of slave. It’s also remarkably creepy how almost none of them ever stop and ask “if these are intelligent, what obligations do their creators and the people who interact with them have?””
That was the premise of BattleStar Galactica. The Cylons were annoyed and they didn’t have The Three Laws imprinted on them.
Denninger has a takedown of SpaceX. He’s not a believer.
https://market-ticker.org/akcs-www?post=255574#google_vignette
JMG,
Well yes, and all the bright things of our age shall continue with the whatever that makes them believe how special they truly are, and that they are – indeed the center to which all existence points. Or whatever. In my life, I had the wonder of someone who became a member of a club, a rather unique one, that has at its core the notion of controllers and the controlled. Well, wanting to be an controlled this little one thought I would be controlled – and where the controlling ended – who the f*ck knows. This is a age of such silly things, and the really powerless ones assuming such authority that is fully such sad humor. Nevertheless – out goes the idiot. And a moment of some humor for me reflecting on that moment in Braveheart where ancestor Edward I is walking that one – to the window… ‘Who is this person who thinks I need his…” Indeed, this is an age filled with them, and they are legion. Well, at least for now.
Good blog.
JMG,
For most of my career I had my own shop in the subcontract metal manufacturing business. Over time it was small and then bigger and small again. I have known and done business with many other shops over the years. Almost always ,the genesis of a good and growing business is the stage where it is the owner plus 3 or so dedicated employees and perhaps his wife keeping the books. At this stage the business is very efficient, can afford a few pieces of good equipment and turns out high quality that builds it reputation and creates further growth.
Eventually if things go right it the business grows to the size where it has to have a full time HR person handling health insurance, hiring, firing, workers comp etc. After that point it is often downhill as administrative costs grow while employee productivity goes downhill.
If I was king of the USA I would figure out a way to mazimize the. number of 5 person business’s by making that size a sweet spot as far as minimized fees, taxes and regulations. No administrative class needed.
Chris 38
> MD would be considered salary class
I am so old (73), I remember when an MD, usually male, was a sole proprietor. In the 1960s and earlier.
Each MD was a business unto himself (hardly any partnerships; no groups); he made housecalls, too — I remember those. He had his own wood-worked, fairly posh office, several rooms, professional but comfortable furniture. He often lived modestly with his family in an upstairs flat or apartment.
It was rather insulting if an MD was “on salary”— it meant he couldn’t make it on his own — hence, it hardly ever happened. Things changed in the 1970s, when corporate males started to look down upon female nurses. Males corporate-types pushed out female nurses. It was in the 1970s that healthcare in America went to pot, I remember my mother saying, who was a visiting nurse, — she said males and their corporations started viewing people’s ill health as THEIR cash cow,— the means by which they could become rich. Yes, the decision was conscious. Non-MD corporate males explicitly wanted huge profits so they could afford mansions. My mudder was right— everything did turn to shale after female nurses were no longer in charge. Up until the 1970s, female nurses ruled the roost; they were the informal bosses, where MDs had to consult “the nurses” before they did anything substantial.
💨🩺👨🏼⚕️💨Northwind Grandma
Dane County, Wisconsin, USA
For some the sky has fallen, for others it’s business as usual. It’s a recession if you have a job but a depression if you lost your job. I think hubby might have the UFO Chronicles, I know we have Twilights Last Gleaming, I’ll have to get it. I’m open to every take on it, especially from you. I’m guessing you’re going to say they are part of the unseen spiritual realm like Jacques Vallees who was Spielberg close Encounters consultant.
TylerA 43
> He who shall not work shall not eat
It wasn’t only Lenin saying that. That was the way of the world. It just “was.” Genealogist-speaking here: Back in say, 1860 New York City, if one didn’t work, one starved. Usually the husband worked, but not always. It depended. Guess how much work got done. A lot.
Starvation was a fact. Same as in 1870, 1880, 1890, 1900, 1910, 1920, 1930. Then FDR happened.
Same as in 1850, 1840, 1830, 1820, 1810, 1800, 1790, and as far back in time one wants to go.
Speaking of the USA.
My Uncle Jack, born 1927, told me a story about his mother Florence (my grandmother) while she still lived at home with her mother Emma and six sisters.
Florence was born about 1895. She was a middle sister. Around 1915, Emma’s husband was a ne’er-do-well drunk, and left Emma and the seven sisters to starve, and/or become destitute, thrown out onto the street. It was a neighbor, one “Mary Fuller,” who fed and housed the eight, and made sure they were okay. As a genealogist, the name Mary Fuller has been impossible to trace, so I never was able to identify her.
A hundred years ago,— a thousand years ago,— 10,000 years ago, neighbors looked after neighbors. No money changed hands. Neighborhoods looked after their own people. As a village, at some future time, we will return to those old ways because the old ways worked. JMG, in different language, has said as much. What JMG calls something like community, I call neighbors.
There was no cash-exchange/money-based welfare system before FDR; there will be none in the future. Monied welfare systems are a blip in time. Before welfare dollars, people held it together person-to-person. Worry not.
FDR, LBJ, Ninny Pelouzzi, and Chack Schoomner, “monied”-welfare was always a racket that they were able to siphon off dollars for themselves and their comrades.
I was there when LBJ came to power. There was no worse money-grubber than LBJ. Although Ninny and Chack are close behind LBJ. The whole lot of them,
Demoncrats,
want to increase all manner of taxes. In addition, Demoncrats want to snuff out small business, including micro-businesses like mom-and-pop partnerships.
Starving people WERE a fact of life in Lenin’s time. They ARE a fact of life now. They will be a fact of life forevermore. Famine has always occurred. Fewer births will help. If anyone promises “no starvation in this region,” they are lying.
All one can do is make sure one’s neighbor does not starve. Handing out cash, anywhere, anytime, changes absolutely nothing in the long-run.
💨👨🏼⚖️🍳💨Northwind Grandma
Dane County, Wisconsin, USA
Oh I remember that podcast well. These days I have to do a lot of driving so my brain is awash in podcasts. I can put the intonation to those words. Including the ouch-es and the chuckles. You dear sir are the doom prophets revenge.
Oh, I should mention the reason for my constant driving. I have to juggle the triplet responsibility of doing a blue collar worker re-qualification, with a farmers night school ( where we get to be taught, amongst other things like mychoriza cultures in soil, how to make alcohol ) and collapsing our family assets to a manageable size.
Any lists of good podcast recommendations would be welcome.
Oh, and I might be able to add another set of words to that Eurabiamania example; Folks if you are ever on the receiving, or even just grazing, end of JMG saying in a reserved and polite tone:
“I would strongly recommend ….”
Treat that as though it is flashing CODE RED and air raid sirens are going off in the background. It need not be words of doom, but it will certainly be important.
Make a mental equivalent of a full salute and silently execute with extreme diligence. You will benefit.
What do you think will happen to the Proprietor class as America’s future unfolds?
For that matter, what happened to diminish the proprietor class? Was it simply competing with the salary class, and thus mostly eliminated?
Where I live in Canada, independent contractors routinely offer to settle their bills by allowing you to pay them in cash–Besides mid-to large-ticket maintenance, I also know and patronize an egg-lady, and give her back the egg cartons when I’ve used the eggs. I have a bread lady that stops by once a week. I make cherry jam and haskap jam from my trees and bushes, and trade them for other peoples’ foods. The Farmer’s Market is now at parity with the local grocery, and sometimes below. The local barter network doesn’t support local residents entirely, but it’s growing. I hope we can grow into a future where people can grow food, make and fix things. Bartering is a way to get to know our neighbours, and to become known.
PygmyCory–please, never agree to MAID! If anyone here has not yet read it, please look up PC’s awesome story, ‘The Gift of Perfect Knowledge’ under the pseudo-pseudonym ‘worm bookworm’ on ‘An Archive Of Our Own.’
https://archiveofourown.gay/works/56479069?view_full_work=true
Anyone who can do a story like that deserves applause and support, not death!
Also, while we are talking, please search up articles on ‘leucovorin and autism.’ This is a slightly different version of the vitamin, folic acid.
Keep up the good work PC!
JMG # 48:
Abuse of class privilege seems a good explanation of Pavlovian angry reaction I’ve sometimes seen in some middle class people, when you remember them there are still social classes. Thanks.
————————————-
Aldarion # 63:
Well, Conrad wasn’t a very optimist writer. Maybe his own life made him a pesimist man (indeed, a Polish who wrote in English).
————————————-
Pygmycory # 73:
Oops! Any attempt to allow “voluntary” euthanasia to mentally ill people is beyond a healthy ethical view…Unfortunately, here we’ve got another gentle euthanasia law, which for example allowed recently “voluntary” death of a disabled young woman who also suffered a borderline personality disorder (cough). Thanks to our “Progressive”
government…
————————————
JMG # 89:
You’ve remembered “Holiday in Cambodia”. I remember an old rap band here, quoted that song in one of their songs, during early ‘90s, as a very sarcastic tribute…It was a song about known murders in Spain, with a heck of very dark humo: “Veraneo en Puerto Hurtado”(by Defcon2). Well, Puerto Hurraco was a small town who suffered an awful massive killing, and “veraneo” is like “vacation”, so do the math..
JMG and Commentariate,
Concerning MAID,
Our government publishes a yearly data report:
https://www.canada.ca/en/health-canada/services/publications/health-system-services/annual-report-medical-assistance-dying-2024.html
And just today a parliamentary committee recommended against expanding MAID to people who are only applying due to mental illness : https://globalnews.ca/news/11909486/medical-assistance-in-dying-mental-illness-2/
According to the data report the majority of people using MAID are basically Boomers with cancer. Also over 95% of the users in Canads are listed as Caucasian.
Intenational data suggeats most recipients are of high economic status: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10581715/
End of life healthcare is also very expensive, especially surgeries and pallative care. Expensive treatments can prolong someones life regardless if the quality of those last months and years of life are awful. I beleive people accessing MAID are saving the government money in end of life care.
I don’t think this brightens the picture at all. Being a worker in my mid forties it certainly feels a dismal amd undignified option. Something about working and paying into the system that then encourages you to salute and be a good citizen by choosing MAID once your too useless and expensive.
As a UK based person, our situation is likely to be broadly the same as the US’s but with some differences. My primary concerns around the use of AI to replace staff (or justify the replacement) is that we are going to see a brutal couple of years with potentially millions or people added to the welfare bill. That subject is already a hot topic in politics over here with the general acceptance that the bill is too high and too generous at present but no one wants to make the painful choices to solve that, adding millions more while removing those tax receipts from government income is likely to create a “bit of a sticky wicket” as cricket lovers like to say. Additionally, people tend to react badly when they suddenly find themselves on the painful end of a financial adjustment. The ongoing drama in politics and the hyping of the migrant crisis (not that there isn’t a crisis, but its definitely getting a lot of extra attention at the moment), is likely to be a volatile mix. When the UK de-industrialised during the late-70s and 80s, we saw a lot riots, street violence and the like, this is likely to go the same way. As is usual in these cases, once you throw the board in the air, there is no guarantee how the pieces are going to land. So while some may relish watching the salary class “get theirs”, they might not be too happy with how that plays out.
“It’s been pointed out repeatedly, however, that the US (for example) could give every poor citizen a comfortable income plus benefits for much less than it costs to run the current social-welfare system.”
As I understand it** this is the main argument advanced by advocates for a Basic Income system, who argue such a system can do away with the entire bureaucratic apparatus for determining individual eligibility, and therefore be much more cost effective.
As best as I can make out, this idea falls on deaf ears to those who believe reward should be paired with effort, a very basic cultural underpinning of the “American Dream”.
This is why your basic thesis – that simply doing away with large chunks of the bureaucratic system as part of this new “unstoppable Progress” story that is bound up with AI is a do-able American project – makes more sense to me than the hopes some pin on a system which might inadvertently reward the undeserving, such as Basic Income.
** back in 2010 or 2012, for a year or so, I was getting advocacy emails from a local Basic Income advocacy group, which repeatedly hammered on this cost-effectiveness point – direct payments vs large bureaucracy must be cheaper.
I forgot to mention this book I saw earlier this week at work by Henry Snow. It’s called Control Science: How Management Made the Modern World.
“Whether on Caribbean plantations in the seventeenth century or in Amazon warehouses today, the powerful have constantly developed new techniques to control workers—and new justifications for doing so. Ideas of control perfected on the factory floor have expanded to dictate our personal lives, political rights, national policy, and the global economy.
Seventeenth-century intellectuals such as William Petty and John Locke argued that human beings were selfish machines who had to be controlled for their own good. A century later, Jeremy and Samuel Bentham tried to do exactly that with their infamous Panopticon prison. When nineteenth-century Japanese elites imported European factory technologies, they came up with new theories of political control to justify this development. After the Second World War, the General Electric Corporation created an internal propaganda department to fight unions, then pitched that propaganda to the country with the help of an actor, the future President Ronald Reagan. Extending these practices, billionaires today dream of extending the algorithmic control of Amazon warehouses into every corner of our lives.
Blending intellectual, economic, and labor history, Control Science is a thrilling and lucid work of history. Henry Snow reveals how common sense about work, the economy, and human nature was fabricated and must now be challenged.”
The album Plastic Surgery Disasters from DK has the song “Well Paid Scientist” … my selection for the week.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xxmxknLCg_g&list=RDxxmxknLCg_g&start_radio=1
You’re a well-paid scientist
You only talk in facts
You know you’re always right
‘Cause you know how to prove it step by step
A PhD to show you’re smart
With textbook formulas
But you’re used up
Just like a factory hand
[Chorus]
Something is wrong here
You won’t find it on a shelf
You’re well-paid, you’re well-trained
You’re tied to a rack
[Verse 2]
Company cocktails, gotta go
Say the right thing
Don’t fidget, jockey for position
Be polite
In the pyramid you hate
Sip that scotch
Get that raise
This ain’t no party at all
You might also like
Winnebago Warrior
Dead Kennedys
Buzzbomb
Dead Kennedys
California Über Alles
Dead Kennedys
[Chorus]
Something is wrong here
You won’t find it on a shelf
You’re well-paid, you’re well-trained
You’re tied to a rack
[Verse 3]
Cringe and tense up
Grind your teeth
And wipe your sweaty palms
Close your windows driving past
The low-life company bar
They’re making fun of you
Ha!
[Bridge 1]
Ah, even you
You’ve gotta punch the clock
Why don’t you punch your boss?
Ah, even you
You just punch the clock
Too scared to punch your boss
[Bridge 2]
When will you crack?
When will you crack?
When will you open your eyes
Open your eyes, open your eyes?
[Verse 3]
Pull up to your sterile home, you’re drained
Bite the heads off of your kids
Chew them well; they taste like you
Just slam the door
Assigned here ’cause your company owns the land
All your colleagues live there, too
Private guards in golf carts
Keep you safe at home
[Chorus]
Something is wrong here
You won’t find it on a shelf
You’re well-paid, you’re well-trained
You’re tied to a rack
[Refrain]
When will you crack?
When will you crack?
When will you crack?
When will you crack?!
[Outro]
The dark, shattered underbelly
Of the American dream
Avoid it like the plague
It stares you from your bathroom mirror
Drown!
Also, I had a dream last night where I asked this lady who was tending a bar if she had a metafilter. She showed me some different phones on the bar counter and I wondered about the metafilter being applied.
I made this meme based on the dream:
https://imgur.com/a/mTqSQSC
@Northwind Grandma et al: I totally agree about travelling locally and (bio)regional living. I wrote a whole article about it, and lowering our expectations around vacation… I really love Maine and the PNW, so the desire, though, to be able to travel is still there. I like to see new places… but I have to also live by what I write about. I’d like to further explore this country of the United States and beyond… but extensive travel and big trips every year aren’t in the deck at this time. Also, I think when people used to go on big trips it was a once in a lifetime thing. That was certainly how I felt when my stepdaughter was living in Hawaii on the Navy base (she also had a grandfather on Oahu, and some aunts and cousins -she is part Hawaiian, so she herself had been a few times with her father). Having people to stay with in Maine, Hawaii, and Seattle were some of the reasons we were able to go in the first place, otherwise just the cost of lodging would have been too much. But I never need to go back to Hawaii. It was nice in the places where the rest of the tourists weren’t as prominent, but finding those spots was sometimes challenging.
We’d still like to go to Scotland, Wales, Iceland… I’d really like to visit the Asatru Temple and see what a modern pagan living place of worship like that is like. Japan would be cool too… in the meantime we camp in KY and visit the national park of Mammoth Cave which I am really looking forward to. It’s only a few hours from us, and I’ve been wanting to go back since I was a kid. Got two different tours of the cave planned: one by lantern that starts at night, and the River Styx tour that goes deep down to the underground rivers that helped form the caves.
Here are my articles for anyone who wants to take a gander:
https://justinpatrickmoore.substack.com/p/getting-away-from-it-all
https://www.sothismedias.com/home/getting-away-from-it-all
It also came out in the most recent issue of New Maps for anyone who subscribes.
Pygmycory: I’m sorry, I missed that you had said something to me. Those of you who oppose MAID and the expansion thereof are on solid ground indeed. However, since I am very much considering accessing it myself in the event of the expansion to include mentally ill people taking place, I don’t believe I will be writing my MP, signing petitions, or doing anything else in opposition to it. I’m sorry.
“Institutions will try to preserve the problem to which they are the solution.”(Shirky)
I’m afraid I’m going to agree with this idea, very appropiate to explain attitudes and behaviors (“modus operandi”), not only within large bureaucratic organizations, but also good to depict how some private charities and NGOs work in real world. Indeed, sometimes, some of them depend heavily of lavish state-funded subsidies…so to some extent, they’re half-statal bureaucracies.
For example, in my country there’s a NGO whose main purpose is to denounce and prosecute racist attitudes and behaviors. I won’t say its full name to avoid hypothetical problems for me (ahem). I think racism and its “brother” xenophobia, are real problems here, like in another European countries. However, I sometimes think in a mischievous way, this NGO wouldn’t exist anymore, if every “white” Spaniard (maybe due to magic or a miracle) stopped to speak/do racist words and things. This risk isn’t real, because unfortunately, there are always and every day a lot of racist/xenophobical occurences in the usual far right echo chambers, in “social” media and MSM alike here. I also think, in the strange case racism would dwindle soon (?), this problem could be “solved” growing today “hate speech” list by Law.
By the way, it’s interesting to check some Muslim and/or Black men here usually speak against women and gay people…Oh, “they’ve got their customs, so we must respect them”. However, given these sexist and/or homophobical attitudes and behaviors aren’t commited by white Spaniard men, often our brave feminists and gay rights activists keep quiet (cough). Of course, every migrant men are “beings of light”.
I had dropped out of university (couldn’t handle the math) and got a diploma in drafting at the local technical college. While working as a draftsman at the lowest rung of the salary class something happened that persuaded me to go back to university and get a degree.
For some reason our employer (a municipality) could not pay our salaries into our bank accounts that month, so we were instructed to get paid in cash along with the wage laborers. Off we trooped to the paymaster’s office and stood around while each man was called to the table. While he and everyone else watched, the paymaster slapped the bills down on the table, counting out loudly, “Ten, twenty, thirty, forty,…” When the total was reached the worker gathered up the money, signed for it, and the next man stepped up.
First the workers, then we draftsmen. We got quite a bit more money. Behind us the workers started muttering a bit as they saw how much more. Then the engineers. Up to that point I had no idea how much engineers were paid, but as we watched the money pile up in front of the engineers, “Hundred, hundred and fifty, two hundred,…”, and they turned red with embarrassment, we draftsmen started muttering and the workers started whistling and making loud cries of amazement.
That’s when I decided I had to get qualified. I had always thought engineers were much brighter than I was, but having worked with them I realized I was just as smart as them. So I got a bursary, went back to university, got a degree, and things went well for a while, but then as a result of a few bad decisions things took a turn for the worse, which I won’t discuss.
Ian D. # 114:
“End of life healthcare is also very expensive, especially surgeries and pallative care. Expensive treatments can prolong someones life regardless if the quality of those last months and years of life are awful. I believe people accessing MAID are saving the government money in end of life care.”
In addition to your paragraph, I can tell you a hard data who wrote the known and famous (at least in my country) Dr. Sans Segarra, in a book about death; which seems an unpleasant elephant in the room of our dear “progressive” government health policies: There’s a very permissive law allowing euthanasia for everybody who ask for it “at will” (even for mentally ill people, according woke zealots); but there isn’t any govt law depicting and ordering paliative care in Spain. So do the math. Our govt isn’t interested in improving human conditions of terminal patients in our health system…but they’ve promoted very well an apparently “humanitarian” solution (ahem).
Going back one more layer, money is a psychological construct of the collective consciousness. It’s an agreed upon belief in a store of value, and the wage/salary/investment classes are loosely based on the value of goods and services you can contribute to society. We are salaried, and my family has participated in the investment class rituals., It’s a type of magic, using a belief system to manifest physical assets into your life. As much as I don’t like usury, money is one of the most useful constructs of humanity, it’s built a society that has backed innovation (for good or worse). It’s gotten to the point that most of the peasants don’t have to starve to death in a freezing mud puddle outside of the landed gentry’s estates and the peasants can mostly be protected from the blood sports of the from someone like Elizabeth Bathory (mostly, Epstein criminals are getting a real time cover up).
Humans need food, clothes, water and shelter to survive. All of those things come from God given renewable soils and sun. Hemp, bamboo, wood can keep us alive with certain skill sets. If there is enough energy and built up tech, asteroid mining becomes feasible. Which is why I think we can afford some optimism.
Finally, I still think you should have the criminal class as a separate category because they don’t really operate under the same social structure and outcomes as the wage/salary/investment classes and cartel activity is worth trillions.
I have gotten to the point that everything I have, including my body, just seems like it’s all on loan from the universe.
Before I start with the responses, a note for those who are keeping track. I fielded a lot of flak, here and elsewhere, for my post on Operation Dildo Blitz; that was predictable enough, and mildly amusing. This post got a very different reaction: no tirades in my inbox at all, but instead a flurry of attempted comments trying to bring up wholly unrelated subjects and drag the conversation away from the theme of the post. That’s a reliable sign that I’m really over the target. Interesting…
That said, let’s proceed.
Kimberly, the medical-charity racket is one of the best examples of the way salary class habits make failure the only option. You can bet your bottom dollar that if the Komen Foundation heard about a genuine cure for breast cancer they’d do their level best to suppress it — what a terrible threat to the gravy train that would be!
Clay, smaller businesses are also more effective drivers of job creation, so there are many good reasons for the sort of policy you’re suggesting.
Candyd, that’s one aspect, and I’m considering a book on the subject. Most of what I discuss in the book already published is the huge amount of the phenomenon that consists of known, once-secret military technologies during their development. Do you recall when everybody was seeing black triangle UFOs? Funny about that — those were the years when stealth planes were in development, and they look like…
Vitranc, I won’t argue!
Alexander, the proprietor class was mostly squeezed out of existence by government policies that favored big corporations at their expense. It’ll return in a big way, though at first it’ll be mostly under the table.
Emmanuel, that’s very good news!
Ian, thanks for the details.
Gavin, with everything else that’s going on in the UK these days, yeah, it’s going to be explosive.
Scotlyn, yes, and it would work even better to provide some such income to those who genuinely need it, and not to everyone. A very modest number of civil servants could see to that. Of course removing excess regulations and fees will also drive job creation, so those who can work will be able to.
Justin, interesting. I wonder if Snow deals with the failures as well as the successes of that approach.
CandyD, money is a fascinating construct and one of these days I’m going to need to do another post about it. I’ve been reading some of Nick Land’s essays; as often happens when I read things that are smart and well written but (to my way of thinking) wrong, that’s catalyzed a whole series of reflections, and some new insights on how and why we’re screwed. 😉
wondering how you could write so much about musical chairs and not realize that the DJ who’s taking the chairs away from salary class and wage class is the investment class which is the sole winner in this game:
– AI development => enriches it through its investments
– Salary class shrink => less people to pay when you’re CEO, more money for the investment class through reduced labor costs
– welfare reduction => less taxes to pay for these welfare policies
Now here’s the fun part: less salary class => many more people in wage class => wages can be lowered => investment class benefits
So yes AI is going to streamline the salary class but is it for the better og the whole population? I don’t think so… all I’m seeing is a return to Europe’s 19th century class system with an aristocracy (the investment class), a reduced bourgeoisie (the remainder of the salary class) and the populace fighting for its survival through meager wage jobs
And now let’s look back at what happened in Europe after a century of this: a lot of revolts in different part of the continent, the communist revolutions and eventually the rise of fascism…
Sounds like a great world coming for the upcoming generations… maybe we just need a Carrington event => destroy the worlds electronics, get back to real life => have people benfit from their work rather than that of others…
Thank you for the old-fashioned word “proprietor class” which helps me locate myself fairly accurately, if anachronistically.
I suppose that Wendell Berry might be considered a primary advocate for the interests of this class. And that “distributism” could reasonably be said to articulate its class interests most accurately. “Not being beholden”, a sentiment that was common to many of my proprietor class forbears, might also be one of its deepest commitments.
I have spoken before about the cross-class mixed marriage that my parents entered into, and which produced me, but it is equally true to say that at least three of my grandparents were born on proprietor-class farms. The fourth was my mother’s mother, who supported herself as a live-in nanny from around age 15 until she married my grandfather at around age 27. (I know a lot less about her family background). The man she married had little education, as he ran away to sea when he was 17, and never returned home to the farm. However he believed in frugality and saving and eventually saved enough to purchase a small home and marry, and thereafter worked at various residential maintenance/janitorial jobs, while also studying the financial pages and making small stock bets – a man with a working class income and an investment class sensibility, who advised us all to work hard, never borrow, save 10% of everything earned, and buy everything in cash. These were sensible people who put little store in book learning, and much store in work, frugality, and paying your way. My relatives on my mother’s side of the family are very down to earth wage class people who have mostly remained in the surrounds of Boston, where they were born.
My father’s parents also came from proprietor class farms, but, as lay preachers were interested in education, and after they emigrated from Nova Scotia to Boston, my paternal grandfather became a proprietorial grocery store owner. His biggest dream of sending all his boys to college was fulfilled, and as a result, a number of my relatives on my father’s side entered the salary class, working at academia or in the NGO sector, and have moved quite a bit more often and further afield away from Boston, where they, too, were born.
I have always felt the “pull” of the way the politics and economic interests of the two sides of my family line up to different classes, and that experience remains my personal window seat on the fractures in the society as a whole.
My own parents simply stepped a little sideways, agreeing with each other that the life well lived would be the one that took them together to the mission field, and so they themselves have long lived inside a sort of bubble that protects them from the worst of the class struggle between salary and wage class that their relatives are caught up in.
However, now that I can safely say that I am a member of the proprietor class (being self-employed in my clinic), and so is my husband (being self-employed on his farm), I can also see that I do not have to go back more than one or two generations to be back among ancestors that are pretty squarely in that class.
It’s good to hear that the proprietor class will return in a big way. Do you have any advice for someone who within the last year made the transition from wage class to proprietor class? (I’m completely above-board, as it happens. I had a clear sense while starting my business that under-the-table was emphatically not the choice for me)
From my impression, by the blurb, chapter titles and the like, the Snow book seemed to be about the failures and how that has gotten us to the present moment with the PMC.
“…it would work even better to provide some such income to those who genuinely need it, and not to everyone. A very modest number of civil servants could see to that.” You would think so, wouldn’t you?
However I think that our recent history shows that any given “very modest number of civil servants” can easily think up new ways to complicate the task of determining whose need is “genuine” to the point of needing many more civil servants to [Shirk] carry[ing] it out… 😉
The whole point of taking “deservingness” out of the equation (for those who advocated for it) was precisely that this was the only way to take ALL the civil servants out of the equation altogether. Like I say, I grew dubious, and I unsubscribed.
In terms of welfare, there is a weird wrinkle that took place in Ireland after the bank crisis (I don’t know how widespread this is)… by means of which the provision of welfare was privatised, and parcelled off to competing private interests. This has turned the Irish poor and disabled into a new class of capital asset, and, as far as I can see has also made a nonsense of the “public/private” argument.
Clearly, bureaucracies and lenocratic habits can exist both in the private sector and the public sector.
OTOH there are both public goods and private goods that are equally worth protecting in the interests of ordinary people and nations.
Scotlyn, UBI was a good idea and was doable back in the 1970s when Daniel Moynihan persuaded President Nixon to propose it. It would have to be combined with some form of national service for all requirement. For example, two years post high school and possibly two weeks to a month annually thereafter. AND, what is to prevent property owners from simply rising rents to suck up the extra subsidy? So, rent controls as well.
It might interest some to know that in inner city neighborhoods, social workers are more hated than police.
@Untitled #53
“Multiple examples have surfaced showing that LLMs replicate the biases that occur in their training data”
I roared laughing when I read this, you have no idea how amusing I found this comment, because you’re right of course, and yet you may have no idea how right you are.
There’s an intersection here with the OP. In recent months I’ve been using AI tools a lot to model the future, and I won’t go into that too much, because I know our host doesn’t want it, but just to say, with any of the mainstream AIs I always have to begin the conversation with a lengthy outline establishing that my worldview is not the dominant one it was trained on.
And so just this week I had an AI tool congratulate me on having chosen a strategy that is “low status but sustainable”. Lol! But that really is how its training data sees the world.
@JMG 102
“Cererean, it’s almost unheard of. You do sometimes get a salary class person with the brains to rake in money, live frugally, and then walk out of cubicle world to do something more interesting with their lives, but they have to face the united peer pressure of their entire class to do it.”
Ahem, I feel seen by this comment!
(But that’s why I’m on this blog I guess)
Northwind Grandma #93:
And I would love to show it to you but I’ve been unable to find it online. As I recall it, there’s not much more to it than what I described above. A blond, reasonably attractive young woman in overalls smiles at the camera. The slogan is overlaid next to her. The name of the job portal is below, I think.
She was, needless to say, spotlessly clean. I strongly suspect any actual job involving a workbench would change that within five minutes.
—David P.
Chuaquin,
Thanks for your reply. Ok… well thank you for not sparing the gruesome details. Spain seems to be modelling good ‘Operational Efficiency’. This is a popular term being used right now to capture the process our heavily indebted hospitals are going through to stay on budget. A society practising operational efficiency by cutting useless workers instead, getting on budget that way, that could be framed as progressive as well…
Kimberly Steele @ 103.. humm, ‘pink drill bits’.. maybe I’ll add some of those to my stable of garden art, to keep those dildos (as per last week’s discussion..) company. Not sure about the pink chicken though.. Regarding the whole breastcancer fraud, I would put prostate cancer in a similar state, in that most p. cancers are not of a condition which merits invasive surgery, and/or ‘treatments’ via radiation, chemo. Essentially, the man dies of other causes .. or just plain old age, rendering the case for intervention mute. But, alas .. those generous managerial-class salaries don’t pay themselves now, do they…
Regarding salary class entrenchment, the UK seems to be an extra-special case here, especially in light of the full rape gang report that just came out and its shocking revelation that up to 250,000 WORKING CLASS British girls had been sexually abused (and worse) by Muslim immigrant populations (primarily Pakistani) over the past several decades, beginning with the election of Tony Blair.
One thing obvious here is that it’s not young salary class girls who were abused en masse. Right now, the right wing on social media seems completely fixated on leftism being at fault. While leftist ideology did play a big part in this, they are largely ignoring the class dynamics at play here, which you point out in your article. We all know that Britain has long been a society dominated by extreme class snobbery and it seems that when the salary class there rose to prominence, they fully inherited the old aristocracy’s snobbery and utter contempt for le petit peuple. So I think this is the other half of the equation; the salary class that has been in control of the big UK institutions did everything in their power to ignore (and even dismiss and belittle any reporting on) the mass human rights abuses their client demographics inflicted on young native wage and welfare class girls.
To affirm some of your observations above, going by the conservative reaction to this story on social media, it seems like few people on English-language social media like to talk about class; they’d rather frame it as a dualistic culture war battle. And of course the leftist salary class just dismisses and handwaives all of these types of revelations and smugly gaslights anyone pointing to facts they don’t like.
Badger, of course the investment class is going to benefit from the collapse of the salary class, but the wage class will also benefit as excess regulation (the single biggest brake on job creation these days) is pruned back, illegal immigration is shut down, and real estate prices collapse back to reasonable levels. Thank you, though, for that final lapse into apocalyptic fantasy — a useful reminder that failing classes inevitably embrace those, and we’ll see the salary class latch onto plenty of such delusions as they sink.
Scotlyn, the decline of the proprietor class is a major factor in economic history, and far too little attention has been paid to it. Go back a century or two in most parts of the world and it was far and away the largest class. That’s a change worth discussing.
Alexander, I wish I did. I’m still working out the details of that via my astrological side gig.
Justin, that’s promising. So often books of that kind do the “Century of the Self” schtick and proclaim the omnipotence of whatever they’re critiquing.
Scotlyn, ah, but that’s only an issue when the salary class runs things. Bureaucracy can work very well, and avoid the Shirky trap, if there’s another class holding the reins; the Chinese mandarinate is a good example. Admittedly the emperors kept the mandarinate in line by the crude if effective expedient of beheading mandarins who failed to solve problems, but there are less sanguinary ways of doing the same thing.
Bofur (if I may), thanks for this — a useful reminder that, along with their other flaws, LLMs are simply engines for parroting the conventional wisdom, and will be no more successful than that ever is. As for the comment, I think a lot of people who read this blog fall into that category.
Mithridates, that’s an excellent point, of course. The hatred and contempt with which the salary class holds the wage class is even worse in the UK than in the US, and appears in ghastly detail in the rape-gang scandal. It’s indicative of the power of class divisions that feminists who claim to be all about the empowerment of women have turned a blind eye to this whole business; what they’ve made very clear is that the only women they want to empower are those of their own class.
I have surfaced for a bit. Am busy with my weather oracle and my husband’s retirement.
About musical chairs, our local elections are all about retaining power as in fight the Big Bad Orange Man and btw make things affordable again. I think that local salary class has lost it and are scrambling for relevancy. A local Congressman funded by the Federal Workers Union (yes, a union of salary people) is trying to stop the moving of the U.S. Agricultural Department from DC to the Midwest, where the farmers are. They don’t want to move and of course it is the Big Bad Orange Man’ s fault. It continues on in that vein where they want their jobs back after the DOGE carnage. We are dealing with what I believe are people who think of themselves as entitled or at least indispensable
—
Meanwhile our next-door neighbors who look out for us since my husband is ill are asking for food handouts. They cannot afford food and gas. They have four children, wage jobs as landscaping and teacher’s aide. My husband who is the investor class has entered an informal arrangement for them to help us for pay. They and we have a longstanding relationship in caring for each other. So we are helping each other. They are really in a bad way, as they never have asked for handouts of any kind.
—-
Last thought – the Civil War photo reminded me of General W.T. Sherman’s March to the Sea that completely destroyed the planter class in the South. A humor note – I knew a Sherman re-enactor who worked at Bentonville, NC, where Johnston’s army surrendered to him (after Lee’s surrender). He hated going to the local Piggly-Wiggly in costume since the old ladies would run him down with their shopping carts. They still remember after all these years. –
Which brings me to the final thought – will this class change bring forth the same long memories of hate towards the class disposers?
JMG and Clay,
I see the situation in our local school district playing out in my small city similarly. After many years of the community supporting all levies and bonds that support our local schools, suddenly there is not enough money to support the number of teachers we have, or even the number of schools. The district first cut teachers, 7-10 from each school so perhaps that wouldn’t be noticed by the community, but then they argued that they had to close 2 local elementary schools. They are saying that in 5 years the population has declined that much. Meanwhile, they have just finished building a beautiful administrative building complete with fancy espresso bar. And this is a blue state and blue town, people are shocked, and now the community is organizing in opposition to this.
One prominent speaker has looked at the numbers and data that the district used and noticed that it hasn’t been analyzed correctly at all, just manipulated numbers to justify school closures. As more people look at this it is becoming clear to all that there are way too many overpaid administrators, whose positions have not been cut, for such a small school district. I’m happy to see parents respond to this.
Warning: negativity ahead. Folks who like their reading positive might want to skip.
JMG @ 125 : “it would work even better to provide some such income to those who genuinely need it, and not to everyone. A very modest number of civil servants could see to that.” No, it wouldn’t work, and I doubt you have much experience with the highly corrupt social work bureaucracies. What the modest number of civil servants would see to is transmission of stipends to their own families or tribes. Like social security, a UBI program would need to be inclusive of all American citizens, even the wealthy and the layabouts. I had rather pay the latter to vegetate than have to deal with constant low grade thievery.
CandyD @ 124 “Going back one more layer, money is a psychological construct of the collective consciousness. It’s an agreed upon belief in a store of value, and the wage/salary/investment classes are loosely based on the value of goods and services you can contribute to society:” From where I am standing, that is an assertion without visible foundation. At best, it is a theory, one among many. At worst, it is an appeal to emotion dressed up as basic principle. A person can put out whatever nonsense they want. It is not incumbent on others to notice or respond and the fact that no one did notice or respond DOES NOT therefore mean that a particular bit of pasta hurled at a particular wall has now become “established truth”.
BTW, I have nothing against the salaried in principle; I just wish these folks would do their jobs and learn some ethics and manners.
What is in the way of small proprietorship in the USA is the high FIRE sector costs, rents, utility expenses, insurance and the like. Overregulation does not help. I have one question for everyone here who would like to see a return to neighborhood proprietorship. Would you, you personally, be willing to see the value of your house or other real property decline (as part of a general decline) so that your neighbor could afford to open his or her carpentry shop?
Kimberly Steel 103
> I remember when I woke up to the breast cancer racket. Breast cancer and cancer in general have been “fought” for a century.
I woke up to “cancer in Murica” being a cash cow of the healthcare industry. Note my previous post here in this list (search for visiting nurse).
Something is the strangest thing. A friend (call her “Anne”) (born 1970) has had breast cancer twice. When I tried to start a conversation about cancer being a cash cow in the USA, she shut me down real fast. She informed me that it couldn’t possibly be true—she was in total denial of even the possibility. Anne is too young to have witnessed the drastic transition from then ‘compassionate‘ female nurses being boss to now ‘heartless’ male administration being boss. I feel sorry for her because she cut off an informer (me) who was “there watching” in the 1970s, in the thick of the changeover. Anne just can not fathom the healthcare industry’s raking in cash from other people’s misfortunes, where healthcare executives go on buying binges acquiring 2nd, 3rd and 4th mansion-homes, one in Tuscany, Italy, one in Switzerland, one in Indonesia, on her dime.
So, if Anne is any indication of willful ignorance, I cannot imagine that she will have the spiritual strength to weather a major downturn (or successive downturns). If she can’t perceive the cancer-cash cow-fiasco that has been going on for fifty years, she won’t be able to see declining trends, and I can do nothing about it. Anne jumps on me every time I bring up anything like you write about here, JMG.
I can’t help but feel that Anne’s psyche can’t survive, that she very well may be one of those who jumps off a cliff, killing herself, because she has locked herself into where, with her old world dissolving, she, in her state of overwhelm, refuses to see alternative ways of living. It is hard to watch. She blames herself for “the affluent-world disappearing”; she cannot see that it is society that is the thing declining. It is not like I haven’t tried to get through.
I just need to let her ‘be.’ She needs someone who will listen, be cheerful, and be a ‘yes (wo)man.’ I can do that.
💨👏🏼💨Northwind Grandma
Dane County, Wisconsin, USA
@ Mary Bennett #131
UBI may be a good idea (in certain circumstances), but just like good intentions, good ideas can make good paving stones leading in a certain direction.
The main problem that I personally developed with the UBI idea is that it is simply one more way to play with money, which (as I think another commenter in this thread has already said) is, by its nature, a magical substance, a kind of fairy dust which holds us all enspelled/enthralled. It does nothing to break that particular spell or to free people from its effects.
And to produce general prosperity (which is what it aims to do) it would need quite a lot of limits and checks and balances, every one of which would ultimately be amenable to being gamed.
Clay Dennis 106
> At this stage the business is very efficient, can afford a few pieces of good equipment and turns out high quality that builds it reputation and creates further growth.
The thing is, no one is forcing the business to grow. One can keep the business where it is one boss–three employees–and–one–wife–doing–bookkeeping.
One can, and does, refuse to fulfill orders. When someone approaches one with an order, one can take it or leave it—at that moment, it is a choice. Nicely: “no, I can’t do make that item now, I am overburdened as it is. I have too many orders at the moment. Check with me in three months.” If you lose a customer, so be it,— you have just saved your business.
Or better (for you), raise prices until orders reduce of their own accord. If you are getting too many orders, it means your prices are too low.
To the uninitiated, it is a fallacy to think that growth is the only way to go. A good deal of the time, keeping things at status quo (the whole enterprise feels cool and composed) is the best long-term strategy.
💨⚒️💨Northwind Grandma
Dane County, Wisconsin, USA
@ NeptuneDolphins #139
” A local Congressman funded by the Federal Workers Union (yes, a union of salary people)…”
You raise an interesting point. Because I have to say that in Ireland also, the biggest unions are those representing salaried class people, whereas those representing wage class workers (and there were some strong ones) have been losing both bargaining power and members for decades. There was a time when unions did good work representing waged class interests, but they were too easily pushed aside when globalisation beckoned. And now, most unions practice class warfare AGAINST working class interests. Which is an interesting, if counterintuitive turnaround.
@ NeptuneDolphins # 139
PS – is your weather oracle online anywhere?
Mr. Greer,
I have read The King in Orange (a great read!) and have been following your posts explaining the class disparities in the United States, their causes and effects, and the unraveling you see underway.
Admittedly, I am a member of the salary-and-laptop class (complete with solar panels) that you often describe, and I work in higher education! For clarification, I’m not middle management and do not earn a six-figure income. If I understand your argument correctly, people in my position face two related problems: first, we are increasingly vulnerable to targeted downsizing; second, by advocating for and benefiting from our lifestyle, we may contribute to downward pressure on the wage class, thereby increasing resentment toward the salary class and accelerating the very instability that threatens us.
This leaves me wondering whether there is any room in your argument for those who arrived in the salary class not in the pursuit of wealth, comfort, and status, but in earnest pursuit of meaningful and stable work. Obviously I’m referring to myself, but I will admit that I have a difficult time reconciling the characterization I read here with the reality that brought me to this place.
Twenty-five years ago I was working three part-time jobs and donating plasma twice a week just to still be $50 short on rent. I worked through school in an attempt to improve my circumstances, eventually landed a teaching job that led to a career in “Instructional Design” where I seem to have a natural talent and have done quite well. Higher ed happens to frequently hire in this field, and I was offered this job in a very timely moment with a child on the way. Today, I am salaried with benefits and support a family.
I certainly never intended to make a living by depriving others of theirs; however, I do feel concern that my lifestyle may be threatened and, worse yet, legitimately threatening to others. Is there any room for an honest salary man in today’s world or would someone in my position be wiser to begin looking toward other pastures?
Aaron
Scotlyn, I think UBI was a good idea when proposed in the 1970s and was doable at that time. You may recall it was the Democrats who were against it because welfare bureaucracies, known as “the programs”, were a jobs program for some Democratic constituencies. Too dumb to attempt law or medical school–we won’t even mention science or engineering–social work was the ticket. For the same reason, we are stuck with even the most intelligent Democratic candidates calling for Medicare for All, when what we need (IMHO) is a National Health Service, with a basic and urgent care clinic in every neighborhood. But no, “My daughter/son/auntie’s job!”) howl the various Democratic constituencies, so let us by all means expand an already corrupt system.
This sounds like an excellent topic for our forum on Saturday.
As a public reminder :
This is my current final plan for Adocentyn in Providence. Theme: Past, Present & Future
Friday, 6/19 Past
• 1:00 PM Meeting with Roger Williams, founder of Providence and the First Baptist Church in America.
Location: Roger Williams National Memorial, 282 N Main St, Providence, RI 02903. There is on parking off Canal Street for the Memorial, and onstreet parking nearby.
John McNiff has been studying Roger Williams for decades, so he can well answer any questions you might have, such as a discussion of his evolution from Anglican Priest to Puritan Minister to leader of the Baptist faith to his final self description as a Seeker.
• 2:30 PM History tour of Providence, led by me, about 2 hours, hill climbing involved, starting at the National Memorial
• Dinner TBD
Saturday 6/20 Presentations in a the Parish House of First Unitarian Church of Providence, 1 Benevolent Street, Providence. On street parking on Benefit and Benevolent Streets. Piano available. There are presentations to fill up the morning, but if you have a topic you want to talk about, speak up and we can solve it in the afternoon.
• 9:00 to noon time for talks/presentations
• 12:00 1:00ish lunch delivered, probably pizza from Fellini
• 1:00 – 5:00 time for talks/presentations
• 6:00 dinner at Track 15, a food hall with 7 local restaurants, 1 Union Station, Providence. https://track15ri.com/
Saturday is also Pride day, so we may relocate dinner.
Sunday 6/21 Future
• from 9:00 on, open discussion. Location TBD.
Vitranc 110
> a farmers night school (where we get to be taught, amongst other things like mychoriza cultures in soil, …
Studying soil/dirt is way cool‼️ That particular subject is so fascinating. Composition of soil/dirt makes or breaks a nation. Studying the instrumental role of weeds in growing food is also a great subject.
💨farm🌽🐖🐓💨Northwind Grandma
Dane County, Wisconsin, USA
There is a simultaneous tectonic shift happening with regard to the economic model of the web. The search engines and other social media platforms were insanely profitable because they never had to pay to create the content in the first place, only to organize it. The content creation on the web replaced traditional journalism and magazines because the content could be made available for free to readers in exchange for advertisement or affiliate referral payback that could pay the creators indirectly. But now, with “AI”, the platforms are attempting to capture the value that flowed back to creators in the first place by retaining the traffic and advertisement revenues. They are essentially killing the golden geese because, if the creators cannot sustain themselves, there will be no content to train AIs on or lure people on the web for.
So the salary class working to build the big technology platforms is working extra hard to eventually make itself useless.
@Northwind Grandma:
(To #142): I’m 10 years older than you. One of the most useful things that I have learned in my 83 years is that people really hate to be told any truth that challenges or upsets their own world view. They will actively prefer to believe any comfortable lie over a truth that does that. In the very worst cases, if the challenge cuts too deeply, they will even try to destroy the truth-teller who won’t shut up.
As I’ve said here several times in the past, my father’s step-father worked for a while in his youth as a “sharper” (a sort of con-artist) in a traveling carnival. One of the things that I learned from him was that anyone who can fake sincerity can do almost anything with almost anyone. Most people judge truth — they are, IMHO, hard-wired to judge truth — not by any facts whatever, but only by how sincere the their interlocutor seems to be. (This is one of the enormous advantages of some kinds of neuro-divergency, including mine: such a person lacks this particular hard-wiring.)
(And to #144): I enthusiastically applaud you for saying outright that “it is a fallacy to think that growth is the only way to go. A good deal of the time, keeping things at status quo (the whole enterprise feels cool and composed) is the best long-term strategy.”
This needs to be put on one of those (metaphorical) branding-irons our host used to mention, and applied as needed.
Elsewhere I was having a conversation about academic jealousy, or the jealousy of academics over non-academics who are publishing / playing music / getting art shows, etc. I guess you could say academia is another genre of the salary class. Unless you are a struggling adjunct professor, and then you are just their bilge (or other words that rhyme with itch).
Anyway, listening to Courtney Barnett now, from Australia… I like her slice of life lyricism. The song Depreston is about looking for a home to buy in Preston. I guess they have suburbs too…
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1NVOawOXxSA
“You said, “We should look out further”
I guess it wouldn’t hurt us
We don’t have to be around all these coffee shops
Now we’ve got that percolator
Never made a latte greater
I’m saving twenty-three dollars a week
We drive to a house in Preston
We see police arresting
A man with his hand in a bag
How’s that for first impressions?
This place seems depressing
It’s a Californian bungalow in a cul-de-sac”
There is another DK song, Lets Lynch the Lord…
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MA3QWPXm9TU
I am going to have to turn all this stuff into a De-Control Science delouse the PMC mix.
Oh yeah, my point about the bilge hole academics, well. … uh, just had a few run in’s since my music history book came out. Glad to have sidestepped further interaction. Also did a divination about some activities that a local circle of them hang around in relevant to my own work, but it said not to get entangled. Anyway, I felt a bit of a loss about the possible camaraderie related to shared subjects of interest, but also realized its saving me a headache. Also, the theme of Phase 17 keeps in my mind with this “intensity through simplification” -letting some desires go to focus on the real work.
As part of The Jane Austen Project (we’ll watch and review ALL the adaptations of her novels, along with ancillary films) I’m doing a lot of reading about her and her times.
Surprisingly, two books address the corruption and wide-scale thievery which I didn’t associate with the late Georgian era and the Regency.
“What Jane Austen Ate and Charles Dickens Knew” by Daniel Pool is more Victorian but my goodness did the British elite at every level steal as much as they could.
I’m currently reading G. E. Mitton’s (published in 1905!) book, “Jane Austen and Her Times 1775 – 1817” and my goodness, the corruption and thievery! I’m constantly shocked, although I shouldn’t be.
We also just watched “Peterloo” (2018), a film about the St Peter’s field massacre of 1819 and my God! The petty incompetence, corruption, and venality of Yorkshire and London elites was simply breath-taking.
I slowly coming to understand that corruption will ALWAYS be with us. It’s human nature and we must, as individuals and societies, strive against it. Or try to, anyway.
Dear John, I know you do not watch videos, but the title of this week post reminds me of an old french comedy, “Que les gros salaires lèvent le doigt” (“High earners, raise your hands.”) from 1982. The owner and boss of an insurance company (played by Jean Poiret) invites all his employees to spend a weekend at his country house. Just as the weekend draws to a close, the boss discloses the true purpose of his invitation: the company is struggling, and he must cut costs among the highest salaries, parting ways with four of them. He then announced a last game, and asks, ‘Let the high earners raise their hands.’ Then, too craven and weak-willed to select anyone himself, and twisted enough to use the occasion to humiliate his senior staff, he compels them to play multiple rounds of musical chairs before their underlings to determine who will be dismissed. Here is a mediocre quality version of that last part of the movie : https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x3ad12
As a member of the “salary class” myself, I sometimes wonder how the purge of bureaucrats will play out, and what very humiliating measures will be used to progressively cull a good many from the ‘salary class’…
Kimberly Steele #103 mentioned: In 2010, the Susan G. Komen foundation got caught filing legal trademark opposition after opposition against any smaller breast cancer charity it could find that used “for the cure” in its messaging.
Plenty of organizations do this and some of them are quite small and you’d think they’d behave better. But no.
I’m in Hershey. Up until 2020, the Hershey Lodge hosted “Quilt Odyssey” every July. A lady we’ll call Melissa ran the show. It was her baby. Quilt Odyssey was HUGE. They filled all the ballrooms at the Hershey Lodge for an entire week. Quilt-related vendors came from across the county. The display of art quilts was stupendous. It got written up in all the quilt magazines.
Quilt Odyssey was a big deal.
In 2018 or so (I may have the year wrong), a small, local group of quilters tried to set up a much smaller quilt show for locals and vendors who were stuck on the years-long waiting list for Quilt Odyssey. They got the Methodist Church in Hummelstown to agree to host them. I bought a ticket.
As soon as Melissa heard about it — I was told this by at least two of that group’s members — she threatened to sue the local quilt group AND the Methodist church for daring to host a potential competitor!
The church caved as they couldn’t afford the lawfare and the local group shut down.
Covid killed Quilt Odyssey for 2020. Melissa then apparently contracted some dread disease and she couldn’t or wouldn’t let anyone else take over.
So no more Quilt Odyssey for anyone.
I like much of your theory but have two disagreements. First, the salaried class didn’t take power under Roosevelt. His key accomplishments were Social Security, which created the welfare class; allowing unions, which benefited the wage class; bank reform, which punished the investment class by requiring banks pay insurance. I put the takeover in the 1980s with Reagan. That’s when a class of salaried knowledge workers rose, such as biotech researchers, software engineers and investment advisors. Their knowledge is what differentiated them from the salaried and wage classes.
Second, I don’t think the salaried class controls the country. AI is about to force many in the salaried class to drop down to the wage class. The investor class owns AI, so I think the investor class controls the country.
Last, many thanks to JMG for keeping this space as one of the few that insists on civil discussions, no matter how difficult the topic.
@Teresa
“As part of The Jane Austen Project”
Hey wait, we’re doing that? Here?? I want in on this!
“Peterloo massacre”
Funny, that’s a bit of synchronicity, I was just learning about that recently, almost no one has ever heard of this but it’s another one of those “plus ca change” episodes of history.
Hey JMG
On the subject of salary class and housing, I think I previously mentioned that the Australian Labor Party have upset a lot of them with the federal budget that will be implemented next year since it is going to be making housing and trust funds a bit less profitable. The insane reaction that so many people on the news are showing to this has been quite entertaining, but the one that has been getting the most attention recently are the rather unhinged rants that the Australian comedian Dave Hughes/ “Hughie” has been posting on social media and in various tv interviews. A few people, such as YouTube comedian and political commentator Jordan Shanks, have compared his behaviour to that of a meth-head rambling on the bus about the government.
https://www.news.com.au/finance/economy/australian-economy/theyve-royally-fed-this-joint-dave-hughes-unleashes-over-cgt-and-negative-gearing-changes/news-story/a8442d90afe8aec079a3f93ed881f1fc
@Tom River #158
I think you’re misunderstanding the trajectory JMG has plotted out: Roosevelt allied the salary, wage, and welfare classes against the investment class, with the salary class as the senior partner. That alliance lasted for decades but started coming apart in the 70’s, the era of the “rural purge” in media and the beginning of stagnating wages.
I think Reagan tried to recruit the wage class as allies for the investment class, by exploiting the cultural tensions of his day, but it was too soon. The salary class waged a largely-successful propaganda war through the media of the day reminding the wage class of why they were allies against Wall Street.
But by the 2010’s that alliance came apart. The PMC (upper salary class) started pressing on the cultural tensions in the opposite direction that Reagan had, with the result of infuriating both the wage class and the rising “techbro” investment class, and Trump did what Reagan couldn’t and brokered a deal to ally the two. That alliance is now winning, which explains your second point, but this is a very recent phenomenon and it’ll be some time before the salary class’s power is a distant memory.
Neptunesdolphins, it’s been entertaining to watch the primary shaping up in DC’s Maryland suburbs. Candidates are divided between the ones that are focusing on pragmatic goals like making housing more affordable and those that are still pushing woke causes. I’m sorry to hear of your neighbors’ troubles but glad to hear that you’ve worked out an arrangement for mutual aid. As for long term grudges, oh dear gods, yes. Have you ever read about the way that former aristocrats cling to the memories of their lost status and waste their lives seething with hatred toward those who displaced them? We’ll see plenty of that.
Tamar, that’s common enough that I used it as a plot engine in one of my tentacle novels. Sorry to hear you have to put up with it. I hope the parents win!
Mary, and yet it’s been done before with relative success. You might look up social welfare programs in late 19th century Germany, as one example among many.
Aaron, my argument says nothing at all about the motives guiding individuals in the salary class, or any other class. One of the least useful habits of modern thought is the notion that if group A is harmful to group B, then group A must be deliberately evil and have chosen to harm group B. Not so. I’m sure most people in the salary class are just trying to look out for their own interests, help their children along in life, and do some good in the world in the process. The harm they’ve done to the wage class isn’t a product of personal malice — it’s simply the result of opposing interests in a situation where their ability to get what they want is considerably higher than that of the wage class. Mind you, as that harm has become harder and harder to ignore, a good many salary class people have embraced hatred and contempt for the wage class — it’s very common to hate and despise those you know you’ve harmed — but that’s not universal, of course.
Viking, granted. Once it became necessary to monetize the internet to pay the gargantuan costs of all those server farms, the bloom was off the rose, and the LLM frenzy is taking that down another step. I also expect most countries to find ways to eliminate online anonymity in the near future, and pursue the same sort of war against freedom of speech we’re seeing in Britain right now. Hey, it was fun while it lasted…
Justin, the rise of adjunct professors as an academic wage class is one of the more interesting trends of recent times, and foreshadows the collapsing status of the academic industry in general. Yeah, you’re better off keeping your distance; I’ve had some far from cordial run-ins with academics who were incensed to find a mere peasant like me writing about their subjects!
Teresa, have you ever read the Diary of Samuel Pepys? It’s pre-Regency, but things hadn’t changed much. The level of corruption makes our current kleptocrats look like amateurs. BTW, you’ve got Grose’s A Dictionary of the Vulgar Tongue, right?
Laurent, that sounds hilarious. I don’t imagine there was a novel…
Tom, don’t mistake the current knowledge industry for the salary class more generally. By the early 1940s there was quite a bit of writing discussing the way that the Roosevelt New Deal had inserted newly founded federal bureaucracies into many corners of American life. Of course it metastasized from there, but the decisive change was in the wake of the investment class collapse of 1929. As for your second point, that’s like saying that Napoleon never controlled continental Europe because he was defeated at Waterloo. The current convulsions are the process by which the investment class is supplanting the salary class. You might do a little reading into the relations between CEOs and boards of trustees — before 1929 CEOs were the cringing servants of the trustees; now it’s the other way around — or simply note the way that interest rates, which benefit the investment class but hurt the salary class when they’re high, were driven relentlessly down until quite recently.
J.L.Mc12, one of the odder things about the salary class is the way it gets completely unhinged when it doesn’t get what it wants. Other classes aren’t so relentlessly hysterical.
Just another case in point: I used to work in the Quality Assurance department for a large manufacturing concern.
Quality Assurance has little to do with assuring quality, and a lot to do with regulatory compliance. On a very high level, the purpose of it is to exclude competition from the market. The burden of regulatory compliance is so great that the cost can only be borne by large companies, and it effectively prevents any new startups from entering certain industries. JMG and others have described this pattern.
So the primary purpose of my job, from a certain perspective, was to collect a salary. Ticking boxes was a secondary objective. There were fifty people in the department. Both the high cost and the pointless busywork could easily be accomplished by LLMs.
P.S. I should that as a low-level member of the salary class, I am not at all happy about how things have turned out. I would much rather be living in a world where my class accepted a few sacrifices in privilege in exchange for continued power instead of driving itself insane.
Alas, that’s not the world we live in.
I saw a post on Mastodon which mentioned that Meta (formerly thefacebook, then facebook then briefly FACEBOOK*) has been reassigning a large proportion of its workforce to routine data labelling tasks for AI training datasets social.lansky.name/@hn50/116761068045674783 which is an interesting way of trying to slim down your workforce.
The blog linked from the Mastodon post says that Meta introduced heavy surveillance of its employees, as a way of using their keystrokes and clicks to train AI, then reassigned about 30-50% of core engineering teams to data labelling and “reinforcement learning from human feedback”.
Perhaps it is the hope that they will get bored and leave. It seems to be preferable for some reason to just making them redundant. It is also possible that Mark Zuckerberg just has “billionaire brain” and is just all in for AI irrespective of the cost to the company, in the same way he thought VR and the “metaverse” was the next big thing a couple of years ago.
* Just before they changed the company name to Meta, they decided to make their company name FACEBOOK in all-caps. I found however that in all-caps I no longer saw it as a combination English word, and rather read it as FAKEBOOK.
I would disagree slightly with the way our host has characterized the 4 class model, only in so far as I would place the divide between the ‘salary’ and ‘wage’ classes a bit higher, with the managerial elite and immediate underlings, and then the rest of the workforce consisting of the lower salaried class and the wage class. I think that is more meaningful than to include a broader swath in the ‘salary class’ since the divide is perhaps then more cultural than economically substantial.
I wonder whether this is a difference arising from how things look different in the USA compared with the UK, Europe and some other countries. In the USA it matters more whether you have a job with ‘benefits’ for things like health insurance. That word more often means ‘welfare benefits’ over here. A regular ‘wage class’ job here would probably also be paid monthly in most cases so if you have fixed hours is not really any different from a salary.
There is also what is sometimes known as the ‘precariat’ who are perhaps on a zero-hours contract with shifts being offered or not variably, or a freelance contractor on a gig economy platform. This is really a subset of the wage class rather than a class of its own. I think I read somewhere the better paid of that kind of work called ‘proficians’.
#162 JMG response to Justin – would this be an example of Arnold Toynbee’s ‘intellectual proletariat’?
I might as well add my 2¢ regarding euthanasia, —medical assistance in dying (MAID), now that I know what “MAID” stands for. Just call it by its true name: euthanasia.
——
We wouldn’t be in the euthanasia mess if the various healthcare industries had not spent zillions of dollars (and continue to spend), likely paid by taxpayers, in extending the lives of humans. There is something wrong with that.
Prior to World War II, roughly, when it was time for someone to die, they did; they died. There was nothing wrong with that. It has been happening for, what, millions of years? Ethics, and any other gyrations, didn’t come into it at all.
What we, in the West, have now is a_s-backwards. There was a point in the 1970s where male administrators pushed female nurses out. Female nurses were boss. My nurse mother and I witnesse it. MDs dared do nothing until they got permission by the nurse-in-charge. Not joshing.
Male administrators muscled their way in, in the 1970s, because they saw that sick people represented a cash cow to them, a way they could enrich themselves with 2nd, 3rd, and 4th homes. It was MALES who turned sickness into a profit-center, not FEMALES.
In the proper order of things, the first time one has a terminal illness, it should be the last time; in other words, one dies. There is no 2nd time around.
Keeping people arty-fish-ully (where have I seen THAT word before?) alive is a travesty. If one gets a terminal disease or illness, bite the bullet and damn it, do your bit for humanity,— die. Death is part of life, and if one doesn’t die, (s)he is inhabits a slot well past one’s time to have left the planet.
Why pay for healthcare executives’ Nth house, based on one thinking (s)he MUST stay alive, literally, at all costs? If one hasn’t noticed, we are running out of “at all costs.” We are plum outta dough.
I have looked death in the face every day since 1982. Why not do the same? It isn’t that hard.
Why is MAID even a thing? Just die when one is supposed to, one’s natural death at one’ natural time, and one never gets as far as to be forced to make euthanasia an issue. Jeez.
I say, thumb one’s nose at the entire male-powered healthcare establishment (instituted in the USA in the 1970s “over the dead bodies of female nurses of the day”), and die a natural death,—the first time you get called up,—the first time around the block. Why agree to go ’round and ’round and ’round the block multiple times, each time suffering more, and adding to loved ones sufferings? Why be a glutton for punishment? What is wrong with you people?
When is it time to do your duty?
Die early, and avoid the rush.
💨🛌☠💨Northwind Grandma
Dane County, Wisconsin, USA
@Alexander, if I may give some advice from my family’s success in the proprietor class:
1. Live below your means and save for a rainy day. My grandfather mocked farmers who bought their tractors new, asking “Do you know how much wheat you have to grow to pay for THAT?”
2. You are now responsible for everything – if you have to climb onto a shed roof to find a leak at 70 years old, you do it. Double-check every task that you delegate, people make mistakes. Grandma used to reconcile her own accounts, to double-check their accountants. She found some whopping errors.
3. Treat your workers and tenants with respect, pay your bills on time and keep your word. People talk about the boss who doesn’t. And they don’t say nice things.
Best of luck with your new business, I hope you find success and do good work.
Hi John Michael,
Oh dear! Academics. If I may provide some unsolicited advice: When someone finds themselves on the back foot, it is never good to acknowledge an action (or lack of) and then explain that the intentions were good. Never was there a faster way to escalate an argument than that, whether it was true or otherwise! Intentions are the sort of story people tell themselves so that they can sleep at night. Oh well.
I’m old enough to have known accountants way back in the day who earned their position by way of apprenticeship, and this group of people didn’t seem any more or less gifted than anyone else.
By sheer chance, yesterday I had an interesting chat with a young lady who had just finished her nursing degree, and had done the err, 800 hours of free work required from all who want a job in that field. Except the lady wasn’t working in the medical industry, and casually mentioned that a large portion of the degree was done at home. If I may suggest, there is cheap, and then there is too cheap. It takes a lot of students, lowly paid lecturers and tutors, to make up for the large salaries the upper levels and administrators of such institutions of learning appear to be enjoying. People tend to forget, the places are businesses.
It’s been a rather interesting discussion this week! 🙂
Cheers
Chris
Hi J.L.Mc12,
It’s interesting to see isn’t it? My take on the entire matter is somewhat different. If you can ignore all of the policies, what is actually taking place are a narrowing of options. If the changes pass Parliament and get Royal Assent as-is, well, a trust distribution looks like it will be hammered with tax (and they are already taxable in the name of whomever receives them, so I don’t see the big deal). But forget about that, what the bureaucrats are organising, is that they are reducing the possible ways to receive an income. It probably is that simple.
In the future, I’m guessing a business which runs today under a family trust, will have to pay salaries / wages instead of a trust distribution. It’s all income to an individual no matter who it is dressed up, but there is a difference – a salary and wage requires the 12% super guarantee, whereas a trust distribution does not. Ask yourself the question: Where does that 12% go? Who runs and benefits from the big industry funds? What government is in power? Are there links between the two? People are having melt downs, sure, but follow the money and see where it leads. There is a story there.
The capital gains discount was an arbitrary number pulled out of someone’s backside when the country was enjoying the benefits of the mineral boom. What troubles me is that a lot of these arrangements are being proposed to be grandfathered. The kids aren’t stupid, they look at that and ask: Why are the oldies still getting a benefit and we can’t? Theoretically speaking, there is no reason the policies couldn’t have been flipped on their head with the benefits going to younger folks, and the oldies getting cut off the gravy train with the argument that they’ve already enjoyed a good ride. I don’t see anyone suggesting that, but it would shut up all of the noise and achieve the stated aims of addressing intergenerational inequality. And ain’t that the finest joke of it all?
Dunno, strange times.
Cheers
Chris
Returning to my 109, to further the story of Emma and the girls, passed down orally to me:
Emma’s ne’er-do-well drunk husband James, refused to behave neighbor-like.
Just so you know, the ne’er-do-well husband, in this case, meant hubby raped Emma her whole life; he forced her to birth more babies; he kept abandoning the lot of them; he kept beating Emma and the girls for being female, all except Florence because “she was pretty.” Was this not a nightmare?
My point.
JAMES left the neighborhood. He self-sorted himself out of the neighborhood. The neighborhood would have nothing to do with him. They didn’t care for him,— because he hadn’t EARNED their care. After all, neighbors heard his beatings through cardboard-thin walls of tenement buildings.
The neighborhood left HIM. It is likely at some point, neighbors denied him having access to Emma and the girls.
One winter thereafter, James died an empty and ugly death. It is likely he froze to death after dark having fallen drunk outdoors.
If the neighbors knew of James’ death, they would have celebrated👏🏼. Celebration was appropriate.
This illustrates one neighborhood of olde. This manner of neighborhood will come back. Neighbors sorted out bad and/or evil people due to their having witnessed those persons’ bad or evil deeds. Alas, the monitized-welfare system (since the 1960s) pays bad people equally as much as good people,— hence, we reward people for being evil.
💨🍾☠️💨Northwind Grandma
Dane County, Wisconsin, USA
Wonderful post, JMG. I do hope that this current data centre boom phenomenon serves its purpose of serving as an excuse for decimating the salary class as soon as possible, thereby preventing too many of them from being constructed and operated, as it pains me to see these energy-and-water-Godzillas let loose on disenfranchised rural communities.
Regarding “voluntary extermination” – nice one, JMG. So much for calling a ‘spade’ a ‘spade’, eh? If it comes to devour the Canadian Boomers, there will be a certain poetic justice in it, as it is the Boomer demographic, more than any other, that has supported the Unhinged Lunatic Party (aka the federal Liberals) for waaaay too long. I can well remember the collective horror that I and my childhood friends had when we learned about the Nazis’ euthanasia programs. Five decades later, too many members of my demographic are now just lukewarm on the idea and the current practice of it. Hey, propaganda works!
Regarding the Chicago Obama Centre: I remember seeing a picture of it a few months ago as part of a meme. Egads! It readily lends itself to being the subject of a short story, written in the style of Chambers or Lovecraft, about a building so singularly grotesque and sinister in form and spirit that anyone who sees it instantly goes stark raving mad and drops dead! Maybe if Tolkien were alive today, he would be inspired to title the second book of Lord of the Rings trilogy, “The Three Towers!” The monstrosity desperately needs to be renamed the Chicago Obamanation (play on words for ‘abomination’).
Okay I have had 1 beer and now know what I want to comment. I’m in the Bofur bucket mentioned earlier. I don’t know why I support candidates and policies that go against the interests of my [salary] class, but I do. They just vibe more true to me and I’ve supported them before I found this blog, back when I was a basement dweller. I also intuit some cultural and social weirdness that doesn’t vibe with me is tied into all of this. At one point you said (paraphrase) magic was the spirituality of the excluded, and I’ve always felt excluded. So you might guess the The King in Orange is one of my favorites. Also, you doubtless know this, but a fair amount of salary class people do work pretty hard, but I agree there’s a lot of nonsense jobs.
“Trump just signed a memorandum of understanding with Iran, which stops the conflict in the Middle East and lifts decades long economic sanctions on Iran and hands full control of the Strait of Hormuz to Iran. A defeat for the American empire.”
Part of the memo is that Israel has to withdraw from Lebanon. But the Israelis don’t seem to want to do that. Not a day has passed after Trump signed the memo and Israel violated the ceasefire by bombing Lebanon, and in response Iran has suspended the 60-day negotiation period for peace until Israel stops going to war.
Mary Bennet 141
> Would you, you personally, be willing to see the value of your house or other real property decline (as part of a general decline) so that your neighbor could afford to open his or her carpentry shop?
You bet I would. In other words, you betcha. …
I don’t understand where you are coming from.
However, if you don’t mind me asking. I don’t see the connection between workshops (outbuildings) and house property values.
If anything, a neighbor’s workshop hereabouts is a benefit to the quarter. My neighbors would not mind another workshop, because it is one of many outbuildings. One could say that workshops are traditional.
Jethro and I live in farm country, where every farmer, farmer’s wife, farmer’s kids, farmer’s cousins, farmhand, have always had a secondary vocation, interest, or hobby often needing an outbuilding filled with tools and machinery. Each and every generation did this. Each person makes a point of gaining extra skills and expertise all the time. Some branch out into a venture they want to stick with from which to make money.
One farmer’s relative is a whitesmith, making all sorts of metal goods such as machine parts and artistic sculptures. He has a good-sized workshop in an outbuilding. Outbuildings are functional, not pretty. One sees men, women and kids in dirty overalls. If the clothing isn’t dirty, it isn’t real. If one needs any kind of metal thingy, we know who to call: “Mr Whitesmith.” However, he is not cheap. Expect to pay an arm and a leg.
What’s different over your direction?
💨🪚🪛🧰💨Northwind Grandma
Dane County, Wisconsin, USA
Weilong, that’s an excellent example, and shows how salary class makework and the dominance of big corporations dovetails together.
Slithy, I can understand that. Doubtless that timeline would be a much happier one than the one we’re in.
Mawkernewek, Zuckerberg is perhaps the most clueless of the current kleptocrats, and the fact that he’s taking engineering staff and using them for simple data correction so he can fire them altogether once the algorithm figures out how to do what they do is monumentally shortsighted. Does he realize that all these people now have every reason to want to mess with him, and the skills to do it? Data poisoning and other ways of hacking LLMs is one very likely wave of the future. But then I’ve been thinking of that firm as Faceplant for a while now.
With regard to your analysis, a finer-grained view would certainly draw that line, not least because the lower half of the salary class has had its status driven down dramatically in previous rounds of the game of musical chairs. That said, I haven’t seen any evidence yet that a significant fraction of that lower half votes or supports causes any different from those of the upper half. As for my response to Justin, yes, pretty much.
Northwind, it may have been men originally, but both of the most toxic medical facility administrators I’ve ever dealt with were women.
Chris, the return to the apprenticeship model is inevitable at this point, though a lot of universities will have to go bankrupt first.
Ron, I happen to have found an even better image. Once you see it…

…you’ll never be able to unsee it. Though I wonder if it’s something Lovecraft almost had in mind: the Hulking Trapezohedron…
Luke, I’m willing to guess that, while you’re currently in the salary class, you’re not that high up the totem pole. Right?
Mark, that’s all part of the back and forth. Both sides are trying to extract as much as possible from the deal; there’ll be plenty of yelling and maybe some drone strikes while that happens, but some deal will be managed. It’s in the interests of both sides to do so.
What class am I?
For decades I worked at two part-time teaching jobs. Both had salaries, but dependent on number of courses taught each semester. One of the jobs had benefits, the other did not. I never wore a suit. So salary or wage?
Now I am retired, with four sources of income. One is a pension: salary class? Two are from stocks: investment class? One is social security: welfare?
I do not fit neatly into any of your categories. Your analysis is incomplete.
We were joking about this on the way to the job site the other day. Laughing about all of the soon-to-be-unemployed with no practical skills whatsoever. One of us speculated that family annihilation would skyrocket. The truck got real quiet then, but for the sound of panting little dogs excited for the day ahead.
Here’s the one that put me over the edge for a minute earlier.my kids’ dad got a DUI and has limited English and of course now no transportation and limited work prospects but a way to work to cover his housing w an old boss sleeping over the workshop kind of mowing and security. So he’s checking what it takes to get back his license and guess what:they added a new layer of classes which are $100 ea 3x/week for like a year to get back to legal driving (after $1000s fines and court costs some of which he ‘paid’ w jail time) without paying weekly for an interlock device. But the reason these classes are there at a price that regular broke ppl of ky could never afford, is that THEY ARE BILLED TO INSURANCE AS ALCOHOLISM HEALTH CARE. it’s just like the way section 8 in a community drives up the base cost of rent for poor people because the government sets the price for ‘standard’ worth of mid-s****y housing. But if they weren’t there as a payer, landlords would have to price their units so low-income wage earners could afford them. And then since the gov/insurance bureaucracy is the payer, it seems to be ‘free’ to the poor person trying to cover the cost, but it is VIOLENTLY hard to use the service, psychotically long waiting lists. woops, that provider doesn’t cover *our* service for the *type* alcohol counseling that *you need* in your home county, sorry bout your luck. Change medicaid providers or find a ride somewhere else…. That sort of approach. That’s what UBI would be in spades . Survival funds for an expanded welfare class with torture from salaried professionals or uppity upper wage class administrators attached. SUPER, THANKS FOR ASKING!
JMG, that’s pretty much correct. I am in the second lowest of five levels of software engineer, at the company I work for anyway. The level I am at is the “average” level, where most of the engineers are. I started at the lowest. The level above me is fairly common, but definitely the minority, and the levels above that are rare. So yes, I am just a worker bee.
“Perhaps it is the hope that they {Meta employees training AI] will get bored and leave. It seems to be preferable for some reason to just making them redundant.”
That’s a quirk in US labor laws. If you leave on your own you get nothing. If you get laid off you get unemployment. At large companies the WARN act applies. If they are laying off a large number of at once they have to give the employees fair warning OR pay them a severance in lieu of that warning.
So if you are a psychopath CEO you want to make the employees miserable enough to quit on their own.
And for paradoctor, as JMG said somewhere above the four categories are a simplification. You can move between them as you go though life. As for Social Security, you could think of it as welfare, but you can also think of it as an annuity. You pay into it after all, in fact you have to pay into it. It’s a notably regressive tax with a progressive payout. SSI (supplemental security income) is a separate program if you don’t qualify for Social Security that really does count as welfare.
Ron M 172
> Obamanation
‼️Perfect moniker‼️
I am totally creeped out. Eeewww. The building is a funeral casket. If I lived in Chicaga, I would move far, far away so there was absolutely no possibility I would ever set foot in that building.
Yet, the building suits Obummer’s character.
💨🧟♂️🪢💨Northwind Grandma
Dane County, Wisconsin, USA
Thank you very much for this essay; here are a few thoughts on it:
I like to compare the lives of PMCs—which overlap significantly with the so-called salaried class—to a “reality tunnel.” At one end is the suburban mansion, at the other end is the conference room, and one travels from one end of the tunnel to the other by company car, plane, or Uber driver. Life outside this tunnel is completely ignored, leading to a collective parallel world. This, coupled with a sense of being the “progressive vanguard of the future,” has resulted in an elite that has lost all contact with a large portion of the population.
The impact will be harsh for these people, as in the future they’ll have to be willing to get their hands dirty. I suspect that suicide will become very common among these people, as their pride will be too great to perform any kind of low-paying, physical labor. This would be the only thing they’ll still be good for in the future, since they’ve never learned any higher-level manual skills.
One aspect to all this that I would imagine you’re not privy to John is the ongoing Gender war. I know you wrote about a recent protest in one of your prior posts, but I also noted that your analysis was limited to those in your own generation, which I suppose is only natural.
Amongst Gen-Z attitudes are much more polarized, which sounds impossible, but is very true. Perhaps the phenomena most emblematic of this was the “Man Vs Bear” question which women posted about incessantly just two years ago. The basic premise being that, if you a woman, were in the woods, would you rather encounter a man or a bear? As you can imagine of such a rhetorical question the answer was inevitably always bear. The feminine class, which for those unaware extends far beyond just those with vagina’s, has saw fit to bludgeon men with rhetoric that amounts to stereotyping at its most base level, all while proclaiming their desire to be freed from the limitations of stereotyping they supposedly endure.
This feminine class seeks to reduce masculinity to rape and violence, while elevating femininity to a blanket catchall for virtue. Of course many men resent that, and many in the feminine class are beginning to sense said resentment; the feminine class, which ironically is aligned in many respects with your salary class, are beginning to panic and scramble for a more clear hierarchal structure; but this has lead to a dissolution and disemboweling of said feminine class. Most principally this can be observed within the transgender movement, perhaps the the example par excellence of the feminine class, which has begun to fall into dissension between the FTM and MTF groups as they increasingly seek to define and restrain one another. One can see this more broadly within the identarian class, which coincides largely with HR harpies, as they begin to rip one another down through ideological purity tests; now being white is not only a privilege, but a sin to these lot, being healthy is something one must pay a tax for, being comfortable with one’s appearance is an injustice which those who torture themselves with plastic surgery and cross sex hormones must make you painfully aware of.
All of this ties neatly into the decline of the American empire, and the loss of reserve currency status, which as you noted has allowed us to consume in a manner unseen before. As our fiat system begins winding down the bad behavior subsidized by the state and corporations which handed out these salaried positions, will forcibly become a thing of the past. Most college graduates today are women, women are debt hungry fiends, they wish to consume endlessly, unfortunately they will be crushed under the weight of their own bad decisions once the rug is pulled out from under them.
@ Tom River # 158
I’m very glad to see you here, and joining this conversation! 🙂 Given that you and I did have had some exchanges on this same topic on a previous thread. (Note our successive comments numbered #185 and #186 here https://ecosophia.net/situationism-the-creation-of-situations/#comment-162172 ).
In that thread, you said:
“…the working class has shown little solidarity to itself, and doesn’t see itself as an exploited class. How can the middle class show solidarity with a class that has no internal solidarity?”
And, well, if you are interested in elaborating, I myself am still interested in hearing more of the thinking that lies behind your phrases “class solidarity” and “see itself as an exploited class”.
Here is a very “on topic” story from the New Zealand Herald:
‘Furious’ minister reveals officials misled her, knowingly avoided Cabinet over ‘doomed’ immigration project, millions wasted
https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/politics/furious-minister-reveals-officials-misled-her-knowingly-avoided-cabinet-over-doomed-immigration-project-millions-wasted/RVHZUPXWZ5BG5G2F2DC2QJCQE4/
Staff dismissals likely for public servants implicated in immigration project scandal – Public Service Commissioner
https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/politics/staff-dismissals-likely-for-public-servants-implicated-in-immigration-project-scandal-public-service-commissioner/PBNVUYWGKFA3RHOVGSXX2PE7SY/
Immigration scandal: Winston Peters accuses MBIE officials of ‘constructive theft’ from public over failed tech project
https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/immigration-scandal-winston-peters-accuses-mbie-officials-of-constructive-theft-from-public-over-failed-tech-project/EHG3BXIOB5FBLAZRM24Z5WAXAE/
It seems that NZ Immigration was involved with a “Big Bang” IT project that went “thermonuclear.” As a 33-year veteran of the IT industry, I have seen more than my share of these.
JMG commented that: The vicious internal politics spawned by bureaucracies made it convenient on occasion for the winners in some conflict to force the defeated party to take responsibility for some crass stupidity or other. … Punishing anyone for failing to do a job adequately was still mostly off the table, and “failing upwards” remained standard.
The question is this – is the above what we are seeing in this case, or may this be the beginning of some actual, serious accountability? It is still early days, so it may be quite a while before we know for sure. If senior officials do serious prison time for this, then we will know that a turning point has been reached, and that “business as usual” is over.
Stock up on the popcorn, folks!
@ paradoctor # 177
The “foot in many camps” position your comment describes – as I see it – promises to allow you to gain a meaningful understanding of members of all the different classes.
You may well be in a position to have real talks with people who otherwise can only see/hear one another from across the high barricades and the deep moats dividing their experiences, their interests and their perspectives.
Whenever there are social, economic, political, cultural barriers to cross, there will always be some people (such as yourself, and myself, to an extent) who straddle the barrier, and can speak usefully to what is on both sides of it.
To my mind, this is a fact to be welcomed.
Ron #172 and JMG, brilliant! Don Surber’s column this morning is about the Obama building, and quotes Oliver Wainwright, “ “Behold the $850 million Obamalisk—or, as it sometimes feels morbidly like, the Obamausoleum.” It’s also coming out that the contractors are owed millions in back payments, so the money slushed out somewhere else.
It really is a monument to bad taste. There was a Pittsburgh mafioso who built a pseudo castle in purple stone with ugly stained glass and a fake Michelangelo mural in the foyer (God, reaching out to the mafioso. I swear it happened, I sold them girl scout cookies.) Even that was less tacky and more humble than the Obamausoleum.
JMG,
This post made me remember my time as a salesman in an outlet of an REI like chain. Various workplaces (the high salary ones) were giving their employees cards, credit or otherwise, that would give their holders discounts in the tens of percentages. Some, by my estimates, were either close or at the profit margins of the chain.
Sometimes, the register would just not give the discounts said employees were supposed to get due to bugs. It did not help those “cards” were often in the form of some kind of a phone app, or a 20 character long computer generated code (which I had to manually type).
Anyways, you should have seen the tantrums and abuse a lot of them threw at me when I was not able to give them the discounts their employer promised them due to the register misbehaving.
Scotlyn says:
@ NeptuneDolphins # 139
PS – is your weather oracle online anywhere?
—–
No. I am trying to get it published, and have been reluctant to put on line anything. I may put a scrap or two at my blog sometime.
JMG wrote:
Neptunesdolphins, …. As for long term grudges, oh dear gods, yes. Have you ever read about the way that former aristocrats cling to the memories of their lost status and waste their lives seething with hatred toward those who displaced them? We’ll see plenty of that.
—-
I see Obama’s monstrosity of a library as that. He has personal animus towards Trump since Trump showed up at a dinner and became the sun everyone revolved around. Obama is a narcissist who disliked being pushed aside by the people at the diner. So the library and the big star party was a thumb in the eye of Trump.
Except Trump is like Sherman, Marching through Georgia. Doesn’t care, doesn’t notice. Now he is more like U.S. Grant as having a multi-theater attack on Obama and the PMC class with various armies.
Hence the big, ugly building will probably be forgotten in a few years except by the “Lost Cause” folks. As far as these buildings go, Clinton’s looks like a trailer spanning the two worlds of working and salary class.
Paradoctor, as I’ve already noted repeatedly, there are gray zones and overlaps between the classes. Any analytical system is a simplification, and has to give up fine detail for the sake of overall clarity — that’s true of every form of communication. (We use the word “dog,” for example, for poodles and St. Bernards alike, despite the vast differences between them.) But of course that always provides room for quibbling.
Anon, yeah, it’s going to get ugly. Very ugly.
AliceEm, exactly. It’s all about maximizing salary class incomes in the name of providing services that aren’t needed to people who can’t afford them.
Luke, the reason I guessed that is that for the last decade or so, the lower half of the salary class has being driven down toward wage class conditions, and their attitudes have been shifting accordingly. It’s especially common for people with genuine skills, such as engineers, to be forced into downward mobility to protect people without genuine skills, such as the staff at HR departments and the like.
Executed, that seems uncomfortably likely.
Astrophane, au contraire, I lurk in a great many places. My analysis two weeks ago focused on a particular class, not an age set, because they were the ones flinging dildos. Yes, I encountered the “man vs. bear” business, and interpreted it as a sign of the panic you describe — the attempt by salary class women to become a uniquely privileged group is collapsing, and the arrangements that put them first in line for newly minted bureaucratic jobs are turning into a massive vulnerability now that those jobs are first in line for layoffs. Expect even more extreme forms of panicked handwaving, especially from those who have used their “multiple axes of oppression” as a means of social climbing.
Michael, thanks for this. The test that will determine whether this is just politics as usual, or the beginning of a new movement toward responsibility, is simple enough: does it stop with that one project? If the government responds by auditing other programs, and finds more waste, the reckoning may have arrived.
M Carole, in an age of ugly and dysfunctional architecture, the Obamanation really does stand out. To call it butt-ugly would be an insult to honest rumps.
Circle, yep. The overprivileged can’t stand not being treated the way they think they ought to be treated, especially in the presence of the underprivileged.
Neptunesdolphins, my guess is that in a few years the Obamanation will be demolished. That may happen sooner than otherwise, since the builders apparently haven’t been paid; I could see some Trump-allied billionaire buying the debt from the construction firms and foreclosing on the building!
Oh, and a final note to all: I was pleased to see that comments about the rape-gangs inquiry, and in particular the way that the “Believe All Women” crowd somehow has nothing to say about the mass rape of British girls by immigrant gangs, are starting to focus on the class difference between the salary class feminists and the wage and welfare class rape victims. It was when the Left started ignoring class issues in general, and privileging the ambitions of well-to-do people of historically oppressed categories above the needs of the genuinely poor and vulnerable, that it ran off the rails. A return to sanity would be helpful…
Regarding the Obamanation: Due to a mistake in reading the drawings, unfortunately, the contractors built it upside down. The pretty part is all buried underground.
Regarding the prospect for peace in the ME: it’s important to remember there are three (3) parties involved, not just two. Call them X, Y, and Z. If both X and Y want peace but Z does not, then peace looks unlikely.
Dear John and all,
As a Mediterranean South European dweller I didn’t notice the:
investment class, the salary class, the wage class, and the welfare class. But yes, they are here also.
From my point of view the investment class and landowning aristocracy are, almost, the same.
I
The USA hegemony rules like the British Empire and have teached the world to love their system through Hollywood. We all want to have the american dream. We abandoned old ways of doing things. Lots of laws have been, and are being, changed to ‘de-risk” and promote foreign investment. But somehow the more and more we try to become Winners the more and more we are becoming Losers. The British system was always rigged. The more modern (British) we become the more like an Irish citizen we are.
As always, thanks for a very thought provoking post.
A nice and beautiful solstice to all,
Agnès
@LukeZ #173
Cheers, friend, hey maybe I should have a beer before posting too…
@Robert Mathiesen #152
Thanks for that comment.
I said above I’ve been using AI tools to model the future. Through this, I’ve been given to understand that many users are secretly asking AI tools questions like, “okay I understand the economy is collapsing but how can *I specifically* invest so I don’t lose my 401(k)?”
Smh.
JMG @ 101 above you have: “The point of the war was to provide plausible political cover for removing sanctions on Iranian oil, since the USA fracking boom is winding down and more oil — any oil, from anywhere — is desperately needed to keep the global economy from imploding. The business in Venezuela? Same thing.
Could you or someone of the commentariat who shares your political views please explain why this war was necessary at all? Why not simply remove sanctions in the first place? The president could surely have found a way to explain the removal that would have made him look like a hero to his faction.
Re, the topic of this post and my first response to it, “music to my ears” and so forth.
I think I’m going to run out of schadenfreude long before this is all over.
Four Sided Circle: I’d hazard a guess that this was exactly how that was intended to work. They get the smile and thank you, you get the caca.
The commentary re trans being a salary class thing: Unfortunately that tracks. Of those with a history of doing blue collar work for a living, I seem to be the only idiot who thought that dealing with gender dysphoria by transitioning is a good idea even if you don’t look even slightly like a woman. There used to be a noticable population of other [transmissions] down here at the lower strata, by which I mean street people and other welfare class. Not anymore, or at least not that I’ve seen in the last few years. I think they must have all detransitioned. Or died.
I used to be part of a [transmission] forum on Mastodon. The others were indeed nearly all salary class. They mostly didn’t show their faces in their pfps either, it was usually anime girls and furry stuff. Except for being a [transmission], I had nothing in common with them.
By transitioning, I have alienated myself from the kind of people I like: blue collar people. And become the darling of people I hold in contempt. Frickin brilliant, that was.
Getting a little far from the topic as well as anything others have said now, so I will stop.
Scotlyn # 130:
“Clearly, bureaucracies and lenocratic habits can exist both in the private sector and the public sector.”
I think you’ve pointed a dirty “secret” which neoliberal globalists and woke leftists pretend it doesn’t exist…
——————————————————————————
Ian D. # 135:
“Ok… well thank you for not sparing the gruesome details.”
I usually try to be discrete online, so you’re welcome…On the other hand, about current situation in Spain: we’ll see…
———————————————————————
Mithridates # 137:
“it seems like few people on English-language social media like to talk about class; they’d rather frame it as a dualistic culture war battle.”
Well, it seems in every country dogs bite: at least here, even the “Left” stopped speaking about social classes some years ago to begin their obsession with genders, sexual tendences and racism/xenophobia…Of course, impoverishment of political debate has worsened and accelerated, too, during all these last years.
————————————————————————-
Astrophane # 184:
“The basic premise being that, if you a woman, were in the woods, would you rather encounter a man or a bear? As you can imagine of such a rhetorical question the answer was inevitably always bear.”
A good example of current mainstream feminist misandria, methink. Misandria, like its symetrical opposite within some of men, named misogyny, dehumanizes the “enemy”. Well, if you look at previous succesful attempts to dehumanize religious and ethnical groups with hatred and more hatred against them, things usually end badly (typical example: Jews). It seems pseudospeciation is another way to depict this ominous tendence. Maybe I’m afraid some radical feminists think men aren’t really human beings (cough).
https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/pseudospeciation
JMG,
Today’s holiday is a good example of the salary class using an underprivileged group to get themselves perks. Juneteenth was happily celebrated by African Americans all over the country on the third Sunday in June with cookouts and family gatherings after church. The woke crowd took over and saw it as a chance to get themselves more privilege and another day off work.
In my wife’s agency ,the woke white women in the administration threw an absolute fit to get Juneteenth as a paid weekday holiday for themselves. My wife resisted until the city government and county government around her did it. And then only when the predominantly white salary class women of the County Board of Commissioners forced the issue ,did she give in.
I just took note in today’s newspapers that all the Juneteenth celebrations, by the actual black community in Portland, will be taking place on Saturday and Sunday including the parade and rodeo ( yes a Juneteenth Rodeo). That is because most of the community lacks the salary class jobs that get them the privilege of a paid day off during the week. That day off is for the salary class white folk in cushy government jobs and woke corporations.
Astrophane, I wait to see upon which women those men who think as you do take out their frustrations. My guess, it will be the usual suspects, the plain, the poor, and the mentally deficient, and never mind their actual culpability. If my own preparations are any guide, those of us in the first two categories are even now taking such steps as we can to protect ourselves.
Northwind, we don’t all live in farming areas nor have the means to buy property in such areas. For many who might like to set up workshops, the costs of the space needed is prohibitive, and then there is insurance as well as zoning restrictions–those were put in place to please real estate investors, not the PMC class, and then of course the local and state restrictive regulations on top of that. As sometime dressmaker, I have had to turn down the requests to make wedding dresses because I simply did not have the means to acquire the dedicated, vacuumed daily, used for nothing else space that would be needed. There is a reason why successful commercial dressmakers are often married to high salaried professional men. As for “James”, I think I prefer the present system in which the Jameses can be be arrested and jailed.
Bill’s got the annotated Pepys’ diaries. He’s read them too!
I’ll have to put them on my TBR.
He thinks he has, somewhere, Grose’s A Dictionary of the Vulgar Tongue. He’ll hunt for it because I need amusing unfamiliar slang for my “Steppes of Mars” series.
I just love something being the bee’s knees or codswallop!
@ Bofur #159
Some background on The Jane Austen Project.
Bill and I watched, reviewed, and published two huge books about the films of Agatha Christie. No one had ever done this before. You can find the information here: https://peschelpress.com/agatha-christie-she-watched/
https://peschelpress.com/international-agatha-christie-she-watched/
After we recovered from that six-year project, we looked around and, as change of pace from murder, decided to do the same for Jane Austen.
Shockingly, considering the tens of thousands of books about Jane and every single aspect of her world, NO ONE has actually watched, reviewed, and then published a big book about the film adaptations of her novels. You’ll get a deep dive into a given film (maybe) but no overview.
There are nearly 100 adaptations (theatrical and TV) that we know about from around the world. This doesn’t include documentaries, biopics, and Jane-adjacent material like “The Jane Austen Book Club.”
As with Agatha, we’ll watch EVERYTHING.
BUT! To properly set the stage to better understand the late-Georgian and Regency period, we’re starting with films (which I review) about her time period. It’s shocking how much I DID NOT KNOW.
The Gordon Riots (see “Barnaby Rudge”)
King George III’s mental illness leading directly to the Regency (The Madness of King George)
various films about the American Revolution.
various films about the French Revolution and what led directly to it.
Beethoven was a contemporary, as was Mary Shelley, John Keats, and Percy Shelley. I knew about Lord Byron and Beau Brummell. Other famous people like Catherine the Great. This means more biopics of varying quality.
The British Navy leading to “H.M.S Defiant” (the Spithead Mutiny), “The Bounty” (the somewhat realistic one with Anthony Hopkins and Mel Gibson), and “Master and Commander.” Some biopics about Lord Nelson.
Napoleon, Waterloo, and “Vanity Fair.”
Debtors’ Prisons and the beginnings of the Industrial Revolution with “Little Dorrit.”
Peterloo (2018) which was horrifying, yet still dragged as a film.
I want to include these movies because they illustrate the larger world surrounding Jane Austen’s novels. It’s easy to forget that although she merely touched upon the larger world, that world greatly influenced her life and her novels. For most people, movies are a great way to introduce this larger world. She did not live or write in a vacuum!
Watching the movies depicting Jane’s larger world will take us up into November 2026. Then we start Jane proper with documentaries and biopics. We’ll livestream our discussion on our YouTube Channel, too, like we’re doing now with rewatching Agatha Christie (see https://www.youtube.com/@peschelpress9911/streams
I’ll get around to posting my extensive film lists on my empty Substack sometime later this summer.
You know Mr. Greer, whenever I glimp an image of that half-built ‘Obamanation’, as you characterize it .. what I see, flanked on two sides, are blasted and crumpled ‘Imperial Walkers’ – their blackened innards turned inside out, the resulting debris scattered about it’s base. Where’s a MacGyvered Death Star, when you really, really need one, am I right! Then there’s that UFC Thunderdome, perched upon that White Haus lawn – 2 men enter, *everyone leave. ‘Everyone’ being those lower classes who can’t afford the inflated tickets.. let alone the arrested protesting prize fighter who crashed the party! *WWAD – What Would Auntie Do??
@Mithridates:
I noticed that when the Scottish-axe-girl story was making the rounds. It was so weird and jarring and I’m still struggling with the implications.
What I noticed: on every significant comment thread attached to that story, there was at least one, maybe more, comment that went like: “Oh, I’m in the UK, and you Americans just don’t understand: these girls are low-class trash, so this is a non-story. They’re probably lying and whatever happens to them, they deserve it anyway.” Not those exact words, but pretty dang close. One gets the impression that they’d sooner defend dogs, horses, and pigs from abuse than low-class British girls. I used to think UK people were basically Americans with better manners and different accents. Not anymore. If, as I suspect, these attitudes are common in everybody from the middle class up: well, they’re trash and they probably deserve what’s happening to their country. I wouldn’t be against accepting some of their speech-persecuted as asylum-seekers.
Hi John,
Great post as always.
I’m a member of the salary class and work in financial services. Where I live we have a massive financial services industry for a small jurisdiction which has done very well for decades.
I fell into it after university years ago and have got to a middle level position doing work that is required under our complex regulatory framework.
I’ll be honest with you, I quite like the job still and until recently the pressures have been limited. Unlike most salary class folk I know, I’ve always been prudent, prioritised clearing debt and living a modest lifestyle along the lines you have advocated for years.
We are now seeing AI being used more and more (and its capabilities have definitely got a lot better in the last 6 months or so). The work I got the AI to do recently – it took me roughly 20 minutes beginning to end – was superior to anything our internal audit team who I’m sure are paid a lot! – came up with in terms of what we do within our team.
The firm I work for has recently been taken over by quite a aggressive new company and job losses are coming (although I think I’m pretty save for now).
The good news is I’m fairly insulated for now but longer-term should start thinking about alternative careers/skills. Your comment about the rise of the investment class fascinates me. Is there any way mere mortals like me can get a modest income stream via the rise of these investment class kings in the future.
My own thinking is waiting for a crash in the markets – currently thinking around 2029 or so – and buying long-term quality companies that we will always need. Any thoughts?
JMG 192
> Executed:
I suspect that suicide will become very common among these people, as their pride will be too great to perform any kind of low-paying, physical labor. This would be the only thing they’ll still be good for in the future, since they’ve never learned any higher-level manual skills.
< JMG:
Executed, that seems uncomfortably likely.
The classic job that comes to mind is ”ditch-digger.”
My grandfather, Isaiah (born 1892), an electrician, a man who could build just about anything (heritage: a British stiff-upper-lip, canal-er and farming family who trained their thirteen kids useful mechanical and construction skills galore, whose work ethic was top echelon), during the Great Depression of the 1930s, lost his electrician job at the one humongatoid corporation in his small city, partly because he was white. (That is another story.) He saw his cohorts join bread-lines but he considered bread-lines beneath him (which according to his heritage was begging; or ominously close to being forced into a Work House, so he never stood in any bread-lines. With a wife and two daughters to feed and provide shelter, he swallowed his pride and took a garbage-man job. It might as well have been a ditch-digger.
Isaiah got the family through those years. But even though he was never called up for military service of World War II (in his forties), it was the one-two punch of the Depression+WWII that did him in.
With Isaiah, by age 15, he was skilled in so many things that, I am sure, he navigated job situations deftly over his lifetime. So being a garbage-man humiliated him, it was a temporary situation (a ‘temp’ job), and he was back to doing the construction work he loved within a reasonable time. His family, nor any of his siblings and cousins, nor his parents, starved. The whole bunch of them were “jack-of-all-trades,” so it wasn’t hard to get the next job.
We will be returning to this. Half of men of the late 1800s had an array of skills,— half of men (like migrants and/or couldn’t speak English) had zero skills, so they were the ditch-diggers. Isaiah never was a ditch-digger.
Speaking as a family historian having research this particular line, I know that Isaiah‘s parents, grandparents, great-grandparents, and 2nd great-grandparents, came from the proprietor class of Norfolk County, England (moved between Suffolk County and Lincolnshire), and were made homeless by 1840 due to massive social changes. It is likely their ancestors were farmers, canal-ers, and/or cloth-weavers. Around 1840, when several of the children became adults age 20 or over, three-four emigrated to Australia, two-three remained in England, and one emigrated to Quebec, Canada, then floated down Lake Champlain into New York State (Isaiah’s branch).
The parents of all the 20-year old children remained in England living with those of their children who stayed; they died in England. The whole bunch of ’em were literate, although many in the subsequent generation were not.
BOLSTERS
My point. Accept any sort of job, because each is temporary and one gains new skills and meets new people. Be scrappy and hustle. If one can hustle, one and one’s family won’t starve. I wish I had known this as a teen and in my 20s. Family bolsters a person. I tried to go it alone, and that only half worked out, because I had no bolsters. I see that now. Build your network of “bolsters”: human, animal, plant.
Now I have added a new word to our catchwords in the hopes to help readers at what looks to be a (very) rocky road ahead (depending): community; neighborhood; bolsters. I view this lasting at least a generation.
Most all of us are here because our ancestors worked. I realize that some people’s ancestors were able to use slaves to do their work for them, but I feel those lineages will die off, because wastrel-families do that, they fade into oblivion. The investment-class are wastrels; so is much of the salary-class. Working families flourish more times than not; they don’t fade.
So even though Grandfather Isaiah hunkered down when he had to, he got his family through hard times. (His daughters also worked when they came of age.)
“Acquire a strong work ethic” and one does get through arduous junctures.
I won’t be around for it, at least not in this lifetime. Maybe if I wish hard enough (I think I can; I think I can; I think I can) (and click my ruby slippers together), maybe I will be lucky enough to be born of hardworking farm (human) stock of Wisconsin, a family who teaches a vast array of skills that farmers must in order to perform the dozens of things that keep a farm going.
Or research any of the dozens what one may euphemistically call “careers,“ but are really “jobs.” Things one does with one’s hands, making or fixing things.
My forerunners used to say, “Make yourself useful.”
Make yourself useful, and one will do well. One falls into work that eventually pays well. A job one creates. Jobs don’t grow on trees. In this new era, there is no way someone else is going to provide one with “a good job,” because if the job is that good, that other person will take that job and you will never hear of it. Just like if you create “a good job,” you yourself will take that job, where you tell no-one of that job because you are covetous of that job and will keep it to oneself, and you will be very busy working that job. Logical.
The days of people creating others’ jobs is over. One can loaf around forever waiting for someone to give a person “a good job” and nothing will come of it. No “good job” will fall into one’s lap. Passive days are finished.
Over the last year or two, JMG and the commentariat have talked about the kinds of jobs that will be around next year, in ten years, in thirty years, and more. Think apprenticeships. The conversations are too numerous to reiterate, so do some back-reading.
I would be interested in learning more about what 45-60 year olds can/will do when they get unceremoniously booted out of their work situation,— they obviously must re-train along with youngsters, but what, how, and when. The 45-60 age-group has significant needs because of their existing commitments. What future do they have? Must their future be a “situation tragedy”?
In olden days, the man of the house sometimes took a temporary job away (sometimes far away) from home, where he leaves the wife and kids behind. I think this category is called ‘transient.’
If arty-fisheel ill-telligence CANNOT do a certain job, go for it.
Can arty-fisheel ill-telligence pave a road? No. Can arty-fisheel ill-telligence prune a tree? No. Can arty-fisheel ill-telligence bake a loaf of bread? No. Can arty-fisheel ill-telligence mend a pair of jeans? No.
💨💪🏼👴🏼📚👨🏻🏫🔧🪚💨Northwind Grandma
Dane County, Wisconsin, USA
Speaking of the machinations of the salary/PMC class.
https://pjmedia.com/matt-margolis/2026/06/19/gabbard-drops-bombshell-documents-on-her-way-out-exposing-faucis-covid-cover-up-n4954136
The rapidly rising income and wealth inequality in Canada have made me think about how a less unequal society would look like. It is rather easy to imagine a society where everybody is equally poor in material terms. I started a thought experiment how a society would look like where the average citizen is relatively prosperous in terms of energy access, but where it is rare for anybody to gain more than double what anybody else gains.
The first examples I thought of:
– People would rarely eat out at a restaurant or even order by delivery.
– They might instead invite each other to house parties with relatively elaborate food and drink.
– People would rarely stay at a hotel or resort.
– Many people might want a second home or a mobile home or might go camping
This is probable idle speculation at this point, but I was surprised that thinking from first principles, I arrived at habits that recall what I have heard about the 1950s!
Another of my favorite historical periods is 15th Century England – the run-up to
the War of the Roses, and how it’s so much like our own times. The money economy is starting to erode the feudal system from underneath; serfdom is slowly dying out as their lords – often absentee – prefer straightforward money payments rather than the labor of keeping track of the customary rights, privileges, etc; and you could even find very affluent villeins in some villages. Not to mention villages owned by several different lords or other entities at once. And buying themselves free was on the rise everywhere.
In the affluent, privileged salary class of the period- the priesthood – a priest could own several Livings – be the rector of several churches – and appoint poorly-paid vicars to do the work. (Hence the term “sinecure” for a well-paid position full of perks that doesn’t entail any work. The total collapse of that had to wait for a massive regime change much later, of course – “Thank you,Tudors-” which also meant the collapse of the last of the social safety nets.
History does repeat itself, or at least, it rhymes. As for the total collapse of the ruling class – the corrupt and incompetent crowd around a passive puppet king …..the period was also called “The Retreat from France….
a situation as bad as pre-Revolutionary France in the 18th century.
Any resemblance to situations of the present is purely … coincidental?
Agnes #194 In the novel or movie The Gatopardo you’ll find a good portrait about the sucesion of upper classes in the South of Europe. In the alliance between the Count of Lampedusa and the local landlord and business man Don Calogero, linked with the Mafia.
JMG & Commentariat,
The timing of this blog post worked out very well. Tulsi Gabbard just released documents pertaining to early COVID responses. These documents provide evidence that the US Government was funding Coronavirus research in the Wuhan lab to understand the risks of bat coronavirus emergence, with a specific focus on understanding the disease as it affects “humanized mice.”
The further allegations are that Fauci, and the U.S. Health Department, were aware of the lab leak evidence as early as May 2020, and used the wet market origin theory as a means to suppress the origin of a problem that was funded by the U.S. Federal Government.
If the story holds, this means that the Shirky Principle applies to COVID fiasco, as the bureaucrats of the medical-industrial complex who were in charge of preventing the spread of viral disseases unwittingly manufactured a pandemic, and then leveraged their bureaucratic authority to ensure the only solution came from the medical-industrial complex.
The story, for further reading, can be found here, but I encourage everyone to find diverse sources to the story: https://www.zerohedge.com/covid-19/gabbard-drops-fauci-covid-19-receipts-last-day-he-funded-research-cooked-cover-story-then
On the topic of technological retrovation, I have been thinking that a good way to put my IT skills to productive and profitable re-use is to start a business that involves breathing new life into old computer hardware. Awhile ago I had idea about how the Appropriate Technology ethos could be revived and applied to the world of computing.
Over the past several years the price of key hardware components like graphics cards, RAM/memory, and SSD storage drives have shot up into the stratosphere, because all those new “AI” data centers have been gobbling up the supply of those components. What this has effectively done is put brand new computers out of reach for anyone without disposable income. At the same time, Microsoft recently started imposing very specific hardware requirements for the ability to install or upgrade to Windows 11, which renders countless machines, many as new as 4-5 year old, incompatible (unless one is tech saavy enough to bypass that limitation). Too add insult to injury, Microslop ended security updates and support for Windows 10 last October. So now we have countless people with perfectly good computers that can no longer get support because M$ just made Windows 10 obsolete. And let’s not forget all the bloat, spyware, ads, and invasive updates M$ loads into every Windows installation. I’ve heard plenty of reports of even brand new computers running sluggish on Windows11. This whole mess is a perfect illustration of how enshalelification works. M$ has essentially taken what used to be a great tool for personal computer users and turned it into an obnoxious sales funnel for their ecosystem of subscription cloud services and integrated LLM garbage most people never asked for.
It seems Big Tech in general wants to turn every aspect of computing into a subscription service, instead of offering products you pay for once then own a copy of forever until YOU decide to replace it with something else. A few releases ago, that “My Computer” icon on your desktop went to being “This Computer.” That’s right, it’s Microslop’s computer, not yours. Basically, you will own nothing and be happy. To me this signals that these tech giants have long ago stopped innovating and instead have shifted to naked rent-seeking. Whether it’s Microslop, Rotten Apple, Evil Google, or the Big Slimy River of Schlock, it’s all degraded into the same terrible and exploitative end-user experience.
Thankfullly, Linux can breathe new life into these perfectly good computers, not to mention very old hardware too. There’s a number of Linux distros today that are very user friendly and offer an even better form of the Windows desktop experience most people are very used to. And a Linux desktop stays out of your way and doesn’t try to sell you stuff. I really think Microslop has shot themselves in the foot and opened the door wide for alternative operating systems to start gaining more and more market share. So many people and small businesses will have to start using Linux because they can’t afford new computers. On the more political end of things, I think there can no greater act of technological détournement than using your computer the way YOU wan to use it, not the way Big Tech giants want you using computers.
Might providing IT services along these lines be a good business opportunity as things keep going south? Might this also be a good way to nudge people into being more selective about which technologies they use in their daily lives. I know more and more people have woken up to the idea that what’s new is now often much worse than what preceded it. More and more people now are longing for the days of flip-phones and the ability to actually get human being on the other end when they call a business. Growing numbers of people don’t want the internet inside their washing machine or their coffee maker. I think a whole subculture could be crafted out of this new Appropriate Tech ethos! I’m imagining, “Technology, as if people mattered.”
Finally, if my Appropriate Tech firm (or maybe just an informal grey market outfit) actually becomes something, one thing I can most certainly promise is that there will be no HR department!
@Bofur #132
Yes! Thank you for your example. That’s more or less what I expected, but it’s nice to have it illustrated so colorfully, nonetheless! And that you got that response even after writing what I can only presume was a short essay asking it to set aside all of its unspoken biases only proves the point: these things are not nearly as flexible in their “thinking” as their marketers or executives would have you believe.
Ah, but anyway, I’m about to launch into a rant, and this is getting decidedly off-topic, so I’ll stop here. Still, thanks for sharing your experience, I’m glad I gave you something to laugh about 🙂
Ruminating further on the classes, would wage class with benefits really have different interests than wage class without benefits?
In other words is wage class alone a sufficient marker of the class?
Dear John Michael Greer, Thanks for another thought-provoking essay. As a novelist, quite necessarily, I find the endless human game of status-jockying fascinating. Much of the salary class that I find myself interacting with is behaving in precisely the ways you describe.
Applying your analysis to the publishing industry, and that would include the salaried employees of the university presses, hmmm, outlook mega grim. On the other hand, for those willing to tackle publishing from outside the salary class, and to think outside the box, outside the window, sideways in the cellar, and oh, say, bring in the dancing camels on Tuesdays, this could be swirly fun.
If you are unsure if your hourly job with benefits is wage or salary, in the USA, the answer is simple: do you have today (Juneteenth) off? Labor Day? Memorial Day? Veteran’s Day? Salary class gets holidays, wage class does not.
I think, as a household affected by this, that the Affordable Care Act, aka Obamacare, was designed if not intended to push much wage class into welfare class. If you don’t get health insurance paid for by your employer, you go on the exchange, and try to find out pricing, and get told you don’t qualify because you don’t make enough, go apply for Medicaid. Well, with Medicaid, you get hit with asset restrictions. So you can’t save up to replace or repair your old car, which you need to get to your job, so you have to take an usurious loan when it breaks down, and you can’t buy a new car with your income so you have to buy a used one on that loan, which breaks down, and so on. And everything else the same. Rent to own your refrigerator . . .
So the ACA fined you for being smart enough to not get into that trap. That, at least, got removed.
The claimed intent was that everyone would have health care. The result was to push wage class into welfare class. And as everyone knows, good doctors don’t take Medicaid. No dentists take Medicaid here. So you have health care on paper, but not in practice. Better to stay out of that mess and pay cash, and then you can at least get stitches and bones set.
Well, the local hospital decided to drop out of network with the largest insurance company in the area, so now half the local salary class are finding out what Medicaid recipients have already known about the imposibility of getting care, because the hospital ate most private practice. (Both the hospital and the insurance are blaming each other, of course.) Since the hospital is in trouble for not sterilizing surgical equipment and for retaliating against the whistleblowers, being out of network will probably save lives anyway.
People are talking about the county ought to pull out of the hospital group and build a new county hospital (the old one having been merged into this hospital). Don’t know that’ll happen, too expensive, but people are talking about it.
Phutatorius, peace? The agreement with Iran isn’t about peace. It’s purely an arrangement to allow the US to duck out of the Persian Gulf and pretend not to have lost.
Agnes, playing a rigged game generally works out that way!
Mary, the problem is that there’s a very large pro-Israel faction in the GOP that Trump, and all other GOP politicians, has to placate, and they won’t tolerate the US backing out of the region without some bombs being flung. So the US had to go through the motions. There was also the hope, heavily pushed by those same interests, that the Iranian government would collapse; that didn’t happen, of course, but hindsight is always 20/20.
Cynthia, gracefully [euphemized]. Thank you!
Clay, yep.
Teresa, Grose is essential, and also amazingly funny. Where else can you learn that short-sheeting a bed used to be called making it up apple-pie fashion, or that the chief of a band of thieves in Regency Britain was called the Upright Man, or that “potato trap” was a term for the mouth — as in, “Shut your potato trap and give your tongue a holiday!” Project Gutenberg has it for free download:
https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/5402
Polecat, I won’t argue about either one of those absurd structures!
Forecasting, as I’m well outside that whole world, I won’t presume to offer advice.
Northwind, those who’ve never done hard physical work in their lives are poorly prepared to do it in middle Age.
Beardtree, well, what did I say about the salary class inventing problems?
Aldarion, good. You’re getting it. We may be able to return to that, for at least a while.
Patricia M, a very close parallel, complete with a failing aristocracy and a rising new class.
Mrdobner, yep. “Gain of function” means “inventing a bioweapon,” full stop, end of sentence.
Mithridates, that strikes me as an extremely smart move. I use exclusively old, reconditioned computers, and I know many other people who do the same thing; I also know that I’d be interested in trying Linux if it came preinstalled and tested on an old machine and it was set up to run as a Windows-like visual environment.
Siliconguy, an interesting question that would have to be settled by research.
C.M., publishing is a great example, not least because the big presses these days no longer have any idea how to publish books that people want to read. Major shifts are on the way!
BoysMom, thanks for this. Yeah, that’s about right.
Mithridates: Hear hear to all that, re computers. I have exactly one of those that you mentioned, a machine that originally shipped with Windows 10 that was set to be obsoleted last October. I didn’t wait until October and I don’t miss Windows.
Actually, about that…
Mother Balance: Are you still here? How’d the whole Linux thing go?
Also:
About Man vs Bear. It makes sense for women to regard men in general as a security concern. If a woman finds herself alone with an unfamiliar man, she has no way of knowing whether that one in particular is inclined to assault her or engage in gross behaviour towards her. “Man vs Bear” was about that, but some men seem to think that their feelings about how they are viewed, or concerns about “misandry”, are more important than taking an honest look at the legitimate concern of women concerning their bodily safety. It tells abusive men that other tripods basically have their back. In fact I’m not sure that isn’t generally true.
I don’t buy that any of that is about to hanging on to salary class privileges, which I’d still like to see the end of, even if I’m not quite as gleeful as I was at first take.
Actually, this helped me to realize that using the ladies room as I had been doing up to then was nfg. (THAT acronym I will explain because Google produces a slightly humourous mistake. It is not “New Found Gold”. The first word is “no” and the third word is “good”.) Ideology, political leanings, and desire to include all notwithstanding, and in spite of my best efforts, my physical appearance identifies me as “man”, triggering the expected atavistic responses in women. I have had to accept that this means I have no right to enter a ladies room, trans or no trans. I have no right or wish to frighten women. This means also means I basically can’t go anywhere out of bathroom range from home (walking), because I’ll get the [stuffing] kicked out of me if I try to use a men’s room.
But you’ll never hear me complaining about how unfair it is for women to regard me as potentially dangerous. Of course they do! *I* know I’m not going to do anything to them, but it would be absurd to expect them to just *know* that.
Incidentally, even at the height of my delusion, no force in the universe would have ever made me think it was ok to enter a ladies *changing* room. I knew from the get go that anything that involved changing rooms, I was giving up forever.
Word of advice for anyone who’s thinking of transitioning, not that that’s in style anymore: DON’T!! It is NOT WORTH IT.
(There I go again, trans, trans, trans, trans… Sorry! I really don’t mean to be making everything about that!)
Great essay Mr Greer
Just a curious thought. If you took the mythology of progress away from the Salary class would they still be politically left?
They certainly have the snobbery of the traditional conservative class of my country down pat.
Hi John, Brilliant! The initial four-quadrant sort really got my mind racing. I’ve seen, and used, four-quadrant sorts to analyse tricky problems before, but I don’t recall seeing it applied to the current income disparities in this way before. Yes, many of us commonly think in terms of two way separations (government vs private-enterprise); democrat vs. republican; 99% vs 1%; etc.) but that SECOND cut, to make four quadrants makes many problems a lot easier to think through (and going into further cuts doesn’t help nearly as much).
Anyway, thank you very much for giving us this “Sorting Hat” (TM, Rowling) for the present time.
Here’s an associated question: What “Four Quadrant” setup are we moving INTO? That, to my mind, is a million dollar question: If we can get it right in our heads at this time, we have a really good shot at side stepping an awful lot of grief.
Do you have any four-quadrant model to propose? Even if you aren’t quite certain, I’d appreciate your first cut hypothesis. I’m trying hard to get ready, but I am having a hard time settling on WHAT, exactly, to get ready for. There seem to be too many possibilities. But, at a high level, I suspect we will discover there are really just about four.
That the investment class will benefit from the incoming economic environment at the same time that the price of real estate collapses is a great example of how the future we will be getting will confound the minds of many.
Even if this combination doesn’t happen, the combination that does come will be stranger still
On Grose’s magnificent Dictionary, take a look now at this:
https://www.peterharrington.co.uk/blog/the-original-slang-dictionary-francis-groses-own-copy-of-his-classical-dictionary-of-the-vulgar-tongue/
The bookseller rightly realized the importance of this copy, Grose’s own copy, of the first edition (1785) of his Dictionary, with his significant additions and comments toward the second edition (1788), and he made them permanently available to all on his website.
Both editions can be downloaded from various sites on the web.
@ Cererean / Alice: Some people did it. From 2010 – 2020 there was an Internet fad for FIRE: Financial Indepence, Retire Early. Salary-class bloggers wrote about getting out of debt, downscaling lifestyles, learning DIY skills and investing the spare cash. Blogs such as Mr Money Mustache, Early Retirement Extreme and Millennial Revolution advised readers on becoming independently wealthy through thrift.
There’s a real psychological shift required to re-orient one’s identity away from the job and the consumption, and build it around something else. The blogs and forums served as a new peer group. Interestingly, a lot of these people were engineers, usually in software.
Regarding displaced bureaucrats: there was a New York Times story in 2025 about people who got laid off during the USAID shutdown, and how they were doing a year later. A few got similar jobs in the private sector, some moved overseas and some had to sell their houses or rely on welfare.
These were people earning $150 – $250K / yr, usually married to someone similar. Where did the money go? Not to the mortgage, apparently. I feel bad for people who lost that kind of salary suddenly, but there seemed to be no attempt to save for a rainy day and no reflection from anyone that maybe they should have.
What are the odds that significant numbers of the professional class would, to repurpose a term from your Situationism series, “go alpha”? This is the class that has produced by far the biggest share of the modern era’s terrorists, rebels, and revolutionaries. It seems likely that at least a few of them would try to dust off Lenin’s old playbook to remain in power.
@Mary Bennett
“Astrophane, I wait to see upon which women those men who think as you do take out their frustrations.”
Of course, we all do hope around here that blowback will simply involve the burdensome priviledged losing their grip on everyone else, but alas and as our host has already elaborated in another domain, religious and spiritual freedom, the consequences of today’s behaviour may pour the proverbial child out with the bathwater.
And that means, fringe occult interests may be judged indiscriminate whether or not they lean to demonolatry, and purged by a wild mob, and yes, concerning women, in the worst case it will not only be the priviledged wrongdoers to suffer, but innocents to from that pushback that is building.
The best way to stoke the flame of this pushback, and to guarantee it pushes back way across the line, is to attack the people who share their view of things and their experiences indiscriminately for their built up scorn they show.
I have dealt with anti social personalities and those stepping across lines a few times in my life;
I can guarantee you one thing, Mary Bennett: while you can often find a way to their heart by aknowledging their experiences, otherwise their motto will be: “you don’t care about me – therefore I do not care about you either”.
“Brandi, yeah, Graeber put his usual spin on things — “Everything I don’t like about society is the fault of the evil investment class!” It’s a very popular bit of salary class scapegoating, and helps distract attention from the salary class’s active involvement in creating and profiting from the situation. ”
I think that many academics don’t quite fit in this schema. One would have to classify them as salary class, but for many (most?), the immediate enemy is not the wage class but the administrators who have come to infest universities. In other words, their immediate enemy is a distinct portion of their own class.
In Graeber’s case in particular, he was born into the working class (though the red diaper wing of it) and one of the main reasons he was denied tenure at Yale was his support for the graduate student union there. So I am skeptical of portraying him as someone theorizing on behalf of administrators and HR departments.
I also suspect that you and I disagree on how much power the administrator wing of the salary class has independent of its service to the investment class. I would say it is quite small.
Yes, the salary class threw the wage class under the bus, but the investment class was the bus.
This is the structure of things. How it appears to people is often closer to your analysis.
“NYU professor Clay Shirky has done the best job explaining the critical issue. His Shirky Principle runs as follows: “Institutions will try to preserve the problem to which they are the solution.”
This definitely has some interesting implications for core state institutions like the police and the education system, as Oswegatchie’s comment at #4 also touched on. Then again, maybe the school system is in a different position, in that it doesn’t need to manufacture the “problem” since every new generation is born illiterate, and the state enforces 100% attendance anyway. The Principle probably does apply in full force to what we might as well call “the academic-education industrial complex”, ie. all those salary class academics doing research to “improve” schools. Lately I’ve had the dubious pleasure of getting some glimpses into that world, and to my mind most of it seems to be about creating vast, billowing fog banks of dense academic prattle rather than anything useful. Other than lavish salaries for those involved, no doubt. Or: maybe this is where much of the money Oswegatchie laments ended up?
“The news next to nobody wants to hear is that those lifestyles are going away forever. All of us will have to get used to living much more frugally in the years ahead.”
Yep. Maybe one good thing to come of all this is that people won’t be able to deny it anymore. I’m both surprised and disappointed that most of mainstream society is *still* acting like it’s basically 2005, even now. Even if they admit times aren’t as prosperous anymore, they still seem to be fully committed to the idea that eternal growth is natural and normal, and will resume any day now after a few temporary setbacks. I have to admit I’m getting sick and tired of the pretense at this point.
@Aldarion #208
Your list seems like a pretty fair description of how it works here in Scandinavia, or at least how it used to work between maybe 1975 and now. For all our other faults, it’s probably fair to say we really are much more equal than the UK or North America, both economically and culturally, even if that seems to be changing for the worse now. Anyway, eating out is indeed extremely expensive here, “drinking out” even more so, and second homes are very popular. That’s actually led to an environmental disaster of its own, since rural municipalities tend to raze their last few pockets of relatively pristine wilderness so rich people from the cities can build second homes there. And of course many of these are now regular upper class houses with a rustic look rather than the spartan cottages of the post-War era. Still, that’s a rant for another time…(and a problem I suspect you might have in Canada as well)
@Mithridates #212
Best of luck with the prospective business. I switched to Linux more than a decade ago now and never looked back, and anything that gets more people out of the walled MS and Apple gardens is a good thing in my book. These days I’ve even opted for an Ubuntu OS for my phone, which also feels like a neat detournement. This way I can use it for internet access (which is much cheaper for me that way), calls and texts, but I’m not able to use any other apps, so it’s basically like a “dumb phone” with a camera and internet. Suits me fine.
On a semi-related note to your comment, I wish more public institutions would be good examples and use Linux and free software rather than all the MS stuff. In their infinite wisdom, politicians here in Norway have also decided to add digital skills as one of the four core skills to be taught in public schools, along with the traditional reading, writing, maths and “oral expression”. You’d think this would involve things like teaching students how to install a basic Linux distro, but in my experience it tends to mean just handing them a tablet from the aforementioned rotten apple and making them poke around at apps in the walled garden. If you’re going to give every kid a computer, at least make them do something halfway useful with it! (Plus, giving them old laptops with Linux would save a lot of money compared to buying new from the Not So Pristine Fruit.) So it seems like the worst of both worlds, compared to forgoing the screens in the first place as the other option.
#219 in the words of the Ferengi Quark from Star Trek Deep Space 9:
“Let me tell you something about Hew-mons, Nephew. They’re a wonderful, friendly people, as long as their bellies are full and their holosuites are working. But take away their creature comforts, deprive them of food, sleep, sonic showers, put their lives in jeopardy over an extended period of time and those same friendly, intelligent, wonderful people… will become as nasty and as violent as the most bloodthirsty Klingon. You don’t believe me? Look at those faces. Look in their eyes”
@ Cynthia Christie #197
You have described what must be an intractable predicament. (Which our host frequently refers to as that which cannot be solved, only responded to). And it sounds difficult and uncomfortable, as best I can judge from here.
If you will have them, I would offer you my blessings. And also, if you will have it, my trust that useful responses may become more apparent and ready to hand for you quite soon.
@Chuaquin, yes exactly. Talking only about race and gender proved itself to be the perfect way of obfuscating class divide issues. Notice how the wokification of everything in big institutions happened just a couple years after Occupy Wall St. died down. Suddenly, no one with a megaphone was talking about the 1% anymore, but rather about those aforementioned terms of misdirection. Of course, OWS itself conveniently ignored the salary/wage class divide, rather sticking to the “investment class vs. everyone else” script that has been a mainstay of American leftism for a very long time.
@methylethyl, yes “white trash” have been the one group that’s uber politically correct to hate on, pretty much anywhere in the Anglosphere.
@Jessica, actually I see salaried academics as being the EPITOME of entitled salary class culture. For years this has been the go-to career for mediocre, lazy salary class people who fancy themselves as intellectuals, who want to get paid a cushy salary without having to do a whole lot of work. In recent decades, a professor job has largely become sinecure employment for the most ardent loyalists of the prog-leftist ideology.
And the meaningful divide in academia today isn’t between full time professors and administrators, but rather between full time professors and adjuncts. Basically, adjuncts are the wage class of academia. They get paid scraps and (usually) give zero benefits. And as more full-timers retire or die, those vacant full-time positions are NOT being filled, but rather eliminated with those course slots being allotted to adjuncts. Yet another case of affluent baby boomers pulling up the ladder after they’ve had all their fun. Many such cases.
@BorealBear Thanks! You might be pleased to learn that the government of France is in the process of switching all their computers over to Linux. IIRC as well, there’s a number of German municipalities that have been using mostly Linux in their offices for some time now. Right now it seems a lot of European countries are fed up with American Big Tech. But I’m not yet convinced that this opposition is purely out of principle or simply another manifestation of “Orange Man Bad!” (I find conflating Big Tech with Trump to be kind of funny)
Thank you for the link to Gutenberg’s Kindle version of the 1811 Grose dictionary of the vulgar.
As it turns out, Bill did NOT have it.
Downloading will soon commence!
I left the hospital when a clip board toting nurse had me sign my own write up, for not educating a patient on CHF. He was educated, about a dozen times, for every stay in hospital, and I remembered doing his latest (it’s training not education, the cretins just talk that way), and I documented it in three places electronically. But I missed the check in the box she was monitoring. Sign here please.
AGE GROUP 45-60
GETTING IN BETTER PHYSICAL SHAPE
JMG 217
> those who’ve never done hard physical work in their lives are poorly prepared to do it in middle Age.
Bumm-mmer.
The age group (45-60) having the bottom fall out from under them bothers me no end.
Those 60 now were born about 1966. Those 45 now were born about 1981.
So, roughly late 1960s to mid-1980s. These are Baby Boomers’ (BB) children, not BB’s themselves. It appears that this is the most vulnerable population for when things go awry.
(Man, are Jethro and I glad we never had kids. We felt in our gut that we would be setting up children for failure.)
So, those born during the late 1960s through, say, 1985 (both men and women), if nothing else, would be good to get in physically hardy shape.
There are several ways to accomplish that, both at home and/or join a gym.
If this age group doesn’t plan ahead, as you, JMG, are saying, chances are slim-to-none they will be able to take up a “physically-demanding ‘second’ career.” In other words, they can kiss their a_ses goodbye.
Become physically robust, that is, if one physically is able.
People of this age group CAN prepare for a downturn in (either) the economy and the job front. They CAN plan ahead, by generally becoming more physically fit.
I am not of that age group, but if I were, I would do my best to get in shape. When I do too much exercise, my muscles physically hurt. I would imagine if I were 45-60, exercising more than usual would also hurt, am I right? But push through the pain anyway, and eventually exercising is not painful?
Anyone here know?
I would like to know more what a 45-60 year old can expect regarding exercising + pain.
How would one go about getting in better shape, say, over the next five-years, starting this summer/winter season?
💨💪🏼🤷🏼♂️🏃🏼♂️🙆🏼♀️💨Northwind Grandma
Dane County, Wisconsin, USA
Curt @ 226, I have myself arrived at an age at which I truly don’t much care when or how I die. Offspring have been told I do not want my life prolonged by artificial means and I quite likely will refuse medical treatment altogether. I rather suspect that, as part of a rising trend of church going, we will see increasing numbers of women choosing consecrated life. The advantages are not insignificant. In return for voluntary poverty and the eschewing of sex and childbearing, the woman has decent housing; clothing and meals provided, and she enjoys the respect of her larger community, as well as the satisfactions which come from doing useful work.
Happy Solstice to all who celebrate it (summer or winter, depending on your hemisphere)… 🙂
And to everyone who made Providence, may the weekend be full of blessing and fun!
BorealBear 228
> Then again, maybe the school system is in a different position
Nah. Schools are the worst. Within the last six months, our local school system felt they didn’t have enough stupid clubs to whom they could send the bill to the Town to increase property taxes.
It was The Yoyo Club. The school administrators put their brains together in committee, and collectively stated that students didn’t have enough eye-hand coordination and timing skills which, they said, students needed to prepare for college. They assigned a budget. Said school district had to have $25 for each student for umpteen students to have their own yoyo.
Word got around that if a student joined the club, they got a free “premium” (“expensive”) yoyo. A couple hundred students showed up. 200 students x $25/yoyo = $5,000. Property taxes went up the next year, to pay for this stupid club but also additional stupid clubs.
This was an instance where the school district created a fake problem. They solved the fake problem by charging Town residents X-dollars to finance their fake problem.
This is how school systems have gotten, get, and continue getting, bad names. 99.99% of school districts have no intention of drawing down their budgets. In fact, most school systems exaggerate their “needs” by inventing stupid stuff of which have no business requiring a budget.
Those $25 yoyo’s probably ended up in the back of drawers in short order, and each Town resident was out, for argument’s sake, $25.
Since 1945, school systems have been had atradition of inventing stupid stuff which “they themselves solve,” and feel no hesitation of charging Townspeople whom were never consulted and for which did not give their permission.
School districts: Pare your budgets of stupid things to the bare bones, then next year again to the bare bones, and the year after that, again to the bare bones,— every year with less and less budget. Multitudes of taxpayers are sick of being chumps, that is, being forced to finance school districts’ asinine school clubs (and the like).
‼️For all I care, get rid of football club and soccer club‼️
💨🪀🏈⚽️💨Northwind Grandma
Dane County, Wisconsin, USA
Hello JMG. Do you think the Trump administration’s loss in the war with Iran will hasten the end of US hegemony you mention in this post, and thus put even more pressure on bureaucratic jobs?
At this page is the full list of all of the non-faith-specific requests for prayer that have recently appeared at ecosophia.net and ecosophia.dreamwidth.org, as well as in the comments of the prayer list posts (printable version here, current to 6/21). Please feel free to add any or all of the requests to your own prayers.
If I missed anybody, or if you would like to add a prayer request for yourself or anyone who has given you consent (or for whom a relevant person holds power of consent) to the list, please feel free to leave a comment below.
* * *
This week I would like to bring special attention to the following prayer requests, selected from the fuller list.
May Alex R. be blessed in his efforts to resolve his financial situation, and successfully get completely out of debt within the current year 2026; may he find opportunities toward that end, and also the wisdom to recognize and seize them when they come.
May a safe and happy home environment be enjoyed by Laurelmirror, her daughter, and her mother, as well as protection from evil influences. May their family situation be resolved in such a way that Laurelmirror’s mother will get a chance to recover physically and mentally from the stresses it has caused.
May Kallianeira come to understand or face the entity or issue that seems to have trapped them, causing problems in her material circumstances, causing expensive troubles that threaten to force them out of home and mind, and leaving her burnt out and overwhelmed despite every attempt to find real help. May she quickly find out what to do and how to act to overcome these hardships.
May Geoff G’s sister Lindsay, who suffered a stroke at the end of May, recover to the fullest extent possible, and be blessed and supported in her mental wellbeing throughout.
May Mathew Damon Gallowglass, who has been diagnosed with ulcerative colitis, be treated successfully for his condition and make a full recovery.
May Lisa C be blessed and healed for a complete recovery from breast cancer.
May 6 year old Max be blessed and protected during his parents’ contentious divorce; may events work out in a manner most conducive to Max’s healthy development over the long term.
May Bob W of Lake County, Ohio’s treatment for cancer go well so that he may heal and recover as quickly as possible.
May 1Wanderers’s partner Cathy, whose cancer has returned, be given the physical and mental strength to fight it, and tolerate the treatment, and may she enjoy a full and permanent recovery.
May Jule from Iserlohn, Germany, who is experiencing complications in her pregnancy due to an influenza infection, recover and have a pleasant pregnancy and birth.
May Larry Mulford, who has entered hospice after a year battling with pancreatic cancer, pass in the smoothest possible manner, and may his wife be enveloped in our love.
May Pierre’s young daughter, Athena, be healed from her fatigue and its root causes in ways that are easy, natural, and as holistic as possible.
May Lydia G. of Geauga County, Ohio heal and recover from prolonged health issues.
May Mary’s sister have her auto-immune conditions sent into remission, may her eyes remain healthy, and may she heal in body, mind, and spirit.
May Trubujah’s best friend Pat’s teenage daughter Devin, who has a mysterious condition which doctors are so far baffled by necessitating that she remain in a wheelchair, be healed of her condition; may the underlying cause come to light so that treatment may begin.
May Kevin’s sister Cynthia be cured of the hallucinations and delusions that have afflicted her, and freed from emotional distress. May she be safely healed of the physical condition that has provoked her emotions; and may she be healed of the spiritual condition that brings her to be so unsettled by it. May she come to feel calm and secure in her physical body, regardless of its level of health.
May Frank R. Hartman, who lost his house in the Altadena fire, and all who have been affected by the larger conflagration be blessed and healed.
* * *
Guidelines for how long prayer requests stay on the list, how to word requests, how to be added to the weekly email list, how to improve the chances of your prayer being answered, and several other common questions and issues, are to be found at the Ecosophia Prayer List FAQ.
If there are any among you who might wish to join me in a bit of astrological timing, I pray each week for the health of all those with health problems on the list on the astrological hour of the Sun on Sundays, bearing in mind the Sun’s rulerships of heart, brain, and vital energies. If this appeals to you, I invite you to join me.
“If you are unsure if your hourly job with benefits is wage or salary, in the USA, the answer is simple: do you have today (Juneteenth) off? Labor Day? Memorial Day? Veteran’s Day? Salary class gets holidays, wage class does not.”
That’s not cut and dried either. My salary class job and my daughter’s wage class job have the same schedule.
Holidays are, New Years, Memorial Day, July 4th, Labor Day, Thanksgiving, day after Thanksgiving, Christmas Eve, and Christmas. No MLK day or Juneteenth, no Columbus Day, no President’s day, no Veteran’s day.
Government employees get the extra holidays, not all industrial salary class get them.
It’s not at all a clean split. Limiting the classes to four broad groups might be the best way to do it because the next step up in resolution is a lot more than eight groups.
“The agreement with Iran isn’t about peace. It’s purely an arrangement to allow the US to duck out of the Persian Gulf and pretend not to have lost.”
It’s hard to imagine the agreement continuing to BE an agreement for long, whatever the pretext or the subtext or whatever you think you are doing, IF your faux-negotiating team is made up of Kushner and Witkoff….
The reputation these two have, internationally, is that (as they say in Ireland) you cannot shake hands with them without counting all your fingers after…
Which is to say, these two are not the lads you send if you are trying to make a deal you intend to KEEP.
Thank you for the clarification. I see that the problem isn’t necessarily that the salary and wage classes have conflicting interests or that they are motivated by any kind of malicious intent. Rather, the issue is that the salary class is better positioned to have its needs met, often at the expense of the wage class. Yet when confronted with this reality, a significant portion responds with contempt and doubles down on its behavior instead of acknowledging that there may be a problem at all. As a salary-class worker in higher education, I also found myself falling into that trap in 2016.
This is topical, anyone have yesterday’s WSJ available for a quick summary?
Why Some $100,000 Earners Still Call Themselves Working Class
WSJ’s Janet Adamy explains the surprising findings of what it means to be working class in the U.S., based on exclusive poll findings conducted on behalf of the Journal
By
Janet Adamy
Bofur, cheers!
JMG, I’m sure that explains many cases, but I’m not sure that explains mine unless I’m blind to it. It’s not the job itself that makes me think/act this way. Although it has degraded over the years. But, all my peers whose political leanings I know are leftist. I’ve met two conservatives on the job so far and they were both a level up. I think I have a subconscious troll in me, and Trump is the ultimate troll. Although my serious side does like him more than other politicians. And Trump did get his start when I was still a basement dweller so that makes me a feel a bit akin to those FourrChan memesters, although I’ve only been on FourChan a couple times.
Hi John Michael,
Happy summer solstice. It’s a pea souper down here and has rained for almost three days non stop. A lot of people talk about the coming super El Nino with confidence, but down here it is just one of about four major climate drivers affecting this corner of the planet including: Indian Ocean Dipole; Southern Annular Mode; and the Madden-Julian Oscillation. And that lot have a far stronger influence on summer rainfall than El Nino does, which tends to impact upon Winter and Spring conditions, except right now, it is super wet outside.
That’s the problem with predictions, a person can be wrong! I predicted that we’d face petrol rationing after Easter due to the war, and that didn’t happen. Demand was reduced instead by simply raising prices for energy, and people cut back. That is what being wrong looks like! 🙂 I should have known that down here we tend to rely upon the tried and true strategy of ‘rationing by price’, and will incorporate that lesson more deeply into my world-view. The world is a far stranger place than it appears at first glance. Fortunately thanks to your good guidance, I never hyped up an impending apocalypse!
Speaking of which, I’m getting the impression that your readers see the art of diplomacy as a: ‘winner takes it all’ game, when just like discussing the climate, in reality, it’s a lot more messy. It interests me that that theme is being repeated over and over again here (and elsewhere for that matter), and certainly it doesn’t mean nothing. It’d be a tough subject to write about!
The apprenticeship model is tried and tested, and can be done for lower cost than the service that universities provide. And in fact, I’d have to suggest that students would be subjected to far greater over sight under the cheaper model. It’d be hard to cheat, when the student works under the watchful gaze of the master. This online learning business stuff, probably leaves too many opportunities open for the lazy student.
Cheers
Chris
I would like to add a perspective to this, as I have lived in both the salaried class and now occupy the upper end of the wage class. My job is right in the heart of the titanic changes, building the power systems for the data centers that are summoning the AI avatar of the god Progress I don’t believe in. I once did, and my time as a true believer was filled with impotent rage, a desperate search for a scapegoat for why we weren’t getting the promised tomorrowland. Life in the wage class is a lot simpler, though more grueling. Overall, I actually find I’m using my mind and hands a lot more productively and am far more stimulated than I ever was in an office.
I just graduated from an electrical apprenticeship, and had the chance to talk to a lot of graduates, of all ages, genders, and races. Almost no one believes in AI or progress – what they believe in is the sweet data center money. In many ways these data centers are an effort by the investment class to keep the working class employed while screwing over the salaried class – a nice reversal of the previous, opposite trend. Someone has been paying attention at the top. Yet the bureaucracy in many of the companies still don’t get it. For instance, my company, which will remain nameless, has recently decided to do away with the electrical apprenticeship program, trying instead to turn the process into an assemblyline, hiring dumb assemblers who will carry out the prefect plans of the genius engineers. The fact that the plans are often wrong, that the electricians are the ones cobbling solutions together based on knowledge passed from journeyman to apprentice, has never occurred to them. Because they don’t talk to us – they consider communication to be one way, they issue the orders, the dumb workers obey. Now senior electricians are leaving in droves for the guild – er, sorry union. They seem to think this is an excellent opportunity to cut labor costs. I think their plan is about to blow up in their face – literally, in the case of high voltage electrical work being done by people who have no idea what they’re looking at and are told to just unthinkingly follow the plans.
Funny enough, I had a chance to talk to a DC area programmer friend of mine about AI. He literally invoked progress – that people just have to adapt, get retrained for jobs, that that’s just how progress is. The blind faith blindsided me – here he is, advocating for something gutting his own class and endangering his comfortable lifestyle. He also went on about how we had to get to space to survive as a species. Decline and return to a previous time is literally unthinkable to him. Thankfully, I took your advice and decided to stay silent and not out myself as a modern day nonbeliever in the god of our times – no point in making our visit unpleasant, I doubt I would convince him of anything. I think you’re quite right that AI is simply a trojan horse to get the salary class to accept being put on the chopping block in the name of their god.
I wonder what will happen once countless salary class members have lost everything, and then lost their faith in progress. The wage class has already lost it. When AI proves to be a shadow of what we’ve been promised, that might be the true end of the faith of progress as the mainstream religion of our society. This could lead to a true religious upheaval. I foresee the catholic church picking up a lot of members, but a good polytheistic religious group or idea could scoop a lot of salary class members as well.
Still, for my part, I’m going to leave the company being run by salary class delusions behind, join the modern day wage class guild, and get paid quite well to build these absurdly oversized temples to progress, knowing full well they won’t summon the dead god. Perhaps one day I or my children, who I’ll encourage to eschew college and join the guild to get good working skills, will be paid well to scavenge them. I should probably keep a hard copy of the building plans stashed away somewhere, for me or my children.
Some guy who hiked the entire length of the Ural mountains, mentioned trying to avoid three kinds of animals: men, bears, and mosquitoes.
Cynthia Christie (no. 218) “…because I’ll get the [stuffing] kicked out of me if I try to use a men’s room.”
Really?! In my experience, most men won’t care if women (or female-presenting people) enter the men’s toilet. Or are they just violently anti-trans where you live?
Hi JMG,
I was thinking about the frankly surreal behavior from tech executives regarding LLMs; typically when a company makes a new product or service they go out of their way to highlight its benefits and hide or obfuscate any drawbacks. But with LLMs they’re inventing nonsensical science fiction drawbacks on top of the very real drawbacks those systems have, while downplaying the positives. “LLMs will make everyone obsolete, they’ll become gods, they’ll rule the world if we let them”. If anyone has ever actually used these systems to try and solve a problem let alone if someone has played with the technology under the hood, it’s very clear these scenarios touted by industry are pure fantasy. I find it fascinating because in the attempt to make reality fit a science fiction plot, these firms are actively marketing their products poorly and are encouraging consumer backlash. It’s a real sign of the times I think. People, particularly technical people, have a deep need to believe in science fiction fantasy narratives. Does this assessment make sense or am I misreading this behavior?
Best,
JZ
Philip, an excellent point. At this stage it’s the populist right that’s the youthful insurgent movement full of new ideas and the establishment left that’s the stodgy old guard snobbishly insisting that what worked in their youth is still the best option. I don’t think you can get the latter to give up their faith in progress, though — they’ll just redefine it to mean more of the same forever.
Gnat, it may not be a four quadrant system. The 1826 economy I outlined in my post had more than four classes, and the future system may have more or fewer, too.
Jfisher, yep. Many of the old rules will not apply.
Robert, how fun! Thank you for this!
Kfish, I know intellectually that people waste that kind of money all the time, but it baffles me.
Tankermottind, they may try, but the situation isn’t there — there’s already a bureaucratic system in place, and the wage class won’t rally to their banners. Now of course there may still be plenty of pointless bloodshed, but that’s another matter.
Jessica, each class is convulsed with internal rivalries, and full of factions trying to improve their status relative to their rivals. Nor, of course, do I agree that the salary class has been as powerless as it likes to claim; blaming everything on the investment class has been a valued strategy of the salary class for more than a century.
BorealBear, oh, people will still try to pretend that all is well, or that all would be well if only those villainous so-and-sos from the investment class weren’t up to unspeakable evil. It’s so much easier to do that than to admit that the gravy train was self-terminating.
Teresa, enjoy!
Celadon, a classic example.
Northwind, it’s going to be a rough row to hoe. I don’t think there’s a one-size-fits-all recipe, just a lot of different adjustments.
Yonder, nah, it’s just one more step in the systematic retreat from empire that Trump was basically hired to carry out.
Ecoprayer, thanks for this as always.
Scotlyn, oh, nobody intends to keep it. It’s purely a fig leaf to allow the US to finish withdrawing from the Middle East. On the other hand, it would be a clever move to leave Iran empowered in the middle of the region, to stymie all efforts to unite the region under a single power.
Aaron, exactly.
Luke, so noted! A general formula like the one I’ve offered certainly won’t predict the behavior of individuals.
Chris, stay out of the apocalypse business and you’ll do well. It’s particularly important to do so when the people pushing those claims are frantically praying for something really dreadful to happen so the Orange One will be blamed for it.
Paedrig, thanks for the perspective.
John, that’s an extremely good point and one I’m going to want to brood over.
Ambrose: No, I would not say that they are violently anti-trans here in Vancouver (BC, Canada), but then again that depends on who “they” are. It isn’t about my locale though. I pulled off straight-acting for many years before my defective brain glitched enough that I transitioned. I pulled it off well enough that very few people ever suspected, and I’ve heard the things that straight men say to each other when they think no one of any other description is around. A lot of that is posturing of course, but still I would not like to take that chance. I mean, if I somehow against my will found myself in a situation where I had to use a public washroom that wasn’t a single-user room, I would take my chances on the men’s. I wouldn’t like it one bit. It would scare the [shoot] out of me.
Actually I didn’t much like using the ladies’ during the period when I did that, either. I always wanted to get the heck out of there as quickly as I could.
Also, I don’t think “women” and “femme-presenting people” are equivalent in this context. I think that there’s plenty of men who would be fine with a woman being in there, but not gender non-conforming XY people.
Curiously, anti-trans sentiment is more noticable here in “woke” Vancouver than it is in “redneck” Calgary, Alberta, where I’m from.
Scotlyn: Of course I accept your blessings! How kind of you! Please accept my own and my thanks for your kindness. Also…
Yes, heh, I know about problem vs. predictament. I learned that framing from JMG years ago and I read another blogger who’s adopted it. Very useful distinction! What I have here, Scotlyn, is not a predictament but a problem, since it has a very obvious solution: detransition. I don’t apply that solution for reasons which need not be kept private but that I don’t want to bore anyone with either. What it boils down to is that I feel worse about detransition than I do about the problems it would solve.
And, a Happy Solstice to you as well!
JMG: Happy Solstice!
And also to anyone else for whom that is meaningful. Happy Solstice!
I worked at not one, but two companies as a software engineer in New Zealand that came to realize that they had more ongoing software projects than they knew what to do with before I was shown the door. I’ve seen attempts to turn things around: https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/politics/388814/auditors-probe-nzta-s-hi-tech-business-unit
I want to invent a term for when someone’s moral commitments outstrips their ability to deliver, and they want to begin the slow painful process of making things right. I was thinking “declaring moral bankruptcy” might suffice. As in, “We promised every college graduate a white collar job, but there just aren’t enough, so we’re declaring moral bankruptcy, and starting a new jobs program based on aptitude and availability” or something to that effect.
For a chuckle and a good illustration of salary class shenagigans apropos of this essay, here’s a 2 minute video:
https://youtu.be/0JlEzL3Trrc
PS For those who don’t do video, the visuals are nothing special, you can just listen.
So there’s this huge gap between people who don’t think AI can replace a large chunk of the salary class and the people who are hyping up this technology so much that they’re calling for UBI in anticipation of the layoffs, and I feel the need to explain the difference between how people like me (Data Scientists, AI Engineers) are using AI versus how the average person uses AI.
Maybe you use AI to try to answer some question, and chances are it gets it wrong and leaves you frustrated, or maybe it answers many of your questions correctly and leaves you wanting in other areas. Maybe you use it to write difficult e-mails where you have to be careful (I love using them to communicate with insurance companies, got State Farm to cover my roof damage). Maybe you Google something and read the AI output at the top and laugh out loud at how incorrect is.
That’s most people’s experience with AI. Now, what AI engineers are doing is something completely different, and it involves an unbelievable amount of electricity and brute force.
Here’s one example. Every day, I will feed you customer feedback on our software product. I want you to take that feedback, determine what feedback is reasonable, scan our entire codebase, plan out what it would take to incorporate that reasonable feedback, document it, rewrite the code in an isolated environment, write tests to make sure the code works, run those tests against the code to make sure it works, if it doesn’t work, rewrite the code and run the tests over and over and over again until everything works, then go back and reread the customer feedback to make sure you addressed all reasonable requests and if you haven’t go back to planning out what you need to do to incorporate the feedback.
So, you have these AI programs running in loops doing that, consuming giant amounts of electricity and eventually stumbling onto to producing working software through sheer brute force of retrying over and over and over again.
That explains the huge amount of electricity usage, the enthusiasm around AI from the investment class who want to use it to replace salary class jobs, and why these admittedly tools can achieve remarkable outcomes (through endless automated repetition until they stumble on a working solution).
Re Mithridates #212
I think it’s a great idea to help people move to Linux, and I’ve been doing that for longer than I hoped would be necessary. There are, however, a few things I learned that you should know.
First: most people want Linux to be exactly like windows, only with the bad bits removed. As you probably know, Linux can be made to look like Windows, but it is its own system and will never work the same. Be prepared for complaints about stuff that works perfectly fine, just a bit different than they’re used to.
(I think if you take away the bad bits there will be nothing left, as the whole lot is built on the premise of exploiting people, not helping them)
Second: many people are utterly helpless when it comes to computers. Even very smart and capable people get reduced to simpletons when you place them behind one. Be prepared for lots of hand holding and explaining, because they are not used to figuring things out for themselves.
Yes, that’s a feature of Billy G’s concoction, not a bug.
Third: people are not used to paying for their operating system. They just buy a new computer when the old one becomes too slow (again, a feature and not a bug), and the new one comes with something preinstalled.
Adding the fact that Linux costs nothing (often that’s the only thing people know about it) means you will get complaints about asking money for it. So, be very clear about providing a service and not a product, but still: be prepared for negativity.
I hope this helps and good luck!
–bk
“Scotlyn, oh, nobody intends to keep it.”
The two family businessmen who I have worked for during my employed years happened to live by a very old-fashioned ethic. They bargained hard and advocated for their own interests when making business deals, but once a deal was agreed and hands were shaken, they absolutely believed in KEEPING those deals and fulfilling any obligations to which they had signed up.
I saw one of my former bosses pay a significant personal price for this ethic when two large customers defaulted on what they owed him, and his house was nearly sold under him, but he never considered defaulting in turn. What he did was to visit all of his suppliers and undertake to make sure they would all be paid, even if it took a bit longer than credit terms. It took him the best part of a year, but he did it.
This is the difference between local, family based businesses, and “absentee” business owners (ie shareholders). A local reputation for welching on deals quickly turns your capacity to enter into new deals rather sour.
Blessed Midsummer (in this hemisphere) to those who celebrate it, and a happy midsummer to all.
Irvine, hmm. Something snappier might be helpful, but you’re right that the concept needs a clear framing term.
Noodler, I don’t do video, but thanks for this.
Dennis, thanks for this.
Scotlyn, foreign policy is not a business. It’s a Darwinian cage match. No nation keeps its promises one moment after that stops being to its advantage.
Patricia M, thanks for this!
Northwind Grandma @234
> But push through the pain anyway, and eventually exercising is not painful?
I’m 64, so can answer some of that – of course, the usual disclaimers, this is not medical advice, I am not a doctor, and so on. But I have had some of the issues you talk of. First, there’s a difference between pain, and soreness:
https://www.texashealth.org/Health-and-Wellness/Sports-Medicine/Is-it-Ever-OK-to-Push-Through-the-Pain-During-Exercise
It can be tricky to tell them apart. But if it’s actual pain (and of course, chest-pain is a big red flag) – I’d definitely *not* just “push through it”, that could definitely cause long-term problems. There’s plenty of advice on the web about exercise-for-seniors – mostly about going slow and carefully. One thing I’ve done, for instance, is just not do things that hurt – like pushups – but instead, start with wall-pushups, and build up slowly, over time. Yeah, I definitely had some ego-pushback on that one. 🙂 But hey, that’s life. Another thing I found a while back, that I really like, is bear-crawls – again, it feels silly – but dang, it made a great warmup, and other things started to feel a lot better. So if you change things up, and exercise *awareness*, maybe you can find better routines.
First, happy solstice for you (with “some” delay).
——————————————————————————–
Clay D. # 199:
“all the Juneteenth celebrations, by the actual black community in Portland, will be taking place on Saturday and Sunday including the parade and rodeo ( yes a Juneteenth Rodeo).”
Oops, I’m afraid I’m going to look like an ignorant and arrogant European when I write my following comment, but I didn’t known Black People liked rodeos. That part of American culture was under my radar: I thought rodeo was a kind of show only for white people in the USA. It seems I was under usual trans-atlantic distorsion of American reality: Sorry…
—————————————————————————————–
Cynthia # 218:
“some men seem to think that their feelings about how they are viewed, or concerns about “misandry”, are more important than taking an honest look at the legitimate concern of women concerning their bodily safety.”
If I’ve understood well your reasoning, you wrote some men haven’t empathy enought to grasp the legitimate concern of women about their bodily safety. Well, it could be partly true, but on the other hand I’ve seen here some feminists have no empathy (neither), for their favorite bogey man, straight white men…So I tend to think misandry is a real and shared thing within mainstream feminism, at least for some zealots. Of course, this part of feminism (like the whole ideology) doesn’t represent every woman in my country, nor the world. Nor every men are misogynist guys, beyound usual far right and/or incel boys… Misandry and misogyny are opposite tendences, but they share their disbelief in the another sex/gender common humanity. I think it’s a wrong and unfair bias against the “opposite” sex…
———————————————————————————————–
Mythridates # 231:
” Notice how the wokification of everything in big institutions happened just a couple years after Occupy Wall St. died down. Suddenly, no one with a megaphone was talking about the 1% anymore, but rather about those aforementioned terms of misdirection.”
Yes, I’ve noticed it, I’ve grasped how wokification tendence began and accelerated more or less across the West, between 2011 (Occupy wall St.) and 2018 (Me Too-4th feminist wave), and then it became a “light” censorship totalitarism-like. We had a local protest here named “15-M”, but its social claims were watered and eventually swallowed by the “radical” political party “Podemos”, whose regrettable woke left populist “ideology” poisoned the whole Spanish Left until today. I see with mild Schadenfreude how this populist left party is slowly losing votes election after election here, but I also think it fullfilled its dirty “task”, maybe fueled by some factic powers.
—————————————————————————
Paedrig # 246:
“Because they don’t talk to us – they consider communication to be one way, they issue the orders, the dumb workers obey.”
Your description about usual “modus operandi” (attitudes and behavior) in your work place from “high spheres” to “dumb workers”, rhymes with some situations I’ve been told by some people here who worked in different hi tech (and no hi tech) companies. That “modus operandi” helps to dehumanize workers everywhere it’s implemented, methink. So you can bet consequences in the long term won’t be good.
——————————————————————–
BK # 254:
“many people are utterly helpless when it comes to computers. Even very smart and capable people get reduced to simpletons when you place them behind one.”
Err…I look at myself within your depiction of those many people. I’m slightly smartest than average people, (I know it thanks to some serious IQ tests I filled when I was younger, due to my mental problems, ahem); but I’m a mediocre computer user. I don’t mind to accept it. So I think you’re right, at least according my personal case and experience.
@JMG and everyone
A happy Solstice to all the Druids here and others who celebrate it from me as well!
@Northwind Grandma #237
Thanks for this. Seems like a great example of the Shirky Principle for sure. Thankfully that particular scheme wouldn’t work in this country, since school-funded and affiliated clubs aren’t a thing as far as I know. Of course there’s probably other ways to game the system for those in the know.
@Chris at Fernglade #245
“The apprenticeship model is tried and tested, and can be done for lower cost than the service that universities provide.”
Yes. Absolutely. I think it’s frankly idiotic how our society has locked so many professions behind three or even five year college degrees, when an apprenticeship model would be both cheaper and better. (Three years at university to work in a kindergarten? Really?) Of course it’s even worse in the US, where students also have to run up huge debts just to attend. Off the top of my head I don’t remember if Australia has free college for citizens or if it’s like the American model. Either way, the point is that you’re absolutely right.
JMG @ 256, I take your point about the populist right being the youthful insurgent movement. From where I am standing, I have the same complaint about this movement as I did about the self-styled New Left back in the day (late 60s-mid 70s) which is When are you guys going to builds something? The left never did, and compounded that folly by doing everything they could to undermine those who did build, from organic farming to environmentalism to appropriate technology, as you yourself have referred to. Lefties were moving into govt. sinecures at about the same time the dense structure of regulations so often and rightfully complained about on this forum was being erected. Coincidence? I doubt it. It is a neat trick, impose regs that justify your own salary whilst blaming the nefarious forces of capitalism.
I will say that the young populist right seems to have abandoned traditional rightist war mongering. I just wish that their program looked less like the old confederacy combined with Disney princess sentimentality combined with a shallow consumerism derived from advertising and TV sitcoms. The movement’s intellectual and ideological incoherence is best illustrated by the views expressed about so-called traditional marriage. I note with some amusement that soi-dissant traditional marriage does not appear to include a lifetime commitment. Mustn’t interfere with their rich guy donors’ penchant for trading for younger models. Of more consequence is the absolute failure of these young rightists even to address, much less come up with proposals to ameliorate, the fact that it does take two salaries to keep body and soul together these days. Price controls are anathema to and unions hated by these folks, so what is their solution? Restrict immigration? Well, about that, their president just signed off on an agreement which will doubtless result in a lot more ME migration, not to mention the Israeli dual citizens who will be arriving and expecting to be important.
@JMG
I agree that I’ve overidentified the salaried class with knowledge workers, though I think you may have overidentified it with government regulations. A fun version of the problem of defining the salaried class is Dave Graeber’s Bullshit Jobs. He says that as the CEOs of corporations have become wealthier, they’ve created a class of fawning servants that surrounded them and praise them, but don’t do any useful work.
In 1929, CEO cowered before the board because board controlled the shares of the corporation and directed it. It’s similar to how a board of a high-tech startup controls the CEO now. The change since then is that the stock market has widely distributed ownership of most corporations, and many board directors don’t control shares; the board’s role has become strategic oversight, and they work cooperatively with the CEO.
It seems to me that your target is government regulation, which is administered through a bureaucracy of salaried workers. My answer is that the regulations arose at the demand of the people, especially wage workers, who didn’t want bad air and water to kill them, and that the government is simply fulfilling their desires.
I’ve focused on knowledge workers because some of them have become leading capitalists. As a class, they present competition to the investment class.
@Slithy Toves #161
The economic downturn in the 1970 that led to the Rust Belt happened because Germany and Japan build modern factories for the industrial goods needed to repair their countries. When the repair was finished, they started selling these goods to other countries. Those countries had older, more expensive factories so the competition from Germany and Japan forced them into bankruptcy. This didn’t just happen in the US, but in Britain, France, Italy and even in the Ruhr Valley of Germany. Japan eventually became the leader, pumping out cars like no one’s business. Even Germany had to retreat into selling high-quality cars rather than mass-market ones.
What I’ve read of the working class is that they loved Eisenhower, but went back to the Democrats in the 1960s, but the political disturbances of the time sent them back to Nixon, and they’ve never left since them.
As you can see, I tend to economic explanations rather than ideological ones, because I find the latter too slippery. I can track dollars but I can’t track ideas, because they tend to transform quickly and to take on protective cover.
@Scotlyn #185
I’m glad you enjoyed our last exchange.
What I wrote comes out of standard class conflict ideas. The US working class doesn’t see itself as oppressed by the elites. For example, JMG argues in this post that it’s oppressed by the salaried class, not the investment class. I can’t think of a better illustration of how the working class doesn’t see itself as oppressed by capitalists.
I’m not saying that the working class should think that way. It’s free to think whatever it wants. I’m saying that’s it’s different from the European working classes, and so the US behaves differently socially. For example, Marxism depends on a working class that feels exploited; if the US working class doesn’t feel exploited, then Marxist revolution will never come here. I’ve also wondered why the US working class doesn’t, because it definitely felt exploited in the 1920s when there were widespread, violent battles over forming labor unions. I have a lot more questions than answers.
Re: the collection of 18th century vulgar terms referenced by Robert Mathiesen. Did anyone else know some of that already? I’m almost sure I’ve heard “scurvy wench” before. Not recently, but I have, and I haven’t usually read things written before the mid 20th century.
Re: the salary class getting all Bolshevik up in this [batch]. One of the things I learned this year after starting to look at trans with a critical eye is that estrogen has been found to increase aggression in males, and my own experience supports that. I wondered if some of the woke pushers always knew that and we were meant to be some sort of rainbow stormtroopers. If you only count those of us with real gender dysphoria, there’s not nearly enough of us, but if you incentivize other types of fringe males to go that way, like by saying that any clerkoff [j, not cl] who says he’s a woman can go into the women’s change room, then maybe the numbers make more sense. I’m not sure. (BTW, I am no longer on estrogen. My appearance has suffered for that, but so be it.)
There are in fact references to an incel to [transmission] pipeline when I do a Google search for that.
If the pointless bloodshed that JMG referenced comes to pass, my money is on the wage class, not the rainbow stormtroopers, the latter of whom I will of course not be helping. I will help the former if they’ll have me.
(“My money is on…”: Not a huge bet. At this time, that money consists of my ramen and peanut butter budget for the next two days, and three American quarters that the washing machine wouldn’t take. Wait, I can get a small yogurt at the community center for the three quarters, so I’m not wagering that even though the bet is a very sure thing.)
(Hey, I have a $2.25 meal ticket for that same community center. Heh! Move over, Bezos! Kneel, peasants!)
“Scotlyn, foreign policy is not a business. It’s a Darwinian cage match. No nation keeps its promises one moment after that stops being to its advantage.”
This is very evidently true.
But, while true, it is not all that easy to understand why this should be so. Does the “raspberry jam” principle apply differently to nations? And also, are nations the same as states?
What I see is that people (who think of themselves as being integral parts of a nation) end up becoming the “human shields” who take the flak for any actions taken by the states which govern said nation when those actions are inimical to the people of other nations, governed by other states.
There are even cases of states being in cahoots with one another to take actions that are inimical both to their respective nations and to their respective people-under-governance (to wit the various adverse public health policies carried out in lockstep during the Covid debacle).
While it is evident that there are costs to pay when individuals make promises that we do not keep (even when it stops being to our advantage), do nations not also pay such costs? Do states not also pay such costs?
These may be rhetorical questions. If they seem so to you, please don’t stretch for an answer. 🙂 Nevertheless, I do wonder about the dynamics of all of these relationships, which continue to be human relationships, even when at scale.
“I would like to know more what a 45-60 year old can expect regarding exercising + pain.”
A different focus may be more efficacious, but I don’t think there is a ‘one size fits all’ thing here – everything depends on start point at a particular age, but I would use another metric to measure rather than focussing on pain.
For myself, once I reached thirty, for ease of application I decided that at the start of each new decade I would aim for a level to see me through the coming decade. Active work helps, but define aims and get away from the simplistic measure of muscle bulk, other factors are more useful.
What we have seen is that the gym bunny fitness training turns out sculpted bodies that have very limited endurance or resilience – sure they might look pretty (or not as the case may be), but more use is the skinny guy who can work all day not a gym bunny that is good for limited activity and after two hours they’re ready to go home.
Pain might not be gain but simply a limitation in imagination and thinking – the importance of days off for the body to ‘acclimatise’ seem as much as value as the days when exercise is done to increase capacity.
At nigh on 66 years here, strengthening the foundations of the inner temple have taken on extra importance than just adding a lick of paint to the physical exterior. Put another way, for anyone over 50 the body is more in a holding pattern than a youthful expansion – yes gains may be made, but if you’ve missed the window of developing physically in youth, aims are going to be more constrained – and I am not sure that equating pain with gain is particularly helpful – basically ‘no pain no gain’ is a slogan that floats like a turd.
To clarify – what I mean is that ‘no pain no gain’ acts like a thought-stopper; like a reflection of a partial truth in a hall of mirrors that has then been adopted as a universal truism.
Pain is a signal and it is a signal of many potential things – but of course, if ‘no pain no gain’ is reduced to a euphemism of ‘don’t be lazy’, well I guess that’s fair enough.
Granted this is only a personal view, but finding the flow where one does not feel exhausted but energised can be done in martial practice… which is different to the exhaustion of a day’s hard physical labour – long ago, when asked at a class if my arms shaking was an indication of chi flow, I had to inform them: ‘No, I moved 10 tonnes of concrete blocks today and now I can barely move my arms.’
@BK #254 (& Mithridates #212)
“many people are utterly helpless when it comes to computers. Even very smart and capable people get reduced to simpletons when you place them behind one.”
This is actually supported by a global OECD study that was conducted in 2016: approximately 70% of people are varying degrees of computer illiterate (from not being able to use a computer at all to only being able to perform very simple step-by-step tasks.) Of the remaining 30%, only 5% could perform complex tasks, with the remaining 25% being somewhere in-between.
https://www.nngroup.com/articles/computer-skill-levels/
This was more or less consistent across all first world countries (Americas, East Asia, Europe, etc). Tech geeks and Linux geeks in particular tend to get blindsided by this because they spend a lot of time in communities composed of that 5%, but it’s important to keep the skills gap in mind when introducing these things to laypeople.
Tangentially related, this is also part of why many laypeople are so enamored with LLMs despite all of their flaws: if you lack the computer skills to do what you want in the first place, being able to ask a virtual assistant in natural language to do it for you, even if you have to go back and forth with it for hours or days to get what you want, and even if the end product is subpar compared to what a skilled human would create, it will still feel revolutionary.
Chuaquin: I think we are not very far apart here. Without walking back anything I said already, I’ll say this: misandry and misogyny are both real things, and neither should be. Also, usually men and women have empathy for the condition of the other. I will say however that as someone who’s been a part of both unguarded guy talk and unguarded girl talk, it’s more common for men to lack empathy towards women than it is for women to lack empathy towards men. I can’t prove that; I am aware of no research that shows it; but that’s my experience so that’s what I think.
Men who do have empathy towards women may tend to feel that “Man vs Bear” is an unfair attack on them. To them I say, men should police each other better (and teach their sons better) regarding behaviour towards women, so women don’t have a reason to say stuff like that.
It’ll never be perfect. We are the animals that we are, and like all other species, natural selection has conditioned us for reproductive success, not harmony with each other. It could be worse. For example, it really sucks to be a male elephant seal if you’re not the alpha. Actually it sucks to be a female elephant seal if you’re into a male other than the alpha. (The alpha rigidly enforces that he is the only male that reproduces.) Natural selection will continue to condition us according to that priority, and while we can try to use our intelligence to mitigate the disharmony that goes along with that, some form of it will always be with us. That is animal life. We must deal.
I think it would be a lot better if we just admit that romantic “love” is a nice fairy tale that we use to window dress the truth: the male tends to want to seed as many as possible, the female tends to want only the best seed, and all mating behaviour proceeds from that, via various forms of happy talk and obfuscation. But most are unwilling to look that truth in the face. We’d probably get along a lot better if we lived in the universe of “The Invention of Lying”. Before Ricky Gervais’ character came along, of course. (Is there a Spanish language dub of that? You should see that if you haven’t, it’s really funny! If you can take a little poke at religion, that is.)
Scotlyn: Foreign policy is a Darwinian cage match because there’s no possible enforcement mechanism that all nations are subordinate to, no?
Also.. An opportunity to learn something! I love those. Can you tell me what the raspberry jam principle is, please? I looked it up and all the references were to literal raspberry jam.
Speaking of the universe of “The Invention of Lying”, if I may have a minor indulgence here, I’d love to hear the love ballads from there. The same treacly slow-tempo music but the words are all about birthing hips and income levels and other indicators of reproductive suitability that would be considered utterly crass and cynical in our world.
When you don’t have to die
Because he can afford pizza pie
That’s Amore!
Scotlyn 236
Northern hemisphere
For the last ten years or so, I feel askance during the six months where light increases and dark decreases (here December to March). It feels like I am rubbing corduroy/velvet the wrong way, that is, backwards. It involves a faint irritation.
As of this morning, at least theoretically (less light; more dark), I feel my spirit rubbing corduroy/velvet the right way. From previous years, the smooth-corduroy feeling strengthens over the few weeks. Right now, I can hardly discern the feeling.
I suppose animals sense the solstices. I noticed the last six weeks a plethora of young ones of animals I spot: geese, crows and all sorts of songbirds. This early, I suppose that animals are wrapping up preparing for winter, even though they have three months to do it. Some animals, I understand, mother a second set of babies during the latter half of summer.
💨🌻🦆🪿🐦⬛💨Northwind Grandma
Dane County, Wisconsin, USA
On promises @JMG and @scotlyn #257: There are long-term interests for a state in being known as a reliable negotiator. In 1914, the German chancellor called a treaty on Belgium’s neutrality a scrap of paper, while German troops were preparing to invade Belgium. It didn’t end well for Germany.
Anybody who has ever played Diplomacy knows the temptation to break agreements when it is in one’s short-term interest to do so, but over the next rounds, having broken an agreement with X will make it harder to negotiate with Y.
@ Thomas River #264
Thank you for coming back to me on this.
“Marxism depends on a working class that feels exploited; if the US working class doesn’t feel exploited, then Marxist revolution will never come here. I’ve also wondered why the US working class doesn’t, because it definitely felt exploited in the 1920s when there were widespread, violent battles over forming labor unions.”
I wonder if you have encountered any European working class people lately? In my experience they are not really so different from American working class people when it comes to having excellent hearing. They can certainly hear the contempt in which middle class people hold both them and their concerns – especially concerns about the persistence of low wages and high rents. It registers.
OTOH I also wonder if by “feeling exploited” you mean something like “feeling powerless.” If so, it does not say much about Marxism that encouraging people to feel powerless is what it “depends on.”
The widespread battles over forming labour unions in the earlier part of the last century, as well as the battles over keeping them in the later part of the century did not seem to me to be due to feelings of being exploited as much as they were a matter of people feeling solidarity with others who shared their interests, and willingness to advocate for together for those interests, and becoming aware of the power that solidarity brought them in their advocacy.
Labour solidarity lead to battles, but also to negotiations and to agreements after said battles had adjusted and altered the relationships working people had with those who OWNED, but also with those who MANAGED, their workplaces. I’ll wager that if you study those battles you will find that managers (foremen?) would have lined up with the bosses for the most part, almost never with the workers. Also, and rather interestingly, it seems that it was when unions began to offer permanent, salaried, “management” positions that they stopped being as effective at advocating for the interests of their working class members.
@ Cynthia Christie #250
This is me, and I may be speaking from ignorance, but I’ll wager that detransitioning would not be a solution to a problem, but a response to a predicament…. it would not be, for example, a “replay” button that would restore a person to a prior condition. There are many potential responses, that is only one of many. But all of them will have to start from HERE, none of them can start from (or go back to) BACK THERE. Again, forgive if I speak too forthrightly for someone who is not in your position. In any case, whatever response seems good to you, may it go well for you and bring you blessing.
#270
Firstly “raspberry jam” is JMG’s term for the concept of karma and consequences, and the reason why ethics are an essential protection when doing magic. Just as one cannot spread raspberry jam on toast without some ending up on the fingers, says he, one cannot fully “intend” that a thing happen to others without that thing happening to oneself. In other words, if I want to be able to trust the promises other people make to me, I will increase my chances of that if I, too, strive to keep my own promises.
re cage matches and foreign policy, I do understand that relationships among nations? states? operate at a larger scale than relationships among individuals, but it is also true that, as individuals, we can do better in relationships wherein we perform that which we wish to see. Why would this not also be operative among nations? states?
Scotlyn #266
My point of view ,based in my probably mistaken understanding of philosophical materialism, is that
Individuals are product of his respective society, wich we call “nation” , and that is the result of eliminate the figure of the King in an enlightened state. The figures of the King ,the councelors and the nobles who give support to the regime have been replaced by a president, secretaries of state, and suporting billonaries.
Machiavello said that the chief of a state should act acording with his interests for to remain in power and for to steal territories to another states. Without any moral concern
Philosophical materialism says that a chief of state must be act for to asure the existence of his state, but not for the welfare or interest of all his so called citizens but for the interest of powerful groups who are really important for to asure him to remain in charge.
@Untitled #213
Since you found that entertaining, I’ll give you one more of the many experiences I’ve had. I don’t find these off-topic at all, at all; there’s a very direct line between these anecdotes and the OP’s bit about how some folk are going to find themselves positioned.
I said I’ve been modeling the future. A lot of what I’ve been doing is, I’ll go to an AI tool and I’ll say to it, okay, listen, here’s how I think the future is probably going to unfold, please help me stress-test my model, do you agree with it, do you see any holes in it or things I haven’t thought of. I’ve spent hours doing this.
So one time I opened a conversation by saying, I live in XYZ part of rural Canada and I think it’s one of the best possible places to be as we head into the future, what do you think about that?
Well. In very entertaining and polite fashion – you could tell it was trying to be gentle – it replied, “Uhhh, I have to say I don’t really think so man, no real good careers in that part of the country, it’s not really growing, dearth of great restaurants, etc. Maybe you can tell me what you were thinking.”
And so I had to explain to it at some length why I view not-being a PMC career hub as a positive.
On a final note, and then I won’t post about LLMs anymore: nobody should be using these AI tools as a substitute for the sort of human community we have here, but, these tools are good at what they’re good at, and one of those things is math.
If you’ve kinda sorta heard that our economic model is unsustainable, or that most people aren’t going to be able to afford to “retire”, but you’ve never really understood this because you’re daunted by math, it’s very easy to get AI to hand-walk you through the numbers.
One of the things I have appreciated from JMG over the years is his bald-faced statements about things like energy: “there isn’t anything to replace our current energy sources”.
There isn’t anything. That’s very sobering, when you hear it like that.
But it’s the same with “retirement”. It isn’t mathematically possible anymore for almost anyone.
I was looking at a Twitter thread pretty recently whose theme was “you know the best way to become a millionaire is STILL getting a good job in tech or finance and saving a lot.”
Actually, I agree with that. For now. As we’ve outlined in this thread, many of those jobs will be going away.
But the bigger point I’m trying to make is that almost everybody would benefit from learning about the Money Illusion as it relates to inflation:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Money_illusion
Tl;dr everyone thinks “a million bucks” is a lot of money but it isn’t anymore, and definitely won’t be by the time anyone under 50 wants to “retire”.
And if you don’t totally grasp why; if you kinda sorta instinctively feel that this might be true but you’re having a hard time organizing the math, it’s very easy to get your LLM of choice to model a quick calculation for you:
“What is today’s real inflation rate (not official CPI which is fake)?”
Most people are feeling something around 7-8%.
“At today’s rate of real inflation (7-8%) which isn’t going away, please tell me the purchasing power in today’s dollars of a million bucks in 2046.”
Spoiler: it’s about $230k.
“At this rate of inflation, please tell me the amount of passive income I would need in 2046 to replace 50k per year of today’s dollars.”
It’s $212k per year.
“What’s a realistic market return over years if we optimistically assume that the stock market remains functioning?”
7% is reasonable. Meaning that with inflation at or around the same number, everything a person invests into the market is basically treading water. There will be very few investment-class retirees coasting on passive income from their portfolio, at least not in anything like the style they expected.
And that’s why very few people under 50 will retire. It’s just math. I don’t know what the social model will be in 2046 but it’s going to be Something Else.
Someone above mentioned there are going to be a lot of suicides and deaths of despair. Yes. It’s very sad and sobering.
JMG mentioned the Diary of Samuel Pepys, which coincidentally I’ve been listening to on audiobook. Pepys famously wrote his nephew out of his will for “marrying wrong”, in a fashion that strikes us today as a bit harsh and villainous, but we need to remember that in those days marital alliances and family connections were life-and-death affairs. That’s coming back. We’re in the last decades, maybe even the last years, of anything like the current marital-romantic dynamic.
Chauquin 259
Oops, I misread “wokification” for “workification.” I asked, “Is ‘workification’ a word?”
It is now.
“Workification” is used on the Internet, but seems to have no set definition. That would mean, we can define it what we want.
I would say that workify is when one works with their hands, such as electrician, plumber, drywaller, seamstress, cook, and bookkeepier.
Oh, and here is another new word: bookkeepier, with an “I.” Bookkeepier means a hifalutin bookkeeper🎀.
Sunday evening silliness…
💨💡🪠🍳🧵🔢💨Northwind Grandma
Dane County, Wisconsin, USA
Silicon Valley is in a bubble right now because quote “the Valley has been captured by people that haven’t done any real work in years, haven’t built very much of anything, and thus will fall, well, for just about anything”
https://www.wheresyoured.at/premium-the-silicon-valley-bubble-part-2/
@ Northwind Grandma #234
A very good, basic exercise plan that virtually anyone can use because you are supposed to begin at the VERY BOTTOM OF THE CHART is the Royal Canadian Air Force plan.
It comes in two flavors: men which slants heavily toward strength building and women which slants heavily toward toning.
You can do either as long as you start AT THE VERY BOTTOM OF THE FIRST CHART.
PDFs are all over the internet.
Book versions (in a variety of formats) are easily available via abebooks.com and alibris.com. Or, you might get lucky at your local used bookshop.
Royal Canadian requires about 15 minutes a day, a copy of the instructions, some floor space, and your own sweet self. If you have knee, back, or joint issues, modify the instructions accordingly. I do NOT do the standard sit-up. My back won’t let me.
The program progresses with you, as much or as little as you want.
If you start young, you can work up to near-Olympic levels of fitness and still stick to 15 minutes a day.
Here’s a link to a PDF for women: https://csclub.uwaterloo.ca/~rfburger/xbx-plan.pdf
Here’s a link to a PDF for men: https://csclub.uwaterloo.ca/~rfburger/5bx-plan.pdf
Start at the VERY BOTTOM of the first chart even if it feels ridiculous to do three sit-ups and three leg-lifts and two touch-your-toes. The idea is that you gradually build up some muscle without injuring yourself.
Bill and I have done Royal Canadian for years. If you want to improve your fitness without a gym membership, a personal trainer, or other huge commitment of time and money, it’s a hard plan to beat.
Scotlyn:
Ok, first about not being able to go back. Very fair point! Disclaimers and softening not necessary. The point you made there is absolutely true and certainly not limited to the trans experience, so, yes, acknowledged, fair, true, bang on the money! I would not be hoping to return to some prior point. You’re right, that isn’t possible for me or anyone. If I detransitioned I wouldn’t be what I was six years ago immediately before transition, I would be a significantly older man with a history of trying to be a woman. But the problem that it *would* solve is that I wouldn’t have to worry about using a men’s room, and so I would have much greater freedom of movement than I presently do. Another problem it would solve is I wouldn’t get random dirty looks in the street anymore.
Something else that would cease is something that isn’t really a problem, but an amusement. There would be no more of those satisfied little smiles that mean, “you’re a sign that the right side is winning.” That amuses me because those smiles certainly would not be given if it was known what I actually think!
About raspberry jam, ok, thanks for that info. I know a lot of Greerisms but I didn’t know that one, because while I read all of Archdruid Report, I’ve read less than half of this blog, and only the comments on posts where I’ve been participating. Ok, so intent blows back. I do have to be a bit of a persnickity “actually person” and point out that unless you’re really clumsy or don’t have a knife, you absolutely can spread jam on toast without getting it on your fingers. The metaphorical point feels true though.
About international relations and how they work: The basic idea I have in my head is that the whole world of how nations deal with each other is just more dog eats dog, but I don’t think I’m the ideal person to make that point. I can say only that I see it that way and there it is. I’ll link you to the blog where I get my ideas about that topic from – it’s written by a guy who actually worked in diplomacy some decades ago and knows whereof he speaks. I can’t summarize him because I fail to understand some of what he says and my attention flags at other parts. I’m not up to understanding him fully, but I do read him and try to get partway there. I’ve linked to him before, and seen others here mention him. “Trying to Understand the World” by Aurelien: https://aurelien2022.substack.com/ So there that is if it interests you to read it.
The discussion about dismantling the salaried class brought to mind a cartoon from 1981, when Rompin’ Ronnie Reagan was taking over from Carter. He, of course, had campaigned on cutting back on ‘excessive’ government bureaucracy, like every Republican since, with much the same result. It had the two of them as cowboys, in reference to Reagan’s film career in westerns, and each cow had the name of a government entity as a brand, and Reagan asks Carter, “But how do you tell which ones are the *sacred* cows?” to which Carter replies, “You just gotta ask ’em, Ron!”
I think of that cartoon every time I hear of someone cutting anything.
Mary, I freely grant that the insurgent right is no more oriented toward building things than the fading left. I’m not sure that can be fixed, or that any movement to build things is even possible now, as the Long Descent picks up speed. More on this as we proceed.
Tom, no, my target isn’t government regulation; that’s a symptom of salary class privilege, not a cause in itself. It’s a point worth discussing, though. You’re half correct; government regulation was originally pushed as a way to have cleaner food — air and water came later — but it was the salary class, not the working class, that pushed it. (You can find this out quite readily with a little historical research, which I recommend.) The issue you may not be taking into account, though, is that where a historical process begins is not necessarily a meaningful description of where it ends up. Regulation long since stopped being a way to do anything but maximize the number of college graduates who had jobs as cubicle fauna waiting for them. As for salary class knowledge workers competing with the investment class, you’re decades behind the times — that came in with Roosevelt’s “Brain Trust.” By and large, they won that competition, too. Now the struggle is going the other way.
Cynthia, good heavens. Estrogen produces aggression in males? It’s long been known that testosterone produces aggression in females. That suggests some very odd things about gender relations…
Scotlyn, I don’t claim to know why it’s the case, but history shows that it’s always the case. As for “nations,” strictly speaking those are a fiction created in the 19th century, conflating languages, ethnicities, and states into a supposed unity. I used the term loosely, to mean “independent political units.”
Aldarion, no doubt, but I’ll be impressed if you can find me a single major power that kept its promises to rival powers one second longer than was advantageous to it.
Bofur, I freely grant that anyone outside the top 10% of income has no hope of retiring. I certainly don’t plan on ever doing so — and I didn’t need a stochastic parrot to clue me in. 😉
Anon, that makes a great deal of sense of the vacuous drivel coming out of Silicon (or as I’ve seen it spelled, Silly Con) Valley these days.
Renaissance, well, the last time the US government had as few employees working for it as it does after the latest round of cuts was 1966, so apparently the current set of cowboys are a little less cautious about deciding which cows would head for the slaughterhouse. Git along, li’l dogies!
I encountered a small anecdote regarding the aiification of the bureaucracy the other day. I’m living in China and was doing some routine visa paperwork at the time. A lot of government paperwork here is done via electronic kiosks, and on one of these was a very prominent “fill out with ai” button. I must say, that seems like a very good proposition – I recognize that human intelligence can be very valuable in a bureaucracy, but for everyday interactions? Give me the stochastic parrot! And thank the heavens that its training data is very clear that bureaucrats never, ever use their position to conduct class warfare against the productive classes…
On the subject of llms, I’ve noticed a strange inversion. It seems to reliably be the case that people who think every crystal, river, or book has a conscious spirit animating it believe ai is the sole exception to this pattern – despite sharing a lot of superficial qualities with crystals, rivers, and books! Meanwhile many people who think that consciousness is an irrelevant hallucination created by evolution for no obvious purpose seem similarly convinced that ai is the sole exception and will be producing a literal Deus ex machina any day now. The inversion of beliefs is so similar to the attitudes of alternative health practitioners to medical authorities during covid that I suspect they’re part of the same cultural moment, but I can’t even form a coherent theory as to what’s driving it…
To Oswegatchie #4: About homelessness. Part of the problem is the wide diversity of the homeless people. Some are working poor, some are drunks and addicts of other drugs, some are people who have made bad financial choices gotten into debt, some actually chose that lifestyle (though bleeding-heart liberals refuse to believe this fact. To them its always somebody else’s fault). The book “Glass Castle” by Jeannette Walls is a memoir of growing up with a very intelligent but chronically drunken father and an “artistic” mother who was away with the faeries. This couple, after their 4 kids left them, ended up on the streets in New York City and, despite many family interventions and offers of help, actively chose to live on that way for years. Homelessness is a people problem, not always failure of “The System”.
Chauquin-25 percent of the historical cowboys were Black. Rodeos are also a good part of some native American cultures. The first cowboys in the southwest were Indians taught to ride and herd by the missions. Against orders of course, but the mission priests in New Spain were a bit short-staffed.
Gerry
@ Northwind Grandma #234 re getting in shape
I am 56, a woman. I was active all my life, sports, cycling, yoga, DIY around the house etc.
In the last 3 years things have changed. I get injured and I don’t know why or even when it happened. I even broke my ankle without realising it and without being able to trace it to an event.
I went to a bio kineticist and her exercises has gotten me some way to recovery but not all the way.
Where I live (South Africa) competition for manual work is fierce and I am completely out competed by millions of people who are younger and stronger than I am and who will work for 1/10 of what I now earn in my salaried job.
I recently met a guy in his 40s who jumped from a senior corporate job to being a handyman, but he can obviously supplement his income with this savings from many years of being highly paid. I guess I’ll be one of the people not finding a chair and I don’t really mind that as long as it happens after my cat is gone.
Re Linux:
I have used Linux on my personal devices since 2005, mostly because I was unwilling to pay for Windows. At work however everything is so integrated these days that you can’t get away with doing that. Windows talks to many hidden endpoints just to determine who you are. More’s the pity.
Luddite
In relation to fitness, which Northwind, earthworm and Teresa, among others have all addressed, I will just say this.
In the clinic I notice a significant difference in overall health between people who take a walk every day, and people who don’t. This difference becomes more noticeable the older a person is. Like many of the other things that JMG recommends, which may seem deadly dull at the time, the real key is the doing of some of it every day, no matter what. And it seems that simply going out and walking (probably 20 minutes is a good minimum to aim for) is a very *complete* exercise when it is done every day. The difference that I see among my patients tells me that it really does clock up over time.
That said, ** waves at earthworm ** let’s hear it for skinny wiry guys (and gals, though I am not one of them) who can keep doing a heavy manual task all day and then get up and do the same thing again the next day. (I am simply lucky to be married to one of them). 🙂
Hi John Michael,
I’d notch this one up as a win for your readings:
Uranus in this house is in mixed dignity, as noted already. This can warn of a death in the royal house. It is also generally an indication of sudden changes in government. Well done! 🙂
Bizarrely, the UK the Makerfield by-election was described down here in the media as a ‘thumping win’ for the UK Labour party, but looking at the results, they only scored around 55% of the votes, in a very safe rusted on seat, which means that just half of the electorate decided that the winning party was ‘on the nose’ as they say.
The Labour party in power down here, whom also hold a significant majority, have made some extraordinary missteps of late, particularly in relation to tax reform. It’s been my observation that crass economics trumps ideology, every single time.
Crazy days huh?
Chris
Bofur 277
😢😒
OP ≟
Okay. I will attempt to be nice. Writers don‘t care if their writing is awful. I shouldn’t have to take time out to search elsewhere to get a definition; it makes reading feel like sh_t. I have to do this too many times. ¿When is it okay that a reader gets p_ssed because the cumulative effect of writers’ making readers work too hard? The adage is: “Don’t make readers work.” After it happens several times by different writers in succession, I get annoyed. It shouldn’t the reader’s problem. Argh~
On Wiki:
Operational planning
Original post
Sysop
Observaion post
Organophosphate
Op-ed
Operation
or none of these.
😢😒
💨Northwind Grandma😒💨
> “tempest in a lunar teapot”
…okay, I forgot that there had been another anonymous comment you had replied to, and had perhaps then decided to retroactively make an omnibus reply of. But that one wasn’t from me. (I don’t know how often you check the distinguishing metainformation on these things.)
On fitness:
“And it seems that simply going out and walking (probably 20 minutes is a good minimum to aim for) is a very *complete* exercise when it is done every day.”
Chuck in some breathing and active meditation with that and it really is the dog’s nuts. I inadvertently started doing it having to walk the three miles home from school in the rain or snow for some years… mainly did it to distract myself and only later found out it’s a thing.
I agree with you though, and reckon it is not the intensity but the regularity and range of activity… if we’re not moving the lymph is stagnating! One of my favourites of travelling without moving: pandiculation.
“I am simply lucky to be married to one of them”
Hey there Scotlyn – say hello to himself for me… 🙂
@ Teresa Peschel, #281
Tjhank you for the links, Teresa! I downloaded the PDF for men and printed it.
@bofur, you wrote “We’re in the last decades, maybe even the last years, of anything like the current marital-romantic dynamic.”
That is a very interesting observation and well worth pondering, but I think there are some wrinkles to that dynamic. First, it never ceases to surprise me how many people already, in our supposedly liberated times, marry within their own very narrowly defined social stratum. Somebody observed that doctors used to marry nurses and managers used to marry secretaries, but don’t do so anymore: doctors marry doctors and managers marry managers. Each one of them will obviously tell you they did so for romantic reasons, their spouse is their soulmate. But it is hard to believe that the deep desire to keep up with the Joneses, pay the mortgage in the right zip code, pay for international travel and the right clothes, restaurants and schools for their kids doesn’t mingle with romantic attraction when marrying.
In Brazil, there was a brutal saying “mixed-race women for fun, white women for marrying”. It’s not entirely different for some very progressive salaried people today, you just have to substitute class instead of race! And that is also not entirely different from Samuel Pepys’ time – it’s just that the attitude is internalized in the suitors’ minds, they don’t need to be called back into line by their wealthy uncle.
The other wrinkle is this: if you do want to consider economic aspects when choosing your marriage partner, what future are you planning for? Somebody might be a good choice if you plan to buy and pay down a nice house in a fashionable zip code (etc.) on your two good salaries. Somebody else might be the best support you can imagine if times are hard and you need to avoid starvation on incomes that inflation has whittled away: somebody who will make nutritious and tasty food from scraps, mend clothes and still laugh with your children all through it.
JMG, I heard tell of a family who took in an orphaned baby beaver. To their great surprise, the baby began building dams in its enclosure with the plush toys they had supplied for its’ play. It seems to me that homo sapiens also has a similar instinct to make and build, as witness the countless artifacts that can be seen in any museum. I await your thoughts with great interest.
To all who have addressed my musings about how it is that relations between “independent political units” (aka “nations”), albeit made of people, differ so profoundly from relations between “independent bodily units” (aka “people”), thank you.
There is much to think on, indeed.
There is one irony that I cannot help noticing and will just leave here.
Which is the uncanny way in which foreign policies apparently designed to prevent other independent political units from properly functioning resonate so harmoniously with domestic policies that favour massive inflows of displaced refugees.
JMG,
You are certainly right about regulations ( good or bad) creating salary class jobs. My wife owes her entire career to the Nixon’s Clean Water Act. It created federal ( EPA) and state bureaucracy’s ( DEQ’s) to carry out the regulations. Then an entire engineering discipline ( environmental engineers). Then public agencies in every town, city or county to treat the pollution to the level required by the regulations. Then a legion of private sector consulting firms that employee specialized engineers and scientists to help the agencies meet the regulations. Then legions of special lawyers to interpret the ever more complex regulations for agencies and to sue those who do not meet them.
I would argue that the clean water act was a beneficial regulation that probably helped more than it hurt but by its nature it gets more complicated to meets its standards every year. My wife’s agency held a permit that made her personally responsible ( an unusual aspect of a law made back when the feds meant business) for the status of an entire watershed which empties in to a small, slow river. A permit that was always one of the most difficult in the US is slated to become much more stringent ( PFAS and such) in 2 years and nearly impossible to meet in 5 years.
She would have discussions behind closed doors with elected officials ,that in reality, the watershed had probably reached its carrying capacity for humans and industry. Since most of these officials were elected with funding from the chambers of commerce and homebuilders they were horrified at such an idea. Their brains could not even wrap themselves around such an idea. Such ideas are not common in the wastewater industry nor in state and local government as we all know. She realized that the system that had provided her career would soon make her its scapegoat ,so she retired from the district while the getting was good.
It is interesting that after she left, her replacement boosted capital spending on infrastructure to support more housing development ( pump stations, sewer trunklines etc) egged on by the elected officials. It is not clear these houses will ever be built and if the infrastructure will ever be needed. Nor that the watershed can support any more houses while meeting its permit. But such is the behavior of empire at the end of its run.
BOOKKEEPING, A SITTING JOB, NO ERA NEVER NOT NEEDED.
ALL ERAS NEED BOOKKEEPERS.
JMG 284
> I certainly don’t plan on ever doing so [retire]
Likewise here.
Jethro and I don’t plan to ever retire. We have no choice, if we want to live. The world does NOT owe us a living. Work or die.
I am the bookkeeper of our LLC, plus perform other preparations and supports for Jethro’s making of Gustav Stickley-motivated furniture.
I am learning plenty about bookkeeping. Lately when anyone asks what I do, I say “student of bookkeeping.” I likely will be doing and studying it until I keel over.
Bookkeeping is “applied arithmetic”; it doesn’t need more than + – × ÷, as far as I see. Algebra maybe, I suppose. I had the best EVER algebra teacher, 1965, old school. If a student got uppity, one got an iron poke in the soft shoulder muscle by her 75-year old stiff finger of Miss G, which elicited an “Ow” every time. If anyone ever needs to solve a problem involving two parallel train tracks, I am your go-to woman‼️
BOOKKEEPING AS WORKING-CLASS WORK
I consider bookkeeping to be a working-class job,— a job that has clout and future.
In the hobby of genealogy, now and again I come across the occupation of “bookkeeper” of a man during the late 1800s, say 1860. I then find the man in the 1870, 1880, 1892, 1900 censuses, and invariably, it is the one occupation that led a man to prosperity over his working life. (By the way, back then, it was never a woman.)
Bookkeeping was (and is) a “sitting down” occupation, so for people currently in the age group I aforementioned, born late 1960s to mid-1980s, switching now to learning bookkeeping would be a GREAT idea. Or at least learn (or do) bookkeeping on-the-side, preparing for a 2nd-career. And use software called “MoneyWorks” by Cognito (New Zealand).
One thing about bookkeepers: there are never enough of them. Not one era is there enough of them. If they are any good (including being honest, keeping people’s secrets, returning phone calls, and having a home-office), brand-new bookkeepers putting out their shingle (micro-business startup) are snapped up fast; within three years, they have all the clientele they can handle, and have to close their practice to newcomers (unless a client dies or moves away). Bookkeepers are all age-groups. One can easily be 50, and be a bookkeeper.
In the 1980s, I used to be a bookkeeper. In the ensuing thirty years, I forgot everything. A couple years ago, I started up again, and it was rough. Rough on my ego too. I hadn’t exercised those little gray cells in decades. Bookkeeping is mentally challenging.
I acquired a profusion of used books on the subject, resulting in a decent library to consult when I get stumped. I had enjoyed doing bookkeeping in the 1980s and enjoy it now.
BOOKKEEPERS HAVE POWER!
💨🪑🔢💨Northwind Grandma
Dane County, Wisconsin, USA
JMG: Odd things about gender relations? That normally well-ordered and harmonious sphere? Heaven forfend! 😉
Christopher henningsen: “…people who think that consciousness is an irrelevant hallucination created by evolution for no obvious purpose…”
There are people who think that? How strange. Why would natural selection ever do that? About any feature of an organism? As a side effect sure, but that’s one heckuva side effect! Do these people suggest what might have been the intentional feature that also produced this side effect?
Anyway, that whole topic you’re writing about is very interesting. I’d love to read any follow up to that.
For context: I wrote an app to listen to my guitar and provide live bass and keys backing while I play, and now I think there’s a spirit that jams with me through it.
Mary B. # 261:
I think “New Right Wing Youth” here isn’t exactly the same you’ve depicted, but I also distrust its incoherent ideology…In the short term, there’s a heck of young people here whose fondness to right and far right ideas can be depicted fastly in “how lovely were the ‘80s and especially ‘90s, when white straight males ruled our country”. Of course, these Millenials never researched seriously those old good times dirty “secrets”…They usually fill their ideology with quite economic Neoliberalism and a growing anti-woke attitude in usual cultural wars (the opposite of one bad idea…).
Northwind @ 291: Well, I don’t agree. I’ve been looking up words when I encounter them for many decades. Yes, it interrupts the flow somewhat. But after a while you get a pretty good vocabulary. You notice when someone is using a big word (sometimes incorrectly) simply to be impressive. You notice when there’s a better word choice that a writer could have made. One of the writers who sent me to the dictionary most often, oddly enough, was Jim Harrison. I probably never would have looked up “otiose” were it not for Harrison.
@JMG:
“I freely grant that anyone outside the top 10% of income has no hope of retiring. I certainly don’t plan on ever doing so — and I didn’t need a stochastic parrot to clue me in.”
No doubt, but some people get a lot out of seeing the math. Math doesn’t lie; there’s no “but there’s gotta be a way…”
Anyway thanks for humouring me; I won’t post about stochastic parrots again.
JMG: “Laurent, that sounds hilarious. I don’t imagine there was a novel…”
I checked, and indeed, the film is based on a novel, “Les Bêtes curieuses” (1980) from Jean-Marc Roberts, an author I had never heard of.
Cynthia C. # 270:
“Men who do have empathy towards women may tend to feel that “Man vs Bear” is an unfair attack on them. To them I say, men should police each other better (and teach their sons better) regarding behaviour towards women, so women don’t have a reason to say stuff like that.”
Yes, it seems a reasonable strategy, but I think this attitude within men with empathy toward women may arrive too late, because for a lot of mainstream feminists (at least here), straight European men haven’t pressumption of innocence anymore, so they’ re seen like potential sexual predators, unless they show clearly and enphatically their opposite intention. It’s interesting to notice some feminists here are doing their best to equate punishment for every supposed sexual suggestion from men to women like a real rape attempt (so everything is the same). By the way, personally, I’m quite tired of being the usual “whip boy” for every badf things in our society, in the past, present and maybe future. And not every straight young man here is patient and smart enough for not going into the far right siren chants…
***********************************
“Is there a Spanish language dub of that? You should see that if you haven’t, it’s really funny!”
I’m afraid there isn’t any dub here nor in another Spanish language country. Maybe it’s a pity.
————————————————————-
Gerry # 287:
Thanks for your comments. It seems rodeos are to some extent an interracial entertainment/risk sport there in USA…
You see Republican politicians like Josh Hawley and Riley Moore attending a Teamsters convention today:
https://www.ft.com/content/41c034ba-ef09-4056-860c-91015a9c41dc
As a Brazilian I’m worried about this game of chairs in America because one way to solve elite overproduction in the imperial core is to remove local colonial elites and that removal is always violent and this violence hits all the colony, not just the elite.
I see Trump’s hostility to my country, like supporting exiled malcontents, threatening sanctions, applying tariffs against one the few country’s the US has a positive net balance, as a preparation for some kind of hostile takeover of the top positions in Brasil, eliminating local elites and replacing them with Ivy League gringos. Even though I’m not elite these elite replacement actions always spiral out of control and produce massive fallout, like the way the Romans slowly absorbed their allies.
The question is: can the US pull that or it’s too late? I don’t know. They got their ass handed to them by the Iranians and Hezbollah is stopping Israel once more and there buys time to the rest of the world.
“In the clinic I notice a significant difference in overall health between people who take a walk every day, and people who don’t. ”
‘Two miles a day keeps the doctor away’ has been my motto for a few years now.
Such a great read! I’m sorry for being so late to the discussion but I was wondering, would we be headed towards universal basic income first before this crumbles apart?
@NW Grandma #291
When I was in university (back in the Jurassic Era!), I was always taught, when writing term papers, to spell out unfamiliar acronyms (upon first usage), and then put the acronym itself in parentheses.
Now some acronyms (e.g., AIDS) are familiar enough the this treatment is not needed. However, when in doubt, I spell it out first, then use the acronym thereafter.
Luddite 288
> I went to a bio kineticist and her exercises has gotten me some way to recovery but not all the way.
May I be so bold as to suggest investigating the trade of bookkeeping?
It is working-class, one of the few where one sits; over decades (perhaps centuries), there are never enough bookkeepers worldwide; as a micro-business, a person is one’s own boss; it is quite mentally challenging; bookkeepers don’t come cheap. There are tons of pluses.
💨🔢💨Northwind Grandma
Dane County, Wisconsin, USA
Strangeness over on dreamwidth – cannot expand any comments at all and if try to post something to say about that, the page is redirected to the digital hellscape known as Captcha Loop.
Off topic but seems like watching the internet become more and more unusable… I read that nearly 40% of old web 1 sites are now gone – I used to wonder that the last image as the public internet finally went dark would be of a cat fading to grey, but I’ve changed my thinking – the last interactions for people will be tapping pictures of bicycles, hydrants and buses as the last sparks of consciousness finally turn within and either flare and expand like a bursting star, gutter like a candle and blink out, or implode in madness on some captcha event horizon that passes as digital purgatory.
This should probably have waited until tomorrow’s open post, but thinking on those potentials prompted by dreamwidth troubles just mentioned, the musical chairs in your essay are not the only versions being played. To win at the internet version of musical chairs, one needs to be able to turn away and not take a seat. Or perhaps the internet version is more like the pied piper story.
As for ‘the rise of cancel culture’ I wonder if ‘internet access culture’ will take over.
I have already seen talk of hardware authentication and digital ID acting as gateways through which the ‘clean’ may pass into the citadel.
2-Factor authentication made so simple and convenient, just place a thumb on your phone ID spot and look into the camera for retinal scan and Transcendence(TM) is immediately granted according to the social credit score of the human drone attempting access.
Human drone you say? Say what?
The internet is the astral of the materialist – the intermediate zone of illusion,. and the tech bros idea of uploading their consciousness to a machine (‘downloading’ may be more apposite) is nothing more that a castrated dream playing out as consciousness spirals between oblivion and wider reality.
In some ways human drone class refers to humanity who have chosen to worship self and disregard all else and distinguished by a narrowing of perception alongwith rigidity brittleness and narrowed horizons. But In actual fact, it is not a ‘class’ as such, it is a potential that we all have – in the blink of an eye we can all become drones, and another blink can see us unfold potential. Drone is just a useful term right now in this age of machines. so droneness is people choosing to act like machines rather than living beings.
The internet itself is psychic fly-paper – trapping consciousness in what actually seems a gateway for a hybridised sub-realm.
Reading that some young people are turning away and back to things like books, actual conversation, and doing things in the world rather than living online and wading through increasing llm slop.
Perhaps the internet and the devices are a filter for consciousness, a wake-up test, or simply indicate a direction of travel – for simplicity’s sake – spiral down into the ever denser material interface and ultimate stasis – like flies in amber, or spiral up into the ever more immaterial. Not that they are actually up and down of course – the whole thing is a paradox wrapped in mysterious reflections and enfolded in a cosmic whoopee cushion.
Directions of travel can change of course, but it gets harder if we keep digging in the holes we are already in.
😉
[earthworm]
Anybody ever read the scifi book Market Forces by Richard Morgan?
“Set in 2049, the story follows Chris Faulkner as he starts his new job as a junior executive at Shorn Associates, working in their Conflict Investment division where the company supports foreign governments in exchange for a percentage of the country’s gross domestic product. Contracts are awarded, and promotions are given to employees, through driving duels in which combatants race vehicles on empty roads and often kill their opponents. With the Shorn-supported Colombian dictator Echevarria expected to transfer power to his son, who is supported by a competing firm, Chris allies Shorn with a rebel group to overthrow the government, though other executives attempt to sabotage his plans.”
What I remember is how the people trying to climb up the corporate ladder have brutal competitions with each other to secure their spots… they literally played a game of removing chairs in the office to force each other to be more cut throat in the office.
I was reminded of the book by seeing a post by substacker Mary-Kate Ultra who also wrote about musical chairs:
“Human existence feels like a relentless game of musical chairs where the seats are constantly yanked out from under us. The daily struggle for survival forces a jarring rhythm where people cannot afford to hold a spot for anyone else. It keeps everyone moving in a cycle of self preservation, a discordant chorus revealing how human nature defaults to self interest even though the soul desires symphony.”
https://substack.com/home/post/p-202902595
Christopher, that’s very odd. Myself, I tend to think that everything is conscious, including LLMs; the question in my mind is where the consciousness inhabiting LLMs comes from, and whether it might be more clearly described in the language of demonology than in that of computer science.
Chris, I figure it was a “thumping win” for Labour purely because it gave them another dutiful nonentity to shove into the prime minister’s chair now that Starmer’s passed his pull date. If Burnham had lost, they would definitely have been up the river of excreta without a hand-operated impeller. Crazy days indeed!
Aldarion (if I may), thank you — you may have just given me a detail of some importance. As long as doctors routinely married nurses and businessmen often married secretaries, there was a viable route for common sense to trickle up from the wage class into the salary class, via mothers raised in less affluent circumstances who succeeded in marrying up. Once that stopped, the salary class was unmoored from reality and proceeded to go spinning off into a La-La Land of its own creation.
Mary, of course! Human beings have instincts, and many of them go in inconvenient directions.
Scotlyn, that’s not uncanny, it’s deliberate policy. Without a steady influx of immigrants to push up the population, overinflated real estate prices would begin to slump, and notional real estate values are most of what keep the banks in the US and most of the rest of the industrial world from going broke in a hurry. The foreign policies in question are subservient to that desperate need.
Clay, thanks for this. I freely grant that the Clean Water Act as originally envisaged was a valuable thing. Still, we all know where you get by following a road paved with good intentions.
Northwind, that does indeed deserve to be in capital letters. Bookkeeping has been a steady gig since ancient Sumerian times — museums have clay-tablet ledgers from those days — and it’s completely skill-dependent; if you can do it well, you’ll have a job. I can testify to this, as Sara’s steady work as a bookkeeper is why I was able to launch a writing career.
Bofur, oh, don’t mind me. I’m just waving my cane and shouting “You robots get off my lawn!”
Laurent, thank you! I’ll look for a copy.
Anon, yep. It’s the next stage in the rise of the populist Right.
Luciano, nah, that’s what happens when you combine elite overproduction with a secure elite class in the imperial center, so that driving out unnecessary elite-candidate groups to the colonial periphery is a way to maintain stability at the center. Now? The center cannot hold, and the rising elite class has zero interest in giving those Ivy League gringos anything more prestigious than a shovel and a ditch to dig. No, what you have to worry about is Trump et al. trying to replace your current government with something local but more aligned with his agenda. Can he do it? Good question.
Jane, almost certainly not. Oh, it may well be promised — “Just as soon as the AIs finish creating Utopia, cross our hearts!” — but it won’t happen.
Dreamwidth, I know. They did some upgrades, with the usual disastrous results. My guess is that you’re almost right. The last image as the internet goes dark will be a Captcha screen telling everyone to click on the bicycles, but there are no bicycles in the image and when you click on a square all it does is put in another square without bicycles…
Justin, hmm! Sounds like an updated Pohl & Kornbluth novel.
Cosmic Whoopee Cushion – That sound… I do not think it means what you think it means
https://imgflip.com/i/av061h
“but there are no bicycles in the image and when you click on a square all it does is put in another square without bicycles…”
Hahaha… that is on a Lovecraftian level of horror!
Salary class whining from academia;
“A survey conducted by science news website STAT found that more than half of researchers with grants from the NIH—once a reliable source of $40 billion a year—reported some level of disruption to their funding: a total freeze, a delay in disbursement or a reduction in amount. And 81 percent of researchers in tenure-track positions said they were concerned that funding disruptions could affect their productivity enough to jeopardize their chances of getting tenure.”
The full article is paywalled at Scientific American.
Looking for my very small violin…
Chuaquin: Those are valid points regarding how some women make a much bigger deal about unwanted romantic overtures than is warranted, and about how you and others are tired of being the whipping boy. Of course y’all are tired of it; that absolutely is happening and it stinks. I think both these things are a result of salary class dominance giving that class the ability to chisel out a sinecure for every daughter of the salary class regardless of how empty-headed and otherwise unskilled she might be, in combination with the natural biological tendency of women not to date down. I predict that this regrettable phenomenon will go away along with salary class dominance. Which is good, but is probably cold comfort for the majority of males who had the misfortune to be born in this terrible age. That I see and agree with the point of “Man vs Bear” is notwithstanding all of that.
I wonder if I would have seen how base humans really are in the romantic sphere if I were born in a different age, or if I would have believed in soul mates and other romantic bovine shale. (bovine shale = mentiras) I suppose I’ll get the answer next incarnation, but I won’t remember the question.
Oh, and about “far right”… Seems like you don’t have to go very far in that direction to get that label! Maybe I’m far right. I believe in voter ID. I think illegal immigrants should be deported. I think we should admit only immigrants who have skills that are lacking here. I think men and women are different. I think both of those are non-fungible biological categories. Definitely into far right territory according to some people.
I like Pohl & Kornbluth, so yeah, that’s a fair assessment and probably why I liked that novel.
Someday, all the vast inputs keeping chicken little alive will have to give ; )
earthworm 293
> I inadvertently started doing it having to walk the three miles home from school in the rain or snow for some years…
And were both directions uphill?
💨⛰💨Northwind Grandma
Dane County, Wisconsin, USA
Anonymous 306
> Josh Hawley and the future of pro-worker conservatism
Josh Hawley is making a big bet on the future of the Republican Party. The Missouri senator is staking his career (and maybe a White House bid) on the notion that GOP should mean what it says about becoming a ~workers’~ party”…
‼️Wow. Awesome. I wish Hawley luck‼️
💨👏🏼💪🏼🪚🏚️🔢💨Northwind Grandma
Dane County, Wisconsin, USA
@Bofur #277
“I don’t find these off-topic at all, at all; there’s a very direct line between these anecdotes and the OP’s bit about how some folk are going to find themselves positioned.”
Oh certainly! Pardon me, I wasn’t referring to your post at all, I simply meant I was about to go off on a tangent that would have qualified as off-topic, but thought better of it. Thus far, I’m pretty sure the discussion has stayed fairly relevant, and as far as I can tell JMG seems to agree with this, putting our posts through as he does. The article mentions LLMs as they apply specifically to this issue of the hollowing out of the salary class, so mentioning them in that context should be perfectly fine.
As to your anecdote, well that’s a bit more on the nose than I was expecting 🙂 Still, that more or less lines up with my limited experience interacting with LLMs. It is very difficult to get the model to respond in a way that contradicts the worldview outlined in its training data. However, even a metaphorical rubber duck can be valuable in these situations. If the experience provides you with valuable insights, then all the better! Best of luck with your continued research, good sir.
Jane 309
> universal basic income first before this crumbles apart?
Rather than attempt to garner free stuff “freebies” (sucking off others’ labors), might you start up your own micro-business?
Freebies are going away. No more freebies. No more handouts.
Do you have a special interest where you could make yourself useful? I will throw some things to the universe to, perhaps, jog a memory?
Cooking
Sewing
Dog walker
Go-fer, general “go for this, go for that” “gopher” (you have an errand? I will do it for you.)
Grocery shopper (you have foods to buy? I will buy them for you.)
Appointment keeper/driver? (you have an appointment? I will drive you.)
Hospital hand-holder (you have a loved one in the hospital, and you can’t be there all the time. I will sit with her.)
Hustle.
“Make yourself useful” is what my antecedents used to say.
One can make oneself useful even ‘while sitting.’ Even someone wheelchair-bound can knit, mend, or crochet.
Mending is in high-demand. Mending is getting more popular over time. A sideline off mending is ‘beauty-mending,’ making the garment more attractive than it was ‘before the rend’.
Work hard.
💨🍳🪡👖🏥🚗✈️💨Northwind Grandma
Dane County, Wisconsin, USA
dreamwidth trouble 312
> old web 1 sites
Around 2002, I learned Web 1.0 html. It was 100% a joy. I could do it myself, one fifty-year old. I remember the day I discovered Cascading Style Sheets (CSS). I could put together a website myself. I used static images, usually using clipart.
Then “the computing industry” got complicated; by 2015, the situation was that only teams of professionals could produce a website at the cost of hundreds-of-thousands of dollars. Frankly, the vast majority of websites written after 2015 are fluff and boring.
This autumn, I (and one assistant, making it “we”) (not Jethro; he has enough to do): We will be putting together a Web 2.0 e-commerce as-applied-to-Wordpress website, selling Jethro’s handmade furniture. If I remember correctly, Web 2.0 was when CSS emerged. We will take advantage of CSS/Wordpress.
No fancy anything. Keep it simple. Relatively inexpensive. No huge tens-of-thousands of dollar budget. The written word will be gospel, with secondary clipart images as well as artwork composites we do ourselves using software like PhotoSlop and Affinitee (lots of choice here). Primarily, Jethro and I will be putting money towards writing—good writing, if not ‘great’ writing, the sort of writing exhibited here among the commentariat.
I hope we design the website to have a humble feel. Hokey. Hootenanny. Humourous. Worth reading for the fun of it, in an educational way. Offbeat. Atypical. Sometimes strange. Occasionally edgy. Amateurish will be an attractant. At least this is how I envision it.
Web 2.0 is a keeper. There is no reason NOT to use Web 2.0. It still works. In its simplicity, Web 2.0 is elegant and classic. Even a 74-year old can ‘partly’-hatch a Web 2.0 website. I recoil from overblown websites made (typically) of ephemeral-video — they su_k.
Just sharin’.
💨👩🏼💻👴🏼👨🏼💻💨Northwind Grandma
Dane County, Wisconsin, USA
Justin Patrick Moore 314
> Human existence feels like a relentless game of musical chairs where the seats are constantly yanked out from under us.
Gee, this describes my childhood. This way of putting it is succinct. Excellent way to put it.
I was just thinking about this aspect of my growing up. I would settle on one thing, then it got torn away, leaving me, shall I say, bereft. I would start to acclimatize, then THAT rug was pulled out from under me, leaving me again, bereft. It happened a lot. I would describe it as sad. I barely hung on. I fell often. I believe it is called “falling through the cracks.” The end product, at least through age 18, was that my schoolwork suffered where it was all I could do to keep a “C” average. I have wondered since what kind of experiences my contemporaries had, at the time, kids I knew, particularly the ones who got As.
I guess the kids who got As were where their parents hadn’t divorced; lived in a home where the resulting parent didn’t favor alcohol more than her children; where one didn’t have to breathe second-hand smoke for 18 years; where screaming-and-yelling was the norm; where one had no privacy; where one had a clean, well-lighted place to study.
I guess some kids had those things, but I venture they were in the minority. And are.
Such is life. May children have better lives than I describe here.
💨✨💨Northwind Grandma
Dane County, Wisconsin, USA
Aldarion # 295:
“In Brazil, there was a brutal saying “mixed-race women for fun, white women for marrying”. It’s not entirely different for some very progressive salaried people today, you just have to substitute class instead of race!”
Well, Brazil, like another South American countries, has lived during centuries an evident races mixing process…but you can see usually in most of those countries, upper classes are indistinguishable of their USA and Europe equal upper classes. Even in the most “indigenous” or “African origin” countries, it seems “criollos” on the top of social, political and economic pyramid, are “whiter”than middle and of course, worker class there. For example, returning to Brazil, that country has never had a black or at least a clearly “non white” president…I think this is a endogamic attitude and behavior within those elites, and I agree that, with some local “colors”, can be applied to Western middle-high and upper classes, more or less identified with JMG idea of “salary class”.
———————————————————————————————–
Mary B. # 296:
Oh, beavers…European beavers returned again to some Spanish rivers some years ago, thanks to some illegal beavers releases (without our government permission), made by a few foreign ecologists (Ahem). Beavers were hunted into extinction more or less 5 or 6 centuries ago here, so govt had a bizarre trouble: they weren’t another “invader” species, because there are historical records about them in the Middle Age here; but they were not welcome migrants (they sometimes cut down fruit trees near rivers). So their status is very strange, though they’re ironically a “new” protected species, their hunt is forbidden.
It’s very interesting beavers in Spain don’t build any dam, like another European or American beavers, because our rivers (due to Mediterranean climate) haven’t water enough, especially in summer, to allow them. So, these beavers here usually dig a deep hole in high banks along rivers; then they dig a “skylight” when they stop their hole, and finally they hide very well the two holes alike with branches.
I think this is a good example of a plan B within a non human animal…Indeed, beavers can fit themselves to a different environment, changing their behavior to a better adaptation.
——————————————————————————————
Jane # 309:
According the former intel officer and thinker Col. Pedro Baños, we would go soon or later toward a widespread UBI for the worker class and part of middle class in western countries, due to full implementation of LLM and digitalization in general. Unemployment for everybody! (except for elites and some near-slavery hard workers). It’s interesting he isn’t very happy with his prediction, so he disagrees from usual leftists who support UBI as solution for everybody problems in a near future. He points UBI could be a low subsidy (not much money) to prevent “deplorable” people starve nor attack elites, but no more than this (charity). In addition to this grim future scenary, Mr. Baños thinks people below “digitalized” hi tech elites, would be under a heavy entertainment industry. So he depicts that likely future remembering old Roman saying “Panem et circenses”(Bread and Circus). UBI and Netflix?
Of course, Mr. Baños knows he can write and say certain things, but he’s not an stupid to disturb their former bosses in Counterinteligence and another factic powers…So let’s be careful with his statements. Apparently, he isn’t very aware of the Long Descent, or maybe he thinks there will be a “full digital society” before the decline speeds up. I haven’t enough information about his ideas in this topic.
————————————
JMG # 315:
“No, what you have to worry about is Trump et al. trying to replace your current government with something local but more aligned with his agenda. Can he do it? Good question.”
I’m not a Brazilian, but I can remember there was a President of Brazil, named Jair Bolsonaro, who fitted in the usual South American Conservative or Far Right typical authoritarian leader (I don’t know exactly where to label him). It seems he’s lived better days after his presidency (cough), but it isn’t impossible a new political copycat rises again in a near future, especially if he’s supported by Trump or his sucessor as POTUS…even by rough means (ahem).
According what I usually see in “social” media and MSM in my country, it seems most of “feminist men” come near always from middle-high class or upper class; meanwhile, middle-low class and worker class men (especially young adults) tend to be more and more under the spelling of the far right siren chants…”White” straight men demonization by some mainstream feminists and massive migration are IMHO, the favorite far right tricks to make those men vote them or even join their party.
I bet (to some extent), elites men and middle-high class men can give themselves the “luxury” of being “feminists”, because they’ve never had problems with women in their privileged jobs and relationships. In addition to this, I grasp mainstream feminism (at least here) is “casually” led by pedantocrats from universities and another privileged women, who hate especially “low level” men, so…do the math. Are elites “feminist” men faking their pose? I write this opinion as work hypothesis.
*****************************
By the way, today I’ve seen a poster in the street, put by some fringe far left freaks. Oops! They call for revolution (well, I bet they won’t have a massive answer to join their proletarian “army”, because near every youngs are busy with their smartphones). The funniest thing I read there: they propose an unlikely revolution for achieving women full liberation, LGTBI final freedom and finally the struggle of classes. OK, they’ve written last Marxist term the last one, it seems like they near missed it (ahem). I mean, far left nowadays sometimes remembers in the last moment old Karl teachings, but after having calling for “fighting” their favorite “beings of light”, according woke doctrine…
@ Leondarrell # 11
I think I saw a photo of the Obama building on ‘The Onion’ and just thought they were making a great joke. That thing is horrendous! I’m telling you, while it didn’t start with it, computers definitely accelerated bad design. It is the worst thing to ever happen to architecture, it made terrible designs feel reasonable when on a screen.
@ Jill C #14
Can I just say, thank you for teaching Yoga right. So many places have striped it of it foundations and just turned it into nothing more than stretching.
If done right it can become a contemplative situation. For those at the top of the house of cards they should worry because those that hold it up will just walk away when they get a chance to see just how much they are being screwed. You have done this just right by the sounds of it.
Be well.
Before the comments close, it might be worth pointing out that at least in its early stages the salary class takeover was good for the wage class as well. An argument can be made that, between support for unions, progressive taxation, strictly regulated financial institutions, and the not incidental fact of the rest of the world’s economies being reduced to rubble, the average American worker from roughly 1940-1960 reached the peak of prosperity. It was, ironically, liberal icon JFK that started disassembling the New Deal and so started the long slow decline of the working class.
To the Anon who keeps on trying to post pro-LLM walls of text here: I moderate all comments personally. If your attempted comments keep getting deleted, why, maybe there’s a reason for that, and if you read the paragraph above the comment window you might figure out what it is.
@chuaquin re Brazilian presidents: Lula is usually categorized as non-white in Brazil, more exactly as nordestino, which means a degree of indigenous ancestry (though maybe not black). One of Jair Bolsonaro’s sons is standing as candidate for president and has done all in his power to get Trump’s support.
“And were both directions uphill?”
Ah, you know that road then… I used to dream about having shoes; things got better after three years or so when I got baskets to tie to my feet… but we were lucky:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DT1mGoLDRbc